3 ms·
This is the key flaw in this article: “The truth is that such questions are open to empirical study and it is possible for social science to study them scienti
by mensetmanusman 7y ago
This is the key flaw in this article:
“The truth is that such questions are open to empirical study and it is possible for social science to study them scientifically.”
Here is someone proclaiming to be a scientist, and then throwing out proclamations of ‘truth’ not backed by evidence. Goedel proved logically that any axiomatic system of information exchange can have truths that are not provable.
It’s possible human culture and society is too diverse to make claims of ‘absolute truth’ about. A statistical mechanics approach to why this might be true is telling. The more entropic states available, the more potential outcomes. That is why physics studying single atom or molecules is more ‘understandable’ than sociologists studying 10^35 if them (humans being a cloud of atoms).
- kodz4 7y ago"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal..." All men are not equal, never have been and probably never will be. So why is that line so famous? Why has it influenced the course of history? Not just in the US. What that sentence, and its effects on history show us, is when people are faced with the Unprovable, they have a choice to sit back, do nothing and accept it OR decide what they want the truth to be. Unsurprisingly its always the latter group that makes change happen. The rest just fall asleep reading Goedel.
- mancerayder 7y agoNo way - it's derived from a conception of rights derived from Reason, God, or both. What you say sounds like a Postmodern interpretation, even revisionism, of the original intent. What else do you think self-evident meant? But even worse, you left out the very next part: "endowed by their Creator with Certain unalienable Rights". No, it is NOT about making change happen, or whatever hijacking of Truth is being attempted here, it's about solidifying a state (as in authority) different than other states created with other underlying principles.
- scythe 7y ago>Here is someone proclaiming to be a scientist, and then throwing out proclamations of ‘truth’ not backed by evidence. Goedel proved logically that any axiomatic system of information exchange can have truths that are not provable. The trouble with this argument is that Goedel's proof relies on systems which can model Peano arithmetic; in particular, it assumes that the system deals with numbers that are arbitrarily large. For example, Goodstein's theorem, the commonly-stated simplest unprovable theorem, depends on a function like this: f(2) = 19, f(3) = 7.6 × 10^12, f(4) = 1.3 × 10^154, ... Most numbers in sociology are not so large. The number of possible subsets of the human population is between f(7) and f(8). Additionally, theorems about discrete systems do not always apply to continuous systems. For example, the theory of real closed fields is decidable: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_closed_field http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_closed_field Most undecidable statements depend on things that look vaguely Diophantine, but sociology is rarely Diophantine. Rather, it tends be that approximately a solution is still kind of a solution.
- zajio1am 7y ago> Goedel proved logically that any axiomatic system of information exchange can have truths that are not provable. No, that is a misrepresentation of Goedel's results. A theorem that is undecidable (neither provable nor refutable) from a set of axioms cannot be 'truth' in the logical sense (because there are models of that set of axioms in which the theorem is true, and other models in which the theorem is false) - see Goedel's completeness theorem, which says that every truth is provable (and vice versa). Goedel's incompleteness theorems can be understood on the semantic level as the mathematical structure of natural numbers cannot be characterized by a sane set of axioms, so any such attempt (e.g. peano axioms) that describes natural numbers also describes a different mathematical structure (a nonstandard model of arithmetic) and there exists a theorem that is true in one and false in the other model (so that theorem is undecidable).
- sideshowb 7y agoGoedel is not really relevant to this. In the same way that insolubility of the halting problem doesn't prevent this message getting from my phone to hn to your screen. Its s theoretical limit on what can be computed but we're nowhere near running up against it. (Sure, someone's phone will crash now, but they can still get back here somehow if they're that bothered).
- thrwayxyz 7y agoHe proved arithmetic is independent of logic. Geometry isn't.