4 ms·
I agree. I mean if we're guessing at possible dangers, it seems like there are several possible angles that might be tempting to try: - It's meant to be a stea
by vidarh 7y ago
I agree. I mean if we're guessing at possible dangers, it seems like there are several possible angles that might be tempting to try:
- It's meant to be a stealthy plane, how about tweaking the board to cause a nice and noisy signal leak in certain circumstances?
- find a way of causing the board to fail under suitable circumstances.
- Probably less plausible, if they can figure out what data is passing through the board, then there is potential to engineer side-channels in the hope that they can achieve another compromise that can leverage it. Maybe they never get the chance to take advantage, maybe they do. Or if e.g. they can find an input that an adversary can potentially influence by how they engage with the plane, use that to trigger failure as above.
I'm assuming they're properly inspected and tested on receipt, but wires on circuit boards can interfere with each other in messy ways if you exceed tolerances even a little bit. I recall an amusing case some years back where someone used genetic algorithms to lay out features on an FPGA and got a very good solution that was totally un-reproducible: it turned out their GA had optimized to take advantage of quirks of that one specific FPGA that didn't work on other FPGA's of the same model, by combining things in ways it hadn't been designed for. It seems it's very much possible to design chips that superficially looks like it should act one way but where it acts differently in certainly circumstances.
Doing so in a way that's exploitable without being caught out is probably much harder, but I share your skepticism.
- delfinom 7y agoThat's not how PCBs work at all. Dear god. Such mission critical to EMI designs would be submitted to full spectrum EMI tests once assembled (hitting it with noise of all kinds of frequencies AND testing it for leaks of all kinds). Causing a bare board to fail? lol, perhaps if you have an atomic disintegrator. Assembled boards with actual components? Now you have something you can actually fail but this PCB house does not do said assembly nor have access to that. Figure out what data? Completely impossible. These are just copper traces. They don't get told "Mr Copper trace, you are going to do i2c and send XYZ data! and you are going to be a pci express and send ABC!" at the fab. Jeez. Now a real cause for concern, if say a state actor had access to the completed assembly going into the planes, they could identify a place to embed a backdoor. The state actor controlled PCB house could then embed the backdoor into the PCB itself. But at that point you have 2 different security breaches and the PCB guy is probably lesser of your concerns. The dumber thing would be to alter the current carrying capacity of power traces which tend to be obvious staring at a board. But it would just identical to trolling by causing boards to fail and eventually get it investigated and your supplier contract revoked.
- microcolonel 7y ago> submitted to full spectrum EMI tests once assembled Under all internal running conditions? That's not feasible.
- darkmighty 7y agoWell, it should be possible to hide components inside the PCB, see: (1) https://hackaday.com/2017/09/11/the-components-are-inside-the-circuit-board/ https://hackaday.com/2017/09/11/the-components-are-inside-th... (2) https://hackaday.com/2019/01/18/oreo-construction-hiding-your-components-inside-the-pcb/ https://hackaday.com/2019/01/18/oreo-construction-hiding-you... Analysis should be quite difficult; if you hide them between copper layers, or worse behind components and behind copper layers, I believe it'd require vert inspection with x-rays to detect. The main question is that of utility. Data exfiltration is highly unlikely. It's possible to trigger malfunctions, but it's not clear this would be useful (when triggered at a certain date, randomly, etc) -- it would be easy to detect and cause the companies to switch to suppliers. I think the main possibility/atractivity would be some kind of radio activation of malfunction. But then you need a significantly sized antenna [1] and a very strong signal to penetrate the circuit shielding (which is probably emp-resistant). But the main impediment I think is the total erosion of trust in Chinese manufacturing this could bring. Most of the world manufactures in China and they don't want to change this. They wouldn't sacrifice this trust except at a very good opportunity. The same goes from a strategic spying perspective: don't use bugs frivolously or you'll risk raising the awareness level compromising important opportunities. [1] Which cannot be hidden between layers, although it might be possible to use some of the traces themselves as antennas. If the pcb has an obvious external antenna I/O then of course this would make things easy. All that said, it does make sense to keep an eye on this possibility, but probably not in this particular case.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> These are just copper traces. They're supposed to be just copper traces. The point of comprising it is you add something that's not supposed to be there, like a chip embedded secretly inside the plastic and connected to the traces.
- 7y ago