4 ms·
That sounds odd to me that any site would own the copyright to lyrics. Wouldnt that be the artist / record company's property? The value add of Genius isnt so
by giancarlostoro 7y ago
That sounds odd to me that any site would own the copyright to lyrics. Wouldnt that be the artist / record company's property?
The value add of Genius isnt so much in the lyrics but in the explanation and context given grom Genius. I have even seen actual artists confirm interpretations and explain some things as well I think Hittman from Dr. Dre's 2001 album was one such artist if I remember correctly.
I do see what you are saying on the other hand but I dont think that lyrics written down from a song are some random websites copyright / property.
- buckminster 7y agoThe lyrics belong to the artist or publisher and lyric sites need a licence from them.
- baby 7y agoI always hated this. It's been historically hard to get easy access to lyrics of songs you've bought! It always made no sense to me that you couldn't publish lyrics of songs.
- Borealid 7y agoI think legally you likely have not "bought" a song, you have licensed it. The license includes the right to listen to the song, but not to redistribute either the music or the lyrics. "Ownership" such as it is for intellectual property is still with the copyright holder(s), which is why it makes sense that you don't have the same rights you would if it were truly "your" song.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- acjohnson55 7y agoTo add a little nuance to this, there are two copyrights at play here, the song and the recording. The songwriter (who may or may not be one of the performers) originally owns the rights to the song, but often sells them to a publishing company. The lyrics pertain to the song. The recording is made with a mechanical license to the rights of the song, and a CD is distributed with a license to the recording (owned by the band, unless they recorded as a work-for-hire for their their record label, which is typical). As a listener, you either own a physical product that happens to have been made with those licenses, or you're listening to a performance, if you're streaming. Neither of these things give you further rights with the song or recording. This stuff is pretty wacky, and I may have some of those details wrong. I took a class in music industry law a decade ago
- colejohnson66 7y agoMaybe in the context of streaming, but when you buy a CD, AFAIK, you own the copy, but there are limits on what you can do with it because of copyright laws; Just because I own something, doesn’t mean I can make a copy and give it away. That
- ceejayoz 7y ago> It always made no sense to me that you couldn't publish lyrics of songs. Why? It's pretty much a poem.
- eropple 7y agoPoems are under copyright and can't be reproduced without permission, either.
- ceejayoz 7y ago... That's my point? That they're equally copyrightable?
- wilg 7y agoIt's an annoying thing because you basically always already have rights to listen to the song, but there is no easy way to get the lyrics as text.
- kayfox 7y ago>> It's been historically hard to get easy access to lyrics of songs you've bought! The ones printed in the booklet that came with the CD or encoded in the mp3 file?
- baby 7y agoI seldom saw lyrics in a booklet. Maybe because I was living in France?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jjeaff 7y agoI think the main value they add is working to agreggate all the lyrics into one site. If Google is simply scraping that content from them without permission then that has been litigated many times in court and almost always comes out badly for the "scraper".
- DevKoala 7y agoGoogle uses the lyrics to link you to Google Music, so they end up profiting from the content they scrapped. Honestly if it was any small business doing this, there would be no harm, but considering Google can place themselves at the top of the search results for lyrics, then it is shady. They basically take Genius content, rank Genius low in the results and place themselves at the top.
- slg 7y agoThe same issue also comes up a lot when dealing with data that can't be copyrighted. For example stock quotes, sports statistics, and maps are all statements of fact and therefore no one can copyright them. However you still have to end up either gathering the information yourself or licensing it from a data provider. Simply scraping it off someone else who has already done one of those two is a quick way to get into legal trouble.