2 ms·
Today, we make the statement "a sea-battle will be fought tomorrow". Two days from now, the equivalent statement is "a sea-battle was fought yesterday". That
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
Today, we make the statement "a sea-battle will be fought tomorrow". Two days from now, the equivalent statement is "a sea-battle was fought yesterday". That statement is either true or false. As far as I can see, this leaves two possible views.
First view: The statement today is true or false, just as it will be two days from now. But today we don't know whether it's true or false.
Second view: The statement today is neither true nor false, but it will become true or false tomorrow, and will therefore be either true or false two days from now.
Pick whichever view you like. The argument is going to come down to differences of (unstated) definition of what it means for a statement to be true.