4 ms·
> It's entirely possible that the very smart people who think about aviation engineering all day are supremely convinced that some of the digital tests can abso
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> It's entirely possible that the very smart people who think about aviation engineering all day are supremely convinced that some of the digital tests can absolutely replace physical tests that were in place for decades. I'm not even remotely qualified enough to offer an opinion on that, so I won't.
This is really the foundation of the problem. Members of Congress are not aeronautical engineers, so they're in the same boat as you. Aeronautical engineers work for aircraft makers, so they have a conflict of interest.
Then, because they don't really know what they're doing, they tend to require things that reduce safety, either by requiring measures that aren't cost effective and thereby blow your entire budget including the money that could have been spent on other safety measures with better cost/benefit, or are overly rigid in requiring the specific solution to a problem which was the state of the art three decades ago when the rule was enacted even though safer alternatives are known today.
So why doesn't the government higher some regulators with some relevant industry experience? Well, they tried that, and then we got all of this revolving door nonsense where, to use an example closer to home here, former Verizon lawyer Ajit Pai is now running the FCC as a wholly owned subsidiary of Verizon Communications.
Then we get proposals to prevent regulators from going back to industry when they finish, to try to prevent that. But the government already has trouble attracting talent when they're paying substantially less than private industry does, and the jobs tend to only last for one administration until the next one comes in and replaces them with their own people, so how are they ever going to get anyone good to do a job that will a) pay less than they're making already and b) by law end their private career even though their tenure in government is likely to be less than a decade?
It's possible that we're better off not specifying how to make airplanes safe but instead imposing significant liability on companies and individual engineers who make ones that aren't. (This works in industries where the smallest company has a multi-billion dollar market cap. It's obviously less of a deterrent when the manufacturer has no exposure to the jurisdiction of your courts or is small enough to file bankruptcy every time there is a problem, but then we're no longer talking about Boeing and Airbus.)
- DougN7 7y ago> individual engineers who make ones that aren't Please don’t forget those engineers’ management chain. In my experience, it’s usually business people trying to change things for profit’s sake, not the engineers.
- samcday 7y agoYou make a compelling case as to why regulation can be problematic! I can't find any part of your assessment that I disagree with. What do you think about reforming how we regulate though? You point out that the revolving door problem stems from the fact that attracting the right people is hard when you're not offering them the right salary and career security. Surely there's ways to make that possible in the public sector! Given that regulatory bodies really ought to be non partisan and focused on a particular field or industry of activity, perhaps the institutional heads could be selected via a more democratic process (rather than just whichever buddy helped out an elected representative win their campaign) and given guaranteed minimum terms? And as to the problem of turnover throughout changes of political administration, isn't that perhaps also merely a policy problem? Why does the FCC or HUD need to be gutted and repopulated during a transition of political power? Those departments still have to report to the executive and congressional branches of government, so are their staffing choices something the White House should just be able to change on a whim?
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> You point out that the revolving door problem stems from the fact that attracting the right people is hard when you're not offering them the right salary and career security. Surely there's ways to make that possible in the public sector! It's actually pretty hard. The first problem is that if you paid them the amount it would take to attract good people, it's easy for opponents to score cheap political points by charging you with wasting tax dollars or comparing the high salary to that of unskilled workers. Meanwhile a high salary increases the perverse incentive to fill the position with cronies as a reward for political support, which is the opposite of helpful. There may be ways around it if you're creative, like making a benefit of the position that you and two generations of your descendants get free healthcare and college tuition / loan forgiveness forever (provided you do the job for at least two years). Then that's worth potentially quite a lot of money and provides a suitable incentive to attract good people, but makes it harder to take cheap shots because the total cost is indeterminate in both time and amount. Meanwhile you attract just the sort of experienced greybeard you want, who can do the job for a few years as the final leg of their career before retirement and in so doing provide financial security for their children and grandchildren. At which point it becomes sort of a meta problem, because to bring that about you need honest and creative people in the legislature to make good rules, which was kind of the original problem -- how do you get good and honest lawmakers and exclude incompetent and corrupt ones, when the people choosing them have insufficient time and expertise? > Given that regulatory bodies really ought to be non partisan and focused on a particular field or industry of activity, perhaps the institutional heads could be selected via a more democratic process (rather than just whichever buddy helped out an elected representative win their campaign) and given guaranteed minimum terms? Making them directly elected positions might help, but it's more like trading one set of problems for a different one. Now it's an elected position, but are random airline passengers going to care about who gets elected? (Boeing will, of course.) How do you get honest specialists who know what they're doing to even run, and how does a random voter tell the difference between that person and an industry shill prior to putting them in office? How do you prevent the foreseeable result when there is a disaster not long before an election and people elect a strongman to Do Something About It, only to ruin everything with bluster and incompetence? > And as to the problem of turnover throughout changes of political administration, isn't that perhaps also merely a policy problem? Why does the FCC or HUD need to be gutted and repopulated during a transition of political power? It's because they make policy. If a Democrat replaces Trump they're certainly not going to keep his head of the EPA. Giving them guaranteed terms that are of similar length to the President's doesn't strike me as something likely to change much in a helpful way -- and you still have the same issues in choosing who to select to begin with.
- chroma 7y ago> Well, they tried that, and then we got all of this revolving door nonsense where, to use an example closer to home here, former Verizon lawyer Ajit Pai is now running the FCC as a wholly owned subsidiary of Verizon Communications. That's not true at all. He worked at Verizon for 2 years (2001-2003). Almost all of the other 20 years of his career have been at various government agencies. He was nominated for an FCC position by president Obama and confirmed unanimously by the senate. People hate him because he was nominated to chairman by Trump and because of his position on net neutrality. I know I'll get a lot of flak for this, but honestly net neutrality had no noticeable impact on consumers. Prices haven't gone up. ISPs haven't clamped down on what sites you can visit. This outcome was obvious before the law changed. Internet services improved before net neutrality and plenty of other countries with better service don't have net neutrality. People seem to think Pai wants to deregulate everything, but that notion is quashed if you actually look at what he's done and said. For example: he has argued in favor of a cap on the rates of long distance phone calls from prisons. From a 2003 memo[1]: > I believe that the government should usually stay its hand in economic matters and allow the price of goods and services to respond to consumer choice and competition. But sometimes the market fails, and government intervention carefully tailored to address that market failure is appropriate. > The provision of inmate calling services (ICS) is one such market. Inmates cannot choose their carrier, and carriers do not compete with each other for an inmate’s calls. Those do not sound like the words of someone who is in the pocket of giant phone companies. Pai has also threatened to legislate that phone companies switch to a secure caller ID protocol if one isn't adopted by the end of the year.[2] This would make most robocalls easy to block. The problem is that different phone companies have trouble coordinating, as nobody benefits until they all adopt the new protocol. A government mandating adoption of a new technology is a way to solve that coordination problem. Career bureaucrats are many things, but they aren't what the media portrays Ajit Pai as. 1. http://transition.fcc.gov/Daily_Releases/Daily_Business/2013/db0809/DOC-322749A4.pdf http://transition.fcc.gov/Daily_Releases/Daily_Business/2013... 2. https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/DOC-357422A1.pdf https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/DOC-357422A1.pdf
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> That's not true at all. He worked at Verizon for 2 years (2001-2003). He is a former Verizon lawyer, as stated. > He was nominated for an FCC position by president Obama and confirmed unanimously by the senate. The FCC has five commissioners but only three can be of the same party. Pai's slot was thereby slated to be filled by a Republican even when the President is of the other party. Moreover, confirmation of commissioners is rarely contested because the appointments are temporary and because of the way they're selected, rejecting one would only result in their being replaced by someone of the same party. > People hate him because he was nominated to chairman by Trump and because of his position on net neutrality. People hate him because of his position on net neutrality and other issues. I expect Trump loses more support for nominating Pai (from people paying attention to such things) than Pai loses for having been nominated by Trump (in addition to Obama). > I know I'll get a lot of flak for this, but honestly net neutrality had no noticeable impact on consumers. It seems odd that the ISPs would be so opposed to a policy that has no impact on anything. > Prices haven't gone up. This is never a thing it was supposed to cause. The opponents had argued the opposite -- that network neutrality would cause prices to be higher. Yet we haven't seen a significant price reduction either, though seeing any pricing result on a short time frame would be quite unexpected regardless. > ISPs haven't clamped down on what sites you can visit. Again, not a thing that was expected. The problem is things like zero rating favored services while imposing metering or usage caps for others, and purposely oversubscribing transit links so that their direct competitors for video services have to pay them monopoly prices for interconnection. These things occur even now. Also, these companies are highly experienced in government policy. They know perfectly well not to jump right into outrageous behavior from the date of the rule change if they want to keep it. That doesn't mean it's not coming. Expect to see more things like this, from before the rules were in place to begin with: https://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/27/us/27verizon.html https://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/27/us/27verizon.html And again, if they don't intend to violate it then what does it hurt for violations to be prohibited? It's like repealing the law against leaded gasoline and then claiming it's not needed because nobody has resumed production of it yet. If they're not ever going to do it then the rule is harmless and if they are going to do it then the repeal is not. > People seem to think Pai wants to deregulate everything, The claim is that he's in the telecommunications industry's pocket, not that he wants to deregulate everything. These are not the same thing -- especially in the telecommunications industry. The incumbents commonly use regulation to suppress competition. > but that notion is quashed if you actually look at what he's done and said. For example: he has argued in favor of a cap on the rates of long distance phone calls from prisons. The high rates don't go to the major telecommunications companies, they go to the prisons or their bespoke prison calling system providers. It constitutes ~0% of Verizon's revenue -- and is if anything probably costing them some money in lost business because the high cost paid to other parties suppresses demand for their services. > Pai has also threatened to legislate that phone companies switch to a secure caller ID protocol if one isn't adopted by the end of the year. Once again nothing to the detriment of large telcos, which have the scale to implement the requirement efficiently (unlike some of their smaller competitors), and benefit from it by not having robocalls causing customers to cancel their telephone service as not worth the inconvenience. Also apparently not very effective regardless: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20190610/07405142367/fcc-pats-itself-back-new-robocall-plan-that-isnt-new-has-no-real-teeth.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20190610/07405142367/fcc-p... But let's suppose it's not a bad policy -- it's possible for the interests of telcos and the interests of consumers to coincide. The issue is that shouldn't be the only time that FCC policy benefits consumers. Meanwhile he's repealing network neutrality and privacy rules, rubber stamping the T-Mobile/Sprint merger, appointing industry lobbyists to consumer advisory panels and various other problematic policies: https://energycommerce.house.gov/sites/democrats.energycommerce.house.gov/files/documents/FCC%20Ltr%201.24.19.pdf https://energycommerce.house.gov/sites/democrats.energycomme... https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/12/ajit-pai-buries-2-year-old-speed-test-data-in-appendix-of-762-page-report/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/12/ajit-pai-buries-... https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/09/ajit-pais-plan-to-lower-broadband-standards-is-crazy-fcc-democrat-says/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/09/ajit-... https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/bj49j8/fcc-falsely-claims-community-broadband-an-ominous-threat-to-the-first-amendment https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/bj49j8/fcc-falsel... https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/mb57gx/no-broadband-competition-100-mbps https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/mb57gx/no-broadba...
- chopin 7y agoOne problem with your suggestion is that it is reactive and not proactive. That's dangerous in safety settings. You will almost surely find people willing to run the risk. Others have to bear the consequences (passengers, share holders). Criminals are almost always sure that they will not be caught. Jail time is not a very good deterrence.