4 ms·
In some cases not speaking to the Police can damage your defence later, though.
by chrisseaton 7y ago
In some cases not speaking to the Police can damage your defence later, though.
- DenisM 7y agoSuch as?
- chrisseaton 7y agoSuch as if you had an alibi that you try to use as a defence in court but you didn't mention it when questioned by Police in the first place. This can cast doubt on the alibi - presumably because people will think you made it up later and if it was true you should have been able to say so in the first place. > it may harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned something which you later rely on in court https://www.gov.uk/arrested-your-rights https://www.gov.uk/arrested-your-rights
- the_snooze 7y agoI think what everyone is getting at is that you should refuse any questioning at all, full stop.
- chrisseaton 7y agoYes I know - but the problem with that is that when you get to court and try to defend yourself, your defence will be weaker because you didn't answer questions at the time. It's bad advice.
- the_snooze 7y agoNo, your defense will be weaker if you talk because the prosecution will use your words against you. They're not going to give you virtue points for being kind to them and not bothering them with things like asserting your right to an attorney. That's not their job. That's exactly what defense attorneys and police themselves advise. https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/mvkgnp/law-professor-police-interrogation-law-constitution-survival https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/mvkgnp/law-professor-poli...
- chrisseaton 7y agoWell the law in some jurisdictions says explicitly > it may harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned something which you later rely on in court As in the jury are allowed to take into account the fact that you did not reveal information at the first opportunity as a negative.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- erispoe 7y agoThat's something that your solicitor would know and advise on. There is still no reason to talk to the police without an attorney/solicitor present.
- astura 7y agoOnly if you aren't human. On the other hand... >You might make mistakes when explaining where you were at the time of a crime that the police interpret as lies; the officer talking to you could misremember what you say much later https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/mvkgnp/law-professor-police-interrogation-law-constitution-survival https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/mvkgnp/law-professor-poli...
- Retra 7y agoBut if you do mention it and make any kind of error, that seems likely to be used against you as well.
- blck 7y agoOr it gives the cops time to poke holes in your alibi or otherwise intimidate your alibi if the cops are dead set on you being the guilty person. Better to tell a lawyer your alibi so he can collect the information first so that he’s not blindsided later. This is if you can afford a lawyer who can work with you quickly. If you’re poor and you think your alibi is strong enough to let you go immediately then it might be better.
- Nextgrid 7y agoTo be fair, you are quoting an UK site where the at least a semblance of justice actually exists, unlike the US where “justice” is just a business.
- dang 7y agoPlease keep nationalistic flamebait far away from this site. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- Nextgrid 7y agoThis wasn’t intended to be nationalistic, I was just sharing my thoughts on the US justice system which I believe is deeply flawed. I mentioned the UK because that’s what the parent comment linked to but it could’ve easily been another country (except the ones where the situation is even worse, which there aren’t too many of thankfully). Feel free to edit/delete my post if you think it will improve the overall discussion.
- dang 7y agoI'm sure it wasn't your intent, but unfortunately most flamewars get started unintentionally. Think of this as fire safety.
- backpropaganda 7y agoWhat you're saying and what's in the link seems to be consistent with the advice of refusing to talk to the police at all, and not to talk partially or to answer some questions and not answer other questions, or answering but changing the statement later.
- DenisM 7y agoYou should have mentioned that you're talking about the UK in your original statement. The fact that you did not may be used against you in the furtherance of this discussion. In the US we have the fifth amended, and it seems that [1] as long as it explicitly invokes the protection one would be safe from similar repercussions. https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/when-how-invoke-your-right-silence.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/when-how-invoke-your...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Dkastro92 7y agoWith today's technology I don't think you need to talk without a lawyer to better case your alibi. You have to remember that it is legal (USA) for the police to lie to you but not the other way around.
- JamesBarney 7y agoEvery defense attorney I've talked to says they've had a hundreds of cases where they wished their client hadn't talked to the cops. And they've never mentioned one where they wished their client had talked to the cops. Oh Chris you're from the UK. I think most people on this thread are assuming you're talking about the u.s. where you should absolutely not talk to the cops until a lawyer is present. It must work differently in the UK where either the cops and prosecutors are less aggressively trying to convict you no matter your innocence or guilt. Or not speaking to the cops is held against you far more.
- chrisseaton 7y agoIf you had a really rock-solid alibi - something that meant there was not even a remote possibility that you were the offender, would you still not bring it up at all to the Police? You'd go all the way to court, months later, and only then bring it up?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- TACIXAT 7y agoWhat if the police aren't questioning you about what they say? Your alibi can place you where they want to place you.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 7y agoIn the US: you don't ever talk to the police for any reason unless you have a lawyer with you telling you what to say. You're completely right about the UK though. If you didn't do it and police are asking if you did it it's normally much easier to just tell them that you didn't do it, and this has very little risk. The risk comes from people who have committed the offence, but who think that it's a minor issue and think that just explaining it to police will mean they can go. If the police stop you and you have a self-defence baseball bat in the boot of your car then you need to say "it's for playing baseball with the kids". As soon as you say "it's for self-defence, just to scare people off, I'd never hit anyone with it" that converts it into an offence and police are a bit touchy about weapons at the moment.