3 ms·
I mean, not secretly. Amazon is very explicit that it saves recordings of all commands for training and personalization -- you can even manually review and dele
by crazygringo 7y ago
I mean, not secretly. Amazon is very explicit that it saves recordings of all commands for training and personalization -- you can even manually review and delete them, or disable them completely.
And obviously if you have your children speak to Alexa, it will record them too. Same with visitors in your home. It's not a secret... it's how it works.
Alexa does support voice profiles. But it's certainly not perfect -- voice identification can be hard even for people to do (depending on similarity), and there's a huge leap from distinguishing between pre-identified voices, versus determining if a voice is one of those and not one of billions of other people. And there's certainly no magic way to analyze a voice a determine that it's 12 (not allowed) or 13 (allowed).
So I'm not exactly sure what this lawsuit intends to change?
The only thing I can imagine is perhaps to allow disabling voice recordings per voice profile, so you can create a voice profile of your child and then do that -- but intriguingly, Amazon says voice profiles can only be created for users 13+, so there's presumably something legal here.
But really, if you don't want your kids (or visitors) using Alexa, either tell them not to use it, or don't have one in the first place. I really can't see how this is up to anyone other than the parents?
- jsty 7y ago"but intriguingly, Amazon says voice profiles can only be created for users 13+, so there's presumably something legal here" Presumably if they're banned from storing and processing the information of under-13s, that includes doing so for the purposes of identifying that individual as under-13.
- ronsor 7y agowell then, that's simply an impossible condition (if you can't find out whether they're under 13, then you can't comply, and if you do try to find out, you aren't complying: there's no way out)
- toomuchtodo 7y agoThrow out audio for any non registered profile.