5 ms·
> Those who voluntarily declared their deposit-box holdings would be taxed at a low rate of about 15 percent, he added. In what world is a wealth tax of 15% a
by sokoloff 7y ago
> Those who voluntarily declared their deposit-box holdings would be taxed at a low rate of about 15 percent, he added.
In what world is a wealth tax of 15% a "low rate"?!
- kokojie 7y agoSome European country tax 90% of income...
- manderley 7y ago> Some European country tax 90% of income... This is untrue.
- NightlyDev 7y agoIf I make a sale in Norway for 100 NOK: Business VAT: 20 spent (20 %) 80 NOK left. Income tax: 39 spent (max ~49 %) 41 NOK left. VAT on purchase: 8.2 spent (20 %) 32.8 NOK left. 67.2 % taxes. If I spend my money on gas/diesel then I would have ~16 NOK of value left. (84 % taxes) About 18 % of the income tax I'll get back during my pension. So 90 % is probably achievable on some things in some countries.
- plantain 7y agoHuh? Why are you accounting for VAT twice? Either you consider that the business 'pays' the VAT or you 'pay' the VAT, you don't get it both ways.
- NightlyDev 7y agoIt is both ways, for me. My business pays VAT on sales, and I personally pay VAT on purchases, so for me and my business VAT will be paid twice. Both for what I sold and what I(personally) purchased.
- plantain 7y agoEither the consumer is paying the VAT or the business. You can't say that the business pays the VAT when you are the business, but the consumer pays the VAT when you are the consumer. If you frame it as you "personally purchased" something and paid VAT, then what you sold as a business to someone else was "personally purchased" and had the VAT paid by them too.
- mrzool 7y agoSource? European, never heard of this. Though a 15% rate is pretty normal around here.
- NightlyDev 7y agoIncome tax? Sure. Wealth tax? No, of course not, then investments would basically never be a good idea.
- Symbiote 7y agoIt's existed in the past. Look up the lyrics for the Beatles song "Taxman", "There's one for you, nineteen for me".
- lm28469 7y agoYeah, and all americans have guns and ford f150. /s https://tradingeconomics.com/country-list/personal-income-tax-rate?continent=europe https://tradingeconomics.com/country-list/personal-income-ta...
- arethuza 7y agoEven the US had a 94% tax rate on income over $200,000 in 1944 and 1945: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_tax_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_tax_in_the_United_State... Mind you - at the same time it looks like the UK had a comparable taxation rate of over 99%.
- jankotek 7y agoI recall income tax over 110%. It was author in scandinavian country. 70% is pretty normal if you count all compulsory insurances.
- oarsinsync 7y agoThat seems unlikely. Work and earn 100, and owe the government 110; or dont work / earn 0, owe the government 0? Being net negative for productivity is literally counterproductive.
- jankotek 7y agohttps://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/15235/did-swedish-tax-rate-ever-exceed-100 https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/15235/did-swedi...
- jules 7y agoThat's marginal tax rate. Many people pay an effective marginal tax rate of more than 100% if you include government programs like social housing. In fact, when you earn around €2200/month here, it is possible to end up with net less than if you don't work at all, due to various programs.
- scott_s 7y agoThe accepted answer explains why that is not a tax over 100%.
- Strom 7y agoReaching 90% is hard, even if you count additional taxes. Take Sweden, where you first remove 31.42% social tax, then 60% income tax, then 25% VAT. You will still end up with 24% of money left of the initial payroll.
- NightlyDev 7y agoIf I make a sale in Norway for 100 NOK: Business VAT: 20 spent (20 %) 80 NOK left. Income tax: 39 spent (max ~49 %) 41 NOK left. VAT on purchase: 8.2 spent (20 %) 32.8 NOK left. 67.2 % taxes. If I spend my money on gas/diesel then I would have ~16 NOK of value left. (84 % taxes) About 18 % of the income tax I'll get back during my pension. So 90 % is probably achievable on some things in some countries.
- mmustapic 7y agoYou are not spending the first 20 NOK of your sale, you are just collecting them from the customer. If VAT was 0% then your sale would be for 80 NOK.
- NightlyDev 7y agoSure I am. If I didn't have to collect VAT then I could sell for 100 NOK instead. It's not my money, but I still have to bill for it and pay it. The customer doesn't get a better product or service because of it.
- sokoloff 7y agoIf the customer didn't pay the VAT, they'd end up paying their taxes some other way and still have less money to spend on your products.
- markvdb 7y agoThis is about enticing tax evaders to come clean. The 15% rate supposedly includes back taxes on some forms of undeclared income. Knowing the official Italian tax rates, that would make it a very compelling deal. Many tax evaders would basicly be taxed at a much lower rate than had they paid their taxes correctly in the first place.
- NightlyDev 7y agoHas to be 15 % of the normal tax or something like that. Wealth tax in Italy is rather low, so 15 % of that would probably be more like 0.1 %.
- mises 7y agoThis isn't even a tax. Here's the dictionary definition: "A compulsory contribution to state revenue, levied by the government on workers' income and business profits, or added to the cost of some goods, services, and transactions." (google) Taxing is adding a cost to an existing transaction, not taking a cut of money arbitrarily. The idea of a wealth tax is literally the government just stealing money. The American government, for instance couldn't do this. We had to pass an amendment to allow income tax; there is no such amendment for "wealth tax". This is a result of Pollock v Farmers' Loan and Trust Co., which affirmed the government directly stealing wealth is unconstitutional. If you'd rather call it theft or confiscation, fine, but not a tax. Most importantly, we've got the Fifth Amendment: "nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation". This means that you could only impose a "wealth tax" if you convinced a court to rule that ninety-nine cents was just compensation for a dollar. I guess we're just moving closer to "the mob" seizing the property of others, just because its constituents want it more.
- coldtea 7y ago>I guess we're just moving closer to "the mob" seizing the property of others, just because its constituents want it more. Well, the law is either what some people want to be or what a majority/plurality of people want to be. The first is not very democratic and can be self serving for the private interests of a few. If the latter however want a wealth tax, or even if they propose that "90% of wealth should be made public" then that could be made into law, regardless of what the constitution says. That wouldn't be "mob" but just law. In fact, the "Fifth Amendment" is already an amendment, showing that the constitution is already not a un-alterable source of divine guidance. At some point, perhaps the whole of the constitution could be considered a BS product of its own time, and replaced with a different set of operating rules.
- leetcrew 7y agowhat is desired by a majority/plurality of citizens is pretty much orthogonal to justice.
- 7y ago
- Lucadg 7y agoThat's low in Italy where the we are used to 50% taxes.
- sokoloff 7y agoNot on wealth, you're not. Assets sitting in a safety deposit box are wealth, not income. Wealth taxes, where assessed, are typically low single digit percent or sub-1%.
- tecleandor 7y agoThis isn't about wealth. They say in the news that they are talking about undeclared income hiding in safes.
- sokoloff 7y agoAh, so it's an income tax evasion holiday (or dirty money cleaning service fee). Article positioned it like it was a wealth tax (that would apply to legitimate savings as well as ill-gotten gains in safety deposit boxes).
- tecleandor 7y agoFirst income tax bracket in Italy is 23%. In Spain I think I'm paying a bit less than 30%. https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/work/taxes/income-taxes-abroad/italy/index_en.htm https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/work/taxes/income-taxe...