4 ms·
Interesting. It's still unclear whether Strauss was assuming Jevon's Paradox would not strike, or whether he was expecting / hoping for our ability to move beyo
by masklinn 7y ago
Interesting. It's still unclear whether Strauss was assuming Jevon's Paradox would not strike, or whether he was expecting / hoping for our ability to move beyond energy (or at least electricity) scarcity.
- ghaff 7y agoYou have to think given the context he believed (or at least claimed to believe) in post-electricity scarcity. It's hard to imagine that anyone would seriously think electricity demand wouldn't rise significantly as the efficiency of producing it grew. In fact, I can imagine a stronger effect with electricity than with many other things.
- dTal 7y agoI would expect the demand for energy to be more insatiable than any other commodity because all commodities require energy to create. The only two end-user forms of energy readily available are electricity and fossil fuels. I imagine that electricity consumption will rise with supply in the same way any life multiplies up to the capacity of its food source.
- ghaff 7y agoFurthermore, if you have an essentially unlimited supply of electricity, you immediately start changing processes, materials, etc. to favor electrical assumption over other costs.
- swagasaurus-rex 7y agoIs the end result life that consumes the majority of the energy produced (dyson spheres come to mind) to create massively more monolithic and efficient economies, converting enormous amounts of raw material into civilization? What would make this different than the postulated grey goo scenario, whereinstead man and machine are the ultimate exponential replicators?
- mjw1007 7y agoThe context was « enjoy in their homes electrical energy too cheap to meter ». I suppose it's not implausible that household energy use could become so small compared to industrial use that it's not worth metering (so that that there'd be a maximum power deliverable but nobody would care about the household's load profile).
- plankers 7y agoYeah, seems that the speaker wasn't considering the law of induced demand[1]. Dang humans: thirsty and miserable, always wanting more. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand
- Retric 7y agoElectricity still has limits based on wire gage. If the cost of maintaining the distribution network vastly exceeds the cost of generation, it may not be worth the billing hassle vs simply paying for the size of the pipe. Arguably it’s simply another case where someone judges a technology by the wrong metrics. If fuel represented a similar relative cost in nuclear and coal power plants, nuclear really would have been vastly cheaper.
- masklinn 7y ago> Electricity still has limits based on wire gage. If the cost of maintaining the distribution network vastly exceeds the cost of generation, it may not be worth the billing hassle vs simply paying for the size of the pipe. Distributing the generation makes this less of an issue, you still need connection between the regions for balancing and load-shedding, but one can imagine that had civilian nuclear been more of a focus local and hyperlocal SMR would be old-hat rather than experiments.