5 ms·
The queue for getting your video posted on YouTube would grow infinitely. (Or, more realistically, people would give up and not bother once it takes years.) Bu
by skybrian 7y ago
The queue for getting your video posted on YouTube would grow infinitely. (Or, more realistically, people would give up and not bother once it takes years.)
But I guess they could charge money to get to the head of the line?
- ilikehurdles 7y agoThe queue for having your video uploaded and public does not at all have to be the same queue for getting your video included in others' recommendations.
- nostrademons 7y agoI can just see the outrage now: "YouTube running a pay-to-play scheme for exposure. Anyone can upload their video, but only the rich can get an audience!" Come to think of it, this is basically the complaint against AdWords and the gradual takeover of the search result page by paid results.
- shearskill 7y agoThis is exactly what happens. Prager U and Ben Shapiro advertise heavily on content adjacent to them (gaming) and their views go up, up they go in the algorithm.
- PretzelFisch 7y agoThat's not true you can upload a video and not allow it to be recommended until some human review was done. Most youtube channels don't need the recommendation engine.
- LocalPCGuy 7y agoThat just isn't feasible. Videos would literally take years to get into the recommended status - another comment pointed out there are 500 new videos uploaded per SECOND.
- munk-a 7y agoIf there was one dude, sure. But apparently YouTube is in the business of supporting the upload of 500 videos/second so they need to deal with the consequences of it. It's not like there's any regulation forcing them to be the place everyone uploads videos to and there are some valid competitors (though they're far less into the publishing/editorializing facet - vimeo is much more often direct linked for instance)
- andromeduck 7y agoSo you don't support freedom of expression?
- FabHK 7y agoA service just hosting videos (without recommending some of them) would be just fine.
- skybrian 7y agoCould search engines index them? Would YouTube's search list them? In what order?
- jasode 7y ago>A service just hosting videos (without recommending some of them) would be just fine. It might be "just fine" in an abstract principle kind of way. However, reality would not support such a site because of human preferences. The problem is that viewers want recommendations (both in search results and followup related videos) and content creators want to be promoted (to get views and ad revenue or sponsorships). This means a video site with recommendations will outcompete a "dumb storage" video site where surfers must know the url for each video they want to play.
- munk-a 7y agoPerhaps it means that editorializing as a service is necessarily a business that needs to be kept separate from the hosting of videos - sort of like the older style of curated link lists that directed users to particularly interesting content existing beside the DNS service that stored an unbiased record of all content.
- v7p1Qbt1im 7y ago> Most youtube channels don't need the recommendation engine. This is just not true. A massive part of the views originate from recommended/up next. Ask pretty much any creator. Only the core audience of a channel will have the notification bell on for a specific channel. Many users don't check the Subscription section and either link in from an external source, know beforehand what they want to search for or just watch what pops up in recommended.
- hrktb 7y agoThere could be a middle ground where videos have limited visibility until getting vetted, or a karma system to fast track regular uploaders etc. I think there’s a ton of ideas to be tried.