2 ms·
I wanted to make almost the same comment, but this part is not 100% accurate: > In every case we know of involving commercial reactors, fuel melt-down happened
by littlestymaar 7y ago
I wanted to make almost the same comment, but this part is not 100% accurate:
> In every case we know of involving commercial reactors, fuel melt-down happened when the reactor was non-critical, completely devoid of fission.
This is indeed true for Three Mile Island, Fukushima and Saint-Laurent-des-Eaux in 1969, but IIRC not for Chernobyl, and this was clearly not the case in Saint-Laurent-des-Eaux in 1980. (Yes, Saint-Laurent-des-Eaux faced two indendant meltdown events…).
More generally, as long as you're using light water as a coolant and moderator (PWR and BWR), you're likely to have negative void coefficient, which prevents fission-induced meltdown, but for other technologies, the risk exists.
- jhayward 7y agoI'll accept the correction regarding Saint-Laurent-des-Eaux, thank you. However the steam explosion(s) that blew apart the reactor assembly at Chernobyl did not melt the fuel rods there although of course there may have been some localized areas of melting. The melt that created the tons of corium was due to decay heat. It occurred many hours after the power excursion and explosion(s).