4 ms·
> we're talking Chromium, the underlying browser engine. As it stands, Chromium is the basis for a variety of browsers, not just Google's flagship. From what I
by quicklime 7y ago
> we're talking Chromium, the underlying browser engine. As it stands, Chromium is the basis for a variety of browsers, not just Google's flagship. From what I can tell (as a non-expert on Chromium's source, so please correct me), the Googley stuff that makes privacy advocates nervous is independent from the core Chromium browser engine
This might be just me being pedantic, but I thought it might be worth mentioning...
Chromium is basically the same thing as Chrome, except that it's missing a few proprietary blobs that Google is not legally allowed to put into Chromium: some DRM stuff, a licensed H.264 codec, a Flash plugin, etc. But if you're worried about privacy, Chromium still has all the Googley stuff. You can still log into Chromium with your Google account, and it'll sync your bookmarks and history and passwords just like Chrome. Chrome extensions are 100% compatible with Chromium, and you can install them into Chromium via the Chrome Web Store.
Some people might be familiar with "Blink", which is the browser engine (and is a fork of WebKit). There's also V8, which is the JavaScript VM. These two components aren't enough to form a usable browser though. So the Chromium Project develops what is called the "Content module" (see https://www.chromium.org/developers/content-module https://www.chromium.org/developers/content-module) which combines Blink and V8, and some other pieces, to form a basic web browser. This is what other browsers (like Opera, and I presume Edge as well) are built on top of, and does not contain all the Google integrations that Chrome/Chromium have.
While Content is missing a lot of the Chrome features that make privacy advocates nervous, it's still a problem because most Chromium/Content developers are Googlers, and will probably not implement things like WebKit's ITP or canvas fingerprinting prevention.
- oldmanhorton 7y agoEdge basically takes the entire chromium product including the //chrome layer, but we have removed or disabled most/all of the Google service integrations
- rvnx 7y agoWhich is needed anyway, because you are not allowed (even as Microsoft) to use Google APIs keys. If you don't remove these services, Chromium doesn't build or will be rejected by Google Play. So it's nothing special.
- mda 7y agoAnd will replace them with Microsoft versions and will declare soon that Edge is the new savior of humanity because it doesn't contain the evilness anymore.
- Terretta 7y agoAnd “Edge” and “Chrome” both ship on iOS using WebKit.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Terretta 7y agoAnd this is why dropping back to the WebKit that Blink came from is not a terrible strategy, especially since it underpins the best integrated (battery life etc.) browser for MacOS and only browser engine on iPad and iPhone. I’d like to see the privacy conscious “user agency” browser builders pivot back to WebKit.