4 ms·
> “But this kind of microbial metabolism can also be detrimental,” said Maini Rekdal, a graduate student in the lab of Professor Emily Balskus and first-author
by chiefalchemist 7y ago
> “But this kind of microbial metabolism can also be detrimental,” said Maini Rekdal, a graduate student in the lab of Professor Emily Balskus and first-author on their new study published in Science. According to Maini Rekdal, gut microbes can chew up medications, too, often with hazardous side effects. “Maybe the drug is not going to reach its target in the body, maybe it’s going to be toxic all of a sudden, maybe it’s going to be less helpful,” Maini Rekdal said.
To be fair (to our "hosts"), gut microbes do us far more good than harm. Yet we continue to prescribe antibiotics like they're Pez candies, and hand sanitizer'ed our way to "germ-free" because that's what sold the product.
- raverbashing 7y agoYeah but you don't get gut microbiota by eating with dirty hands, quite the contrary, a severe gastric infection can mess with your gut flora
- chillwaves 7y agoOur concept of "dirty" needs revisiting. What is the actual chance of getting the infection you describe? And in what conditions?
- mrob 7y agoI wonder if there's actually something to the Raw Foodism movement, not because of their nonsense claims about enzymes, but because raw food contains more viable bacteria.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoI've thought similar about microwaves. That is, using them to cook kills microbes - bad ones, but also good ones.
- mrob 7y agoHow does a microwave kill microbes more effectively than any other cooking method?
- chiefalchemist 7y agoMicrowaves. Not the same as gas heat, transfering thought a pan and into the food. Time. A thorough X seconds in the microwave is more convenient than standing at the stove. It's the tools. It's how they're most likely used.
- nitrogen 7y agoIf anything I'd expect microwaves' shorter cooking times and lower max temperatures to leave more bacteria alive.
- jstarfish 7y agoThey also don't cook evenly. You can have a TV dinner that is half molten and half frozen if you nuke it without the plastic lid. Microwave sterilizers depend on steam to sterilize, not radiation. They just get the water to that temperature quicker than boiling in a pot. Results also vary by organism being eradicated. Hamster in a microwave will end sadly. Cockroaches and ants will survive. Insects have less fatty tissue to absorb radiation I believe. Bacteria has none, so you do the math.
- mrob 7y agoUneven cooking is because of standing waves within the microwave. Lots of microwaves have rotating platforms to reduce this problem. If they're not being forcibly rotated, small enough creatures can avoid being cooked by staying at the nodes of the standing waves.
- wolco 7y agoIt is more complex. It's more about the environment that is created. Raw foods breakdown slower feeding different types of bacteria they have more bacteria but the live ones should be dead after stomach acid.
- kaitai 7y agoThere was an article here recently about fatty acids in soil that reduce anxiety. Very interesting. I am going all in on eating strawberries straight from the garden this year. Hasn't hurt in the past, & I know we're not using manure, so I figure it's good. Would love to see some research on this. Carrots from the yard with just a good scrub to get sand off: a microbiotic delight, or what?
- chiefalchemist 7y agoIf that were the case people would be falling over in masses on the regular. We evolved in a dirt-centric environment. The concept of clean and healthy is essentially a 20th-century invention. How's the working out of us. Put another way, you might be correct but your analysis is the rare exception and not at all the rule. It's foolish to build ideals and behaviors around outliers.
- maxerickson 7y agoIt's working out really, really, really well for us. We prevent an enormous amount of death and disease, very cheaply, with hygiene.
- WarDores 7y agoThis right here. It's easy to talk about optimizing gut bacteria when people aren't dying in the streets of cholera. Not saying we haven't swung too far in the other direction, but we've solved some very big problems with water treatment and hand washing.
- cheerlessbog 7y agoThis is true but I assume that only a small minority of bacteria (and viruses?) have a negative effect on humans.
- WarDores 7y agoI can't refute the statistical point, but even if it is a small minority, the ones that do have a negative effect can be catastrophic. A vanishingly small percentage of wild animal bites transmit rabies, but we still treat the bites seriously with a vaccine because the consequences of being wrong are much worse than the consequences of a false positive.
- jstarfish 7y agoBut you do. That gut bacteria doesn't grow in a vacuum; it has to be introduced. Refusing to eat with shit-hands doesn't save you from possibly requiring a fecal transplant later to compensate for our social constructs. That said, for the sake of invitation to any future dinner parties I do wash my hands, but while also understanding that if we were meant to be chemically "pure" then antibiotics would not destroy our guts just the same as that gastric infection.
- raverbashing 7y agoYour initial gut bacteria "infection" most likely comes from your mother (through a couple of possible means), though there seems to be some scientific questions about that. Otherwise, while you could get good bacteria from the environment, you'll also highly likely to get some bad pathogens as well, especially in urban environments. Or even worse, helminthic infections. You could have fecal transplant candidates try several unwashed food sources and see what happens.
- agumonkey 7y agoMedical inertia. Role of gut microbiome is only a recent trend. Soon we'll probably see change in nutrition and medical advices.