3 ms·
Yeah, based on a very informal survey I’ve seen on some reading-related subreddits, the biggest difference between fast and slow readers was whether they subvoc
by falcolas 7y ago
Yeah, based on a very informal survey I’ve seen on some reading-related subreddits, the biggest difference between fast and slow readers was whether they subvocalized or not.
I fall in the “not” category (the average-sized book is a 3-4 hour length for me), but I will occasionally intentionally subvocalize, just to slow myself down a bit.
- dbmueller 7y agoIs this categorization (subvocalizers vs others) backed up by research? Can on learn not to subvocalize?
- CydeWeys 7y agoI suspect so, as almost everyone starts off as an out-loud vocalizer when they're first learning to read.
- gowld 7y agoThis is a _fantastic_ example of sampling bias. You simply have no idea when small children are reading silently. You assume they aren't reading until they vocalize, and then when they stop vocalizing you change your assumption to assume they are still reading even though you can't hear it.
- pessimizer 7y agoI never knew that anyone subvocalized until I ran into theories that subvocalization was required for reading.
- someguy345 7y agoI would consider whether you really want to. I'm someone who seems to have naturally not sub-vocalized for most of my life or at least if I did it was like a robotic voice fast talking in my head, I guess I would actually sound the words in my head but much faster than a person talking and in a way that did not help me develop a feel for inflection, etc. I have always been able to read faster than an average person but the last couple years has opened my eyes to a lot of communication issues I have had, basically my default has been that when I talked to people it would always seem very low energy and without much emotion or inflection and it has had a very negative impact on my social life, among other things. In the last couple years I've started learning a second language, in which I find it much easier to read if I do sub-vocalize at a normal human pace and I've also started pushing myself to record myself talking about various topics in English and to work on my communication skills overall. I've now started sub-vocalizing when I read in English as well and I'm noticing overall improvements in my life like being able to have more expressive and natural conversations with people. I'm sure reading without it has its places when you really need to speed read but I'm not sure a goal of never sub vocalizing is ideal.
- cnasc 7y ago> I fall in the “not” category (the average-sized book is a 3-4 hour length for me), but I will occasionally intentionally subvocalize, just to slow myself down a bit. This is what I do, though sometimes it's a second pass over a passage that I want to savor or really focus deeply on.
- noir_lord 7y agoSimilar to re-reading a passage I go back and re-read books I really like 3-4 times (and a few many more than that). I've read all of the Discworld novels at least 3 times and a few like Hogfather more than a dozen (I re-read it ever Christmas). Reading is one of lives truly great pleasures and it's one of lifes most democratic.
- dorfsmay 7y agoI'm an extremely slow reader. I read probably most books about this subject, but am unable to absorb material if I don't subvocalize.i see words, chunk of words, but they don't connect to each other and I get no meaning. I've wondered if this is one of those thing that if you have not learned how to do it before a certain age, your brain can no longer learn it, like seeing in stereo etc...
- noir_lord 7y agoIt could be, I was really slow to learn to read (and I mean slow, I nearly ended up in remedial classes) until I got exceptionally lucky in having a teacher who realised my issue wasn't capability it was boredom and who was willing to give up her lunch time to introduce me to books that were engaging (I still remember the first 'proper' book I read, 'Goodnight Mister Tom' by Michelle Magorian - The critical point was when I wanted to know what happened next and began (laboriously) reading it at home so I could find out) - at 7 I had the reading ability of a slow 5 year old by 8 I was reading books typically read in school by 16 year olds. Once I found books and authors I liked I became a voracious reader, from eight to adulthood it wasn't unusual for me to have 3-4 books on the go at once and to read 3-4 books in a week all the classic works of sci-fi, books on science, computers, geography, history, politics, biology I was a sponge, I'd read almost anything - I used to read while walking to and from school, I walked into surprisingly few lamp posts. The more I read the less I vocalised the words in my head, I started with pointing at each word (as most kids do) and then I stopped doing that, then I started looking at the word shape rather than the word and not vocalising it at all, it wasn't anything conscious just a natural progression. In a very profound sense that teacher and my mum altered the scope of my life for the next 30 years, the teacher by realising I just needed the time and the right material and my mum for scouring charity shops/2nd hand book shops to keep me fed with books as money was tight (bless her, she used to keep a list in her purse of all the authors I liked, what books they had written and which I'd read).
- gowld 7y agoIt's also possible that people who don't subvocalize aren't absorbing as much.