3 ms·
You've got 20 magic integers with no explanation in the source. Java version does not contain that.
by viraptor 7y ago
You've got 20 magic integers with no explanation in the source. Java version does not contain that.
- hjek 7y agoYup. Magic integers are bad for readability. So are "magic phrases", like public static void. I think the readability of Pd is horrible, but the question was whether it was human readable at all.
- viraptor 7y agoI don't think they're in the similar category at all. Keywords are part of the syntax - if you know what they are in one place, you know what they are in another. (even if they have multiple meanings) Magic numbers are use-specific and you need extra context to understand them. They're part of the code, not the language itself - although the language can help the situation by enforcing naming in some cases.
- hjek 7y agoWell, I think many programming keywords have a form of meaning that you need extra context to understand. How would I intuitively could guess what 'public static void' was, withing having any idea about OO or Java? I mean, 'void' is perhaps OK, but don't tell me you could understand 'swing' with no context, just by reading the word?