3 ms·
Part 2 of the article is really good. It’s a shame if people are put off by the premise of the article. The authors have already pre-judged the outcome though.
by simonh 7y ago
Part 2 of the article is really good. It’s a shame if people are put off by the premise of the article. The authors have already pre-judged the outcome though.
“Because machines lack an inner mental life...”
Right, well that’s it then. Case closed. No point in researching general AI any more, might as well put all those researchers on unemployment benefits.
The authors do say we don’t know how to engineer a machine with an inner mental life and consciousness, and this is true. It’s why like you (dmreedy) I’m a skeptic of claims that general AI is just round the corner. It isn’t and the Singularity is a good long way off. Our current efforts in AI are pitifully primitive, at best many orders of magnitude dumber than a fruit fly. That doesn’t lead me to believe therefore that we will never learn to solve this problem, or that this problem is in principle not solvable.
- roywiggins 7y agoFor those skeptical that you even need an inner mental life to be intelligent, Peter Watt's novels "Blindsight"* and "Echopraxia" are a must-read. * https://rifters.com/real/Blindsight.htm https://rifters.com/real/Blindsight.htm
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoThese are great novels, but they are just novels. To the best of our knowledge, all intelligent species in the universe have an "inner sight," or, the ability to observe at least some of their own mental machinery. Although the starfish of Blindsight seem possible, whether they are likely seems like another question entirely.