6 ms·
Some of this advice echoes that in Fundamentals of Piano Practice by Chaun C. Chang. https://fundamentals-of-piano-practice.readthedocs.io/en/latest/ https://f
by kazinator 7y ago
Some of this advice echoes that in Fundamentals of Piano Practice by Chaun C. Chang.
https://fundamentals-of-piano-practice.readthedocs.io/en/latest/ https://fundamentals-of-piano-practice.readthedocs.io/en/lat...
Chang precisely recommends the same thing: don't just practice by going through pieces from beginning to end repeatedly. Being a scientist, he quantifies that with efficiency arguments, which are along these lines: if a five minute piece contains two-bar difficult passage, then you can only practice that passage twelve times in the span of one hour. If the passage is only ten seconds long, you can practice it twelve times in just two minutes, which is 30 times more efficient.
One tools is to use a metronome to find the stress passages in a piece. Without a metronome, we hide the stressful passages by slowing down subconsciously.
Set the metronome at a baseline rate at which you can play everything. Then gradually crank up the speed. Then the stress points show up: passages where you fumble.
Chang makes astonishingly clever observations about speed. Basically, speed has two extremes that are easy: very slow, or super fast. It's just as hard to slow down from high speed playing as it is to speed up slow playing. The initial argument he makes is that there is no faster way to play three notes than to just hit a three note chord with three fingers, which is easy, and "infinitely fast". Moreover, it is basically easy to slow down from that "infinite speed" a little bit; if we hit the chord so that the fingers are staggered slightly, we will play a fast arpeggio. A really fast run of notes is like that: hitting groups of notes in this manner, and changing the hand position in between those groups.
- Pimpus 7y agoHah, that is an excellent book. I remember it pissed off one of my friends who claimed that slow practice is the best way to learn. Glad I didn't listen to him, I use these techniques when learning all kinds of stuff. Glenn Gould practiced by playing fast: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qB76jxBq_gQ https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qB76jxBq_gQ
- brooklyn_ashey 7y agoGlen Gould also practiced by playing slowly and very slowly and so on. He practiced by singing and not playing, and yes by playing at speed and as has been mentioned as something bad... he practiced pieces sll the way through for hours on end
- devin 7y agoMy guitar professor in college would have me pick up from random points in a piece of music at speed. Another reply on this thread suggested that practicing slow is categorically bad. This isn't true. There is value in not locking in bad habits by being deliberate at low speed. I had never heard this about playing fast, though. Subjective as it may be, I always abhorred the "shredding" set, because it felt like a cheap trick rather than skillful playing.
- dvlsg 7y agoI agree that practicing slow is helpful. Certainly helps my drumming quite a bit. And not only mixing up slow/fast, but loud/soft, too.
- kazinator 7y agoChang claims that slow practice is valuable, just not so slow that you change the "gait" of your motions. Walking isn't the same motion as running; we wouldn't practice running by walking. But not all running practice is a sprint. He says that it's a mistake to learn pieces too slowly and try to speed up from there precisely because of this "gait" issue.As you speed up, you have to unlearn the wrong motions that do not work at full speed and replace them with different ones.
- Tade0 7y agoAs you speed up, you have to unlearn the wrong motions that do not work at full speed and replace them with different ones. I don't know about piano, but at least in my experience with electric guitar the key to playing fast was to decouple the "gait" from speed by reducing wrist movements and using the elbow more.
- ves 7y agoeconomy of motion works wonders, but even then sometimes there are positions which have the same economy but may be dramatically easier at speed, and you need to play closer to tempo to learn that. Sometimes it's even better to trade away lots of small adjustments to avoid one big one, because you can't hit the big one at tempo.
- stcredzero 7y agoOne tools is to use a metronome to find the stress passages in a piece. Without a metronome, we hide the stressful passages by slowing down subconsciously. It's striking how one's self-perception can be faulty this way. I've had this sort of thing pointed out to me by a bandmate, years ago, using a tape recorder and a metronome. It's like I was in a Sci-fi time-distortion, not because the tempo change was that large, but because it was so invisible to me without the recording and metronome!
- agumonkey 7y agoEffects of metronome are quite insane. Even physically, as a faux drummer, playing with a stable time reference allows for so much more regularity you can be physically efficient, meaning more relaxed, less exhausting music playing (basically energy optimization). Then there's the mind massaging from perception of time .. Having a metronome is almost like a trance device.
- cormacrelf 7y agoTempo is also one of the best expressive devices for performance. The mind massaging works in reverse! Lots of great choruses bump the bpm significantly, and the prevalence of recording and performing to click tracks has made it rare to have the kind of fluidity that you can get without them. You want to be able to manipulate your internal metronome expressively. I'm not a drummer, but definitely something to work on for every musician.
- vonseel 7y agothe prevalence of recording and performing to click tracks has made it rare to have the kind of fluidity that you can get without them. Performing to a click is not nearly as lifeless as a hard-quantized MIDI production without live instruments. Sure, it may not have drastic tempo changes like a drummer who isn’t listening to a click, but it still has human variation. Making MIDI programming sound convincing and realistic is not an easy task
- 7y ago
- relativeadv 7y agoWhat an amazing resource. Thank you for sharing.
- kazinator 7y agoLooking at it again, I'm taking more notice of the piano tuning chapter which I totally forgot about. I've done some piano tuning not long ago; I will re-read that in the light of my experiences.
- graeme 7y agoHow can people find these stress passages in skills that are more mental and have less discrete external feedback?
- jchook 7y agoCan you unpack this for me?
- komali2 7y agoLike an activity that isn't playing piano. Chess, maybe. Or writing. How do you find a "stress passage" in writing?
- moron4hire 7y agoEasy. What sort of writings do you put off the most? Do you fail to write replies to text messages but find yourself easily jumping into long threads on message boards? Or do you put off formal documentation in favor of a series of short notes? What are you not doing? That is what you should focus on, by deliberately going out of your way to put yourself into situations that require you to do it more.
- ralphstodomingo 7y agoI would guess that e.g. in writing, for example, you'd have to find a way to iterate quicker (attempt writing short articles as practice rather than longform), and set bounds on yourself that induce strain (limiting yourself to not edit anything at the first pass until you finish, having a draft worked on for a very long amount of time?) and reviewing every pass you make to see where you could have improved. I may be wrong though.
- jancsika 7y ago> If the passage is only ten seconds long, you can practice it twelve times in just two minutes, which is 30 times more efficient. Your example timing makes me suspicious that this is a theory you haven't actually tried to put into practice yet. Ten seconds is an eternity for a drill of a difficult passage. For an amateur, that's almost guaranteed to be too much music for them to isolate the difficulty. That means instead of a success rate of 100% on the drill they'll get something considerably less. For an amateur, "difficulty" usually means they were already playing it wrong before they began drilling it. So any mistakes in the drill help reinforce the initial muscle memory for that passage. That makes it extremely likely that they'll repeat the same mistake when you add an audience and nerves. Drilling passages that are too long does at least decrease the chance of the player losing their place-- they have practiced starting at various spots that aren't simply the beginning. But they are only "30 times more efficient" at playing the piece with an unnecessarily high error rate.
- LeicaLatte 7y agoThe guitar games use these metronome training methods and are very effective.
- vanous 7y agoYes. Good music teacher will highlight passages to practice, rather than asking students to keep repeating the full length.
- holri 7y agoA fast arpeggio is a complete different motion than playing single notes and also completely different motion than playing a chord. Therefore a chord or arpeggio is not a fast scale. He is comparing apples and oranges.
- huehehue 7y agoGuitar virtuoso Shawn Lane offers another approach, where you attempt to learn very difficult passages by jumping right into it at the correct speed. The idea here is that, by slowly speeding up, you end up using low-speed mechanics on high-speed passages and it doesn't always work. It's not for the faint of heart, but if you find yourself struggling it's certainly worth trying.