3 ms·
Almost everyone. Radio nowadays is just a RF frontend + ADC/DAC block + DSP. RF is the magic grey beards part, but can be quickly solved with off the shelf part
by rasz 7y ago
Almost everyone. Radio nowadays is just a RF frontend + ADC/DAC block + DSP. RF is the magic grey beards part, but can be quickly solved with off the shelf parts. Conversion is also easy off the shelf, or even integrated into rf chip. DSP is where patents come into play and dragons live during implementation phase, but its more or less all software, Apple is good at software.
- supahfly_remix 7y ago> RF is the magic grey beards part, but can be quickly solved with off the shelf parts. What do you mean by "off the shelf parts"? A competitive phone chipset is going to have integrated RF and digital baseband. Because of size constraints, you can't mix and match ICs and have any hope of fitting into a small form factor.
- orbifold 7y agoI think he means that there will be a few components that will be able to develop that IP for you. That is certainly the case for PLLs and other analog bits of digital designs.
- rasz 7y agoI mean RF is a solved problem, there are no secrets in that part of modem design anymore. You can pick an off the shelf cable modem RF frontend (AD9866 etc) and implement 4G baseband. What you will need is experienced software people and IP rights. On a tangential note Intel totally screwed DOCSIS modem chipsets, after taking over TI's Puma product line, by stuffing it with x86 cores and assigning work experience students to write firmware, after all everyone can code x86, right? :) Puma 6/7 can be DOSed by as little as 10KB/s stream. Supposedly there are firmware fixes, but from what I gather they just move critical processing tasks from integrated x86 cores to external ARM SoC - prevents DOSing, but latency issues persist.
- scarface74 7y agoThis is completely out of my area of expertise. But if that’s the case, why is it so much easier (relatively) for Apple to design processors with better thermals and lower power requirements than anyone in the world, soon will be able to design better GPUs for mobile (not high end GPUs) than any other company in the world, but can’t design cellular chips in house just as “easily”?
- knolan 7y agoMy limited understanding is that Apple A series chops benefited initially from expensive manual layout while many ARM chips of that time were using more machine driven layouts. Also Apple, as Apple does, city out a lot of legacy bits and pieces that Wintel are expected to support. So leaner more rigorously designed chips. Of course I could be off the mark here. As usual Anandtech has excellent deep dives into various SoCs: https://www.anandtech.com/show/11596/techinsights-confirms-apple-a10x-soc-10nm-tsmc https://www.anandtech.com/show/11596/techinsights-confirms-a... https://www.anandtech.com/show/9824/more-on-apples-a9x-soc https://www.anandtech.com/show/9824/more-on-apples-a9x-soc