2 ms·
This line of reasoning dilutes the term “totalitarian” too much. Any given group being intolerant of contrarians is not “totalitarian”, it’s just a group follo
by toyg 7y ago
This line of reasoning dilutes the term “totalitarian” too much.
Any given group being intolerant of contrarians is not “totalitarian”, it’s just a group following group instincts. Otherwise you might as well argue that most animals are totalitarian, which is 1) patently absurd and 2) dangerous (since you are effectively arguing that totalitarianism is the natural state of any society).
Totalitarianism is not just about reaction to dissent; it requires a proactive side with structured ideology and a conscious effort to fashion all elements of life (public and private) after such ideology. Whether you really have something like this in Western society, is very debatable. Consumerism might get close, but you can still live and thrive without being a consumer, if you really want, and you won’t be jailed for it.
When you say “subtle totalitarianism”, you are highlighting some elements of Western life that could fit a totalitarian environment, but you are also ignoring all the rest that points in the opposite direction: organised dissent, freedom of expression, tolerance and survival of alternative lifestyles, and so on. This is normal: a lot of sociological constructs are not binary. But you cannot say that a society is totalitarian if it fits only a few of the characteristics of observed totalitarian systems.
I might concede that, after 1990, Western societies have somewhat sleepwalked into something closer to a “totalitarian capitalism” than they were before; but I think we are still far from the excesses of actual totalitarian societies.