6 ms·
> Somehow out of the blue, Fortnite became huge That “somehow” is pretty obvious: they had already built all the assets for a great multiplayer FPS-esque, and
by derefr 7y ago
> Somehow out of the blue, Fortnite became huge
That “somehow” is pretty obvious: they had already built all the assets for a great multiplayer FPS-esque, and already had a whole marketing department spun up to get people to play it. Once they decided to pivot to Battle Royale as a game mechanic, they spent a month on rewriting game logic, and then had a nearly-finished AAA Battle Royale game on their hands with a staff ready to sell it, with more polish than existing entries in the genre and no other studios close to catching up to chase the fad in time.
Business take-away: if you build for a well-established, very competitive market, and then—near the finish line—pivot into a new and (as yet) less-competitive market where you can still reuse everything you built, the extra polish you had to put into your product to get it to stand out in the heavily-competitive field, will make you stand head-and-shoulders above everyone else in the less-competitive field.
(I’m trying to think of other good examples of this effect in the business domain but coming up short. Anyone?)
- ZeroGravitas 7y agoApple using its iPod and Mac experience to enter (smart)phones?
- blazespin 7y agoI disagree. There was no magic trick here. Unreal is a company built with the best and brightest in the games industry over a very long period. I don't think any other company could have replicated their success - they just don't have that level of talent density.
- bhouston 7y agoThis is a very accurate assessment. It was a real effective marketing team combined with a very smart pivot to an adjacent market and hitting product market fit.epic games tried and tried and tried (paragon, recent attempts to revitalize unreal tournament, etc) and eventually they got a huge hit.
- soulofmischief 7y agoYeah, it's like the Picasso napkin thing. Fortnite wasn't an overnight success, it was decades in the making. I had so much hype for the new Unreal Tournament, but after seeing how that was handled I never even gave Paragon a shot. I'm glad Epic Games eventually figured things out.
- jasonkolb 7y agoI like this observation. You could argue that Salesforce did the same thing pivoting from CRM into the platform as a service market. They had the user management, security, configuration tools, reporting, etc, that they were able to take into marketing, call center, etc.
- ascar 7y agoBlizzard with Overwatch comes to mind. But it's pretty much the same scenario. Netflix might also be a good example shifting from DVD renting to streaming.
- distantsounds 7y agoOverwatch is an entirely new game that wasn't spun from another, existing IP. everything in that game is original. a better comparison would be how DOTA spawned from Warcratft 3, or how Hearthstone spawned from WOW. a failed comparison would be how valve released Artifact off of DoTA2. but DOTA auto chess is now a thing. that may take off.
- maccard 7y agoOverwatch is only original in the sense that the IP didn't exist. There's a pretty decent (probably to be taken with a pinch of salt) article from Eurogamer which summarises an AMA and a few old articles and explains how OW came from "Titan" - https://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2017-03-14-blizzards-jeff-kaplan-traces-line-from-project-titan-to-overwatch https://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2017-03-14-blizzards-jeff...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- elefanten 7y agoGP's examples are more applicable to the question posed about late-stage pivots. IP is not the point. It's about having a particular business objective / product in development whose assets were redeployed to realize a different vision. Overwatch came from the assets in development for the cancelled Project Titan MMO. DoTA was built in War3's map editor. Hearthstone used the IP from the Warcraft franchise. Artifact used the IP from Dota 2. Dota Auto Chess was built in Dota 2's map editor.
- chupasaurus 7y agoNever heard of Team Fortress 2? DotA spawned from Starcraft custom map Aeon of Strife using new mechanics from WC3, DotA:Allstars/DOTA 2 is a heavy revamp of the original map. Between WoW and Hearthstone there was WoW TCG, not a video game.
- SamuelAdams 7y ago> (I’m trying to think of other good examples of this effect in the business domain but coming up short. Anyone?) Probably the most famous example is a company called Burbn. Here's a story (not mine) about that pivot: Posting anon. In 2009, the startup where I was working was hitting the skids, and our investors (correctly) were not willing to back us. We all kept grinding for a month or two in honorable futility, but after a while, my bank account depleted and I had to go. To make various ends meet and to keep my mental health during the wind down however, I took up some contract work that I found through various friends in the SF startup scene. One company that I really liked and did some small stuff for was Burbn, which was a mobile-only location check-in that was hinged around taking photos of your location. Missing my friends in NYC (I made a lot of friends in SF, but my inner circle were my college buddies from CMU; I went to tech and they went finance, sigh), I decided to leave SF to head to NYC and get a fresh start. As I was leaving, I wanted to tie up a few loose ends, so I emailed my contact at Burbn and said I was likely to be unavailable for any more work, but that I liked the project and hoped for the best for him. He responded and said that he was near funding on a small pivot, and that if I was interested, there might be a full-time role available. I declined - I was mentally done with SF and the startup scene (Larry Chiang, 111 Minna, the rise of FB spam-crap like RockYou, etc.) as it was then. That person was Kevin Systrom; that pivot was Instagram. Source: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18063362 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18063362
- throwaway121233 7y agoI remember Larry Chiang. Whatever happened to him? He always seemed so lacking of substance but somehow figured out how to show up everywhere. Is he actually the international man of mystery who made it big but keeps his secrets to himself, or just a con artist barely making it by living in a cheap apartment? Obviously the world isn't that black and white but I really wonder what happens to people like him.
- RickS 7y agoSketch, from Bohemian, did something that feels like this. They were working on a vector drawing software, targeted at making rich web2.0 type illustrations more easily. For an example, check out the screenshot of the early app for an idea of the kind of output they were showing off in 2012: https://www.macgasm.net/2012/08/16/sketch-2-1-update-adds-retina-support-and-much-more/ https://www.macgasm.net/2012/08/16/sketch-2-1-update-adds-re... They were competing with Adobe Illustrator at this time, which was extremely dense and less focused on that one thing. And then skeumorphism fell away and product design workflows started evolving and absorbing the systematization practices from devops, etc, and designers needed a way to make mockups that was more advanced than hypersimplistic tools like balsamiq, but less dense/more focused than Illustrator. In 2019, their value prop is completely different (and better!), but the bones of that first application are very visible: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5EatUkHez0U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5EatUkHez0U Since sketch's customers were making this journey, they software emerged along with it, and they deservedly dominated the early product design workflow. Now Adobe's competing with them instead of the other way around, but new entrants like Figma are building in features that are easier from a fresh start, like web collab and canvas items as react elements. Long term, they might get PUBG'd, to use a fortnight analogy – pioneering the category but getting usurped by bigger hits (fortnight) down the line.
- ricardobeat 7y agoLooks like it’s already happening: Figma and Framer X are quickly gaining ground.
- Itsdijital 7y agoEverybody here is missing why this game became so popular, and it's very common trap with the game. Its the reason why the game has also been so polarizing. I've played the game steadily for over a year now, so I have a bit of a grip on what happened/is going on. - Fortnite is not a shooting game. This is the main trap of the game. It looks like shooter, feels like a shooter, can be played like a shooter, but is not a shooter. Fortnite is a fighting game and should be played like one. It has an incredibly heavy reliance on mechanical skills (ala fighting games) and failure to recognize this will just lead to disappointment with the game. - Fortnite's success was a complete accident. The BR mode was a spun off "weekend project" for fun in order to attract players into buying Save The World. It was free and meant really just as an advertising tool. There wasn't much thought put into how it was supposed to play, but Epic 100% did not see where this was going, nor did the community at the time. And that was very much instrumental to it's success. Had Epic saw this coming, they would have totally destroyed the mechanics that made it so good right off the rip. I could write an essay about this, but the short of it is that the building mechanics were used in a totally unintended/unforeseen way and it lead to a wild success. Mark my words, one day in the future, free of NDA's, former devs will come out with some truly wild stories about FNBR. - Fortnite became a runaway success with kids because they have the easiest time adapting to completely new game mechanics. It gets a little gritty here, but the short of it is that Fornite is a completely new type of game with a completely new type of play style. Older players were trying to shove a square piece through a seemingly square hole (see note 1 about shooter/fighter), while younger players could easily adapt their blank gaming slates to fortnite's play style. Yeah the cosmetics and stuff helped, but nobody likes playing a game they suck at. TL;DR: Fortnite is deceiving in what it is. Fortnite was a total accidental success, because of accidentally awesome mechanics. Kids love fortnite because they were less prone to that earlier mentioned deception, and can pick up new things much quicker than older gamers.
- noir_lord 7y agoYou are completely right about the mechanics, I've played it some with the step-son and I can't get the hang of it, I've played FPS on and off over the years and I'm not bad at them but it just doesn't fit my mental model. Which delights him immensely how badly I suck :).
- fnord123 7y agoI think the lesson is that execution (and marketing) are everything. Unreal is a quake rip. Fortnite is a pubg rip. But they executed extremely well. So well that they feel fresh and not like a rip.
- allover 7y agoI mean, just one big reason Fortnite doesn't feel like a pubg rip is because Fortnite's building/editing mechanic sets it completely apart. Watch one of the Fortnite world cup matches going on right now [1] and tell me that you're watching a pubg rip :) [1] https://www.twitch.tv/videos/436713934?t=42m25s https://www.twitch.tv/videos/436713934?t=42m25s
- holoduke 7y agoA quake rip? Not at all. Unreal games always meant to be tech demos so their primary business objective: licensing out the engine became successful. The unreal engine was also one of the first engine with proper edit / scripting tools arround it. They already had them in the 90s with unrealed. Id software with quake did not really have such a license model (apart from some examples) Even today the idtech engine is not build to just license out to other companies.
- bgarbiak 7y agoI’d argue that the very first Unreal was a game first, a tech demo later. So was Unreal Tournament (based on Unreal Engine 1, IIRC), Unreal Tournament 2003, and – this one for sure – Gears of War. Maybe I wouldn’t call them Quake rips though; However, all the Unreals certainly weren’t innovative in any meaningful way, gameplay wise. The engine business exploded for Epic around Unreal Engine 3, I believe. Before that: they really wanted to sell those games. See the career of aforementioned CliffyB – he wasn’t Epic’s John Carmack, he was their John Romero. As for Id Software, they did licensed their technology since early days (Half-Life, Call of Duty, Medal of Honor, few others), but indeed Unreal surpassed them with tooling and support. Id tried to recover their position, around Doom 3 they renamed their „Quake engine” to Id Tech, and was working on the user-friendliness of it’s offering. I think they abandoned that idea by themselves, nonetheless, soon after they were bought by ZeniMax and that was it: no more licenses for companies not related to Bethesda. They don’t even bother to allow their current games to be modded. Meanwhile Epic’s engine business was flourishing, yet the games were flopping. Notice that only after Fortnite’s success they decided to open their Steam rival.
- GCA10 7y agoSlack's creation might fit this formula, too. What started out as an in-game chat function in the ultra-competitive gaming world turned out to be a dazzling workplace communication tool.