8 ms·
Free speech is a very different subject than the rights of journalists. Australians by and large don't want American style, unfettered free speech. And are qui
by threeseed 7y ago
Free speech is a very different subject than the rights of journalists.
Australians by and large don't want American style, unfettered free speech. And are quite happy with "say whatever you want so long as you don't libel or slander someone or some group of people" approach. It's what keeps our very multicultural society together.
What happened with the recent investigation of journalists is about the Australian government's right to see the drafts and sources for articles that involve investigating national security matters. And in general harass and intimidate journalists to discourage such articles in the future.
You can fix the second problem by enshrining the rights of journalists in legislation without having to make it a freedom of speech issue.
- howiroll 7y agoYeah, let’s let the government decide whether a speech is a libel or slander. It’s still a freedom of speech, isn’t it?
- wolco 7y agoWithout freedom of speech you lose freedom of thought. Unkniwn journalists will be affected by removing press credentials.
- emn13 7y agoThat sounds like a slogan, not something founded in reason. No country has freedom of speech; it is heavily regulated... everywhere. The world hasn't collapsed yet. How it's regulated probably matters; granted! But let's not get too apocalyptic about the issue. Not every regulation will turn everyone into mindless drones overnight. And for the flipside: speech is only worth protecting because it's powerful; it's influential. You can insert the cheesy line about power and responsibility yourself... It's a natural and good use of regulation to turn consequences for others into consequences (both good and bad!) for the person triggering them. Communication is not, and should not be, an exception.
- tus87 7y agoAnd one day a right wing government will shut down left wing speech they call "hate speech" or "harmful" and your "reason" will take flight to the winds.
- Vinnl 7y agoWell, the question of how you determine who is a journalist and hence gets these rights protected is still a difficult one. When is someone eligible for press credentials?
- alacombe 7y agoOutside of the US, the world hasn't a great personal freedom track record (including Europe)... disclamer: I exiled myself from Europe due the lack of objective personal freedom and opportunity. "Liberte, egalite, fraternite" has long been forgotten.
- qwsxyh 7y agoI hope you didn't let the door hit you on the way out
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- boapnuaput 7y agoSure, it's a slogan, but you don't really have any arguments against it. The nature of the argument is slippery-slope, or syllogistic: If freedom of speech disappears, then freedom of religion goes with it. There's actually a tight binding between these two in the USA, since the same clause of the Constitution protects both. No country has ever had truest freedom of speech. That doesn't mean that freedom of speech is bad; it could just as well mean that no country has ever been out of the hands of aristocrats for long enough to forge a freedom of speech which trumps their desire to be immune from the lower classes. But you're critiquing a position which has not yet existed and implying that the world will collapse if that position is realized, again without evidence. The phrase "turn everyone into mindless drones" is telltale; it shows that you currently believe that people are not mindless drones. To the contrary, though, it's even easier to imagine that people have been gaining more freedoms through the centuries, and that people are turning into more mindful creatures, with less droning behavior. Even if progressivism is wrong, certainly the communication technologies that we have invented have given the everyday person a power of speech that empowers them beyond what their ancestors had. Speaking of power, the cheesy line I'll choose today is that power and responsibility are formally dual in any category of social relations; if X has power over Y to do Z, then Y has responsibilities to do Z for X. And yes, freedom of speech is an insistence that this power not be abridged from everyday citizens. That's not a bad thing at all; beyond the progressive metanarrative, the slow and steady task of decentralizing and dividing power amongst people is important. To summarize, you are suffering from tropes three through five from the list of censorship tropes. [0] [0] https://www.popehat.com/2015/05/19/how-to-spot-and-critique-censorship-tropes-in-the-medias-coverage-of-free-speech-controversies/ https://www.popehat.com/2015/05/19/how-to-spot-and-critique-...
- stareatgoats 7y agoFreedom of expression and the right of government to retaliate against whistle-blowers do not seem such different subjects to me. They are at least highly interconnected, in what seems to me a fundamental aspect of democracy: that it allows for an informed public to make their decision through the ballot. That doesn't mean that those freedoms need to be absolutely unfettered, but limits on them need to be transparent and well motivated.
- sonnyblarney 7y agoThey are obviously overlapping, but they are definitely different due to the nature of disclosure: The press will be able to disclose otherwise 'privileged/private' information that one wouldn't be able to otherwise publish in terms of 'free speech', if for example it's evidence of a crime. i.e. 'classified material' doesn't fall under 'free speech'. You can't just publish that stuff willy nilly. But if some of that material betrays evidence of a crime, then it's 'fair game' in most modern jurisdictions it seems. The difference between the 'press' and 'everyone else' is, in 2019 still super vague, specifically in the relevant area of being compelled to testify about sources etc. at least in the US, there's no clarity in the law, and some conflicting rulings.
- stevenjohns 7y agoYou're casting a very wide net there. > Australians by and large don't want American style, unfettered free speech I'd argue that Australians, by and large, don't know that they don't have a legislated right to free speech similar to what they have in the US. This is evident by the shock surprise and outrage from Australians every time there is an action that stifles free speech. > And are quite happy with "say whatever you want so long as you don't libel or slander someone or some group of people" approach Neither libel nor slander is protected under the American first amendment. > It's what keeps our very multicultural society together. Australia has a very mono-cultural society. The "multi-cultural society" meme attempts to liken having a kebab shop on the corner to having conflicting cultures in the same area, which to me (as a non-Anglo Australian) doesn't make sense. Australian values and culture is quite evidently very specific (freedom of religion, freedom of dress, freedom of expression, etc) and we - both legally and as a society - reject any culture that conflict with this. Perhaps the only other culture that is allowed in Australia is traditional Aboriginal culture, where we quite literally have a second set of laws to accommodate it. That said, freedom of speech doesn't have any impact on this at all. I'm not sure where the link you're supposing comes from. --- In general, what happened[0] was intentionally misreported by the ABC. 1. The AFP obtained a search warrant for the ABC offices. 2. The AFP notified the ABC that they were coming to investigate in advance, however the ABC reported it to be a "raid." 3. The ABC dedicated a five camera film crew to follow the AFP around throughout the process. 4. The AFP had the explicit goal of finding out who the source was for revealing classified security information. That's it. It wasn't a free speech issue -- and it wasn't a journalistic rights issue. [0] https://www.afp.gov.au/news-media/media-releases/afp-statement-activity-canberra-and-sydney https://www.afp.gov.au/news-media/media-releases/afp-stateme...
- roenxi 7y agoI'd just like to put it out there that I very much agree with everything you said, and would have tried to write a similar post had you not already said everything better than I would have. Particularly the idea that Australia has a very multicultural society; we don't. We have lots of immigrants, but very limited cultural clashing such as is seen in, eg, the US where they actually have to manage all the different cultures they keep incubated. Ironically the fact nearly everyone is first- or second - generation immigrant promotes somewhat homogeneous culture although that is a gross generalisation as all generalisations are. That said, there is one other point that deserves to be kept in focus - why exactly does the Australian government need to classify the fact that they are killing unarmed men and children. That shouldn't be classified information; if someone is killing unarmed children on my behalf I'd like to know about it tyvm.
- docdeek 7y agoThere's a chance of running into problems when you try and define 'journalist', though. If a journalist is someone employed by a major news corporation then you are going to disadvantage the independent journalists with not much more than a website, a good number of contacts in their address book, and a sizable Twitter following. If different rights and responsibilities are allocated to government-approved journalists than to independent journalists or regular citizens, then someone in that government is going to have to hand out the 'officially a journalist' card. I might like the government in power today and I might really like them to deny the official journalist protections you envisage to the journalists from the outlets I think are biased and lean the wrong way. However, because there is a pretty good chance that, in a democracy, the other guy is going to win, I wouldn't look forward to those same restrictions being placed on the journalists I like to read. Hence, the best thing is to protect everyone's freedom to write and publish, to question authority, and to speak.
- jddj 7y agoWe could probably look to the rest of the West for inspiration, they've been navigating these grey areas in the interest of accountability for a while now. It's still a developing science though, see the conflict over "was Assange acting as a journalist?", and the different decisions taken by different US administrations on that particular case, but it will still be kneeded out in the courts which is where we usually decide things like this which are open to interpretation.
- StreamBright 7y agoThis is essentially saying that the issue depends on the definition of slander.
- mc32 7y agoWhy should journalists have more freedom than ordinary people? This can lead to elitism as well as lack of accountability if they know no one can challenge them if they take on agendas.
- dboreham 7y agoI think the idea is that they're special in that they're performing actions in the public interest, and perhaps also some notion that it's a two-way deal: journalists for example aren't expected to dox in-field security services agents, under-cover operatives etc. But...interesting question.
- cromulent 7y agoI read the comment as referring to the fourth estate in general, rather than people who are journalists in particular.
- ousta 7y agounfettered free speech as long as you think like the common san fransico or new york person and don't get your voice erased by zuck or sergei
- rayiner 7y agoAustralia is over 90% Caucasian, and almost all of that is English, Scottish, and Irish ancestry. Due to Australia’s strict immigration controls, the large proportion of foreign born is disproportionately of European ancestry compared to the foreign born in the US. Likewise, because the US has a longer history of immigration, many people who aren’t immigrants nonetheless are members of a visible minority group. Thus, while Sydney has more than 40% of its population born abroad, versus under 20% for Chicago, to American eyes Sydney looks very white and homogenous by comparison to Chicago.
- cyphar 7y ago> Australians by and large don't want American style, unfettered free speech. Most Australians don't know that there is no legislative or constitutional protections for everyday free speech rights they exercise. The High Court has had to stretch the constitution's wording to breaking point in order to rule in favour of more freedom on the side of the public. Maybe we don't want American-style free speech, but maybe we want some other variant of free speech protections such as in any other developed country (we are the only developed country which doesn't have any free speech or privacy laws on the books). The entire argument of not having constitutional language for free speech was that English common law was sufficient. I think that view has been shown to be incorrect. > And are quite happy with "say whatever you want so long as you don't libel or slander someone or some group of people" approach. There are no legal protections for this kind of speech in Australia -- so if they're quite happy with it then they do want free speech laws. Also, America has libel laws restricting freedom of speech in specific ways (as does every other country which has free speech laws).