6 ms·
Court: Photographer has no recourse against university copyright infringement
- deogeo 7y ago...does this mean the US government doesn't have to respect copyright? Seems unusual...
- vokep 7y agoApparently so, according to the university's defense they have sovereign immunity so its no biggie.
- drivingmenuts 7y agoThis was in state court. Federal laws may be different.
- hfkajshfaks 7y agoConstitutionally, they aren't. But congress passed laws waiving S.I. in some cases. Of course, laws can be repealed.
- michaelhoffman 7y agoThe U.S. has waived sovereign immunity by statute for various classes of suit.
- smalley 7y agoIt seems like at least parts of the government argue that any government copying is inherently fair use http://www.loc.gov/flicc/gc/fairuse.html http://www.loc.gov/flicc/gc/fairuse.html Fun fact, the government opinion for patents for the government and its contractors is also that the federal government cannot be found to infringe on patents either. At most they say they voluntarily choose to provide reasonable compensation. This especially applies if the use of a patent is deemed to be in the interest of national security.
- dahfizz 7y agoThe US government has sovereign immunity, just like Texas claims here. The difference is that a Federal court can overrule a state's SI. Nobody can overrule the federal government's SI, meaning the federal government cannot be sued for any reason unless it agrees to be sued and forfeits SI in that case. How do people not know this?
- Doctor_Fegg 7y ago...because not everyone on HN is American?
- Ace17 7y agoWhose role is it to enforce copyright?
- lloydde 7y ago> Olive tried the [unlawful “taking”] approach after the University of Houston rejected his claim that the public university should pay for a photo it used without permission in web and print publications, contending the university has sovereign immunity, a well-established legal principle that protects a state from getting sued.
- erichurkman 7y ago> Olive tried the approach after the University of Houston rejected his claim that the public university should pay for a photo it used without permission in web and print publications, contending the university has sovereign immunity, a well-established legal principle that protects a state from getting sued. Terrifying. So the University of Houston claims they can just steal whatever they want?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- FireBeyond 7y agoAnd if you challenge them on it, Texas courts will find you liable for the University's legal costs, too!
- AstralStorm 7y agoThen you challenge the claim in a federal court because you've exhausted recourse in the takings claim. If that's where Texas wants to go, so be it.
- hfkajshfaks 7y agoIt's sovereign immunity. Any state agency can do whatever it wants and claim immunity unless the Feds get involved. The Feds can do whatever they want full stop. The only constraint is that the state can allow itself to be sued, and therefore you have some recourse that way.
- dahfizz 7y agoIts shocking and depressing that so few Americans are aware of this.
- cryptonector 7y agoAnd whatever constraints the courts interpret the constitutions as imposing on the state.
- sk5t 7y agoAnother clever move by Texas secessionists in their strategy to make the state too unpalatable to deal with or in.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't use HN for regional battle.
- sk5t 7y agoYou've assumed malice where none was intended. Downvotes before self-redacting, nevertheless.
- dang 7y agoNo malice assumed! just reacting to how the comment appears on the surface, because that's how most readers are going to perceive it. If your intent was otherwise, you need to make that explicit. Intent doesn't translate by default on the internet, unfortunately.
- caf 7y agoSo does this mean that Texas schools, prisons, universities, hospitals etc can freely copy and use commercial software, films, books and other similar works? It seems like under this precedent the University of Houston could just create their own copies of whatever textbooks they want for their students, potentially even selling those copies.
- m463 7y agoI took a language class in Mexico, and the textbooks were photocopies, which I was told could legally be used.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoI guess that any out of state company would be able to sue Texas in federal court, where Texas' weird laws do not apply, and they cannot invoke sovereign immunity. But if the company is incorporated in Texas and only does business in the state, I guess the answer is yes? Not a lawyer or anything, but this is my reading. Since no interstate commerce is happening here, the photographer cannot sue in federal court. Edit: I think what I wrote above is wrong, having read a link in one of the other comments. All the same, my guess is that states are not going to be skipping payment on Windows licenses and taking on Microsoft in the courts. But they may be able to continue picking on little guys who have no power, as it has ever been.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> I guess that any out of state company would be able to sue Texas in federal court, where Texas' weird laws do not apply, and they cannot invoke sovereign immunity. “The Judicial power of the United States shall not be construed to extend to any suit in law or equity, commenced or prosecuted against one of the United States by Citizens of another State, or by Citizens or Subjects of any Foreign State.” —US Constitution, Amendment XI
- zdragnar 7y agoThe supreme court has, however, held that federal courts can enjoin states from violating federal law, and copyright infringement is a federal offense under Title 17 of the US Legal Code.
- droithomme 7y agoReading the article solves one mystery, but brings up another. The photographer for some reason did not pursue this as a copyright infringement claim. Instead he argued that it was an eminent domain case where the state had seized his private property and was, according to Texas state law, required to compensate him for the seized property. It would be sufficient at this point for the state to rule that copyright infringement is not the same as eminent domain seizures, rule against him, and order him to pay the defendant's costs for filing a frivolous case. Instead they oddly ruled instead that the school has sovereign immunity from lawsuits, and ordered him to pay their costs. It is strange if the state can not be held accountable in court for eminent domain seizures despite the state law to the contrary. It is strange that they ruled that way rather than ruling that copyright infringement is not a domain seizure. It is strange that the plaintiff filed this case this way.
- LurkersWillLurk 7y agoI agree. I feel that the case would have ended up much differently if he had sued in his federal District Court.
- ccleve 7y agoSovereign immunity is the legal doctrine that the government can't be sued for anything unless it specifically allows you to do so. In this case, Texas state law does not have a provision that allows it to be sued for copyright infringement. So, the photographer could not file a claim for copyright infringement, either in state or federal court. That's why he tried the novel approach of suing them under the "takings" clause of the US Constitution. The Bill of Rights is a specific case where the government has allowed itself to be sued for violating those provisions. Under Supreme Court precedent, most provisions of the Bill of Rights apply to the states as well as to the federal government.
- eximius 7y ago> Sovereign immunity is the legal doctrine that the government can't be sued for anything unless it specifically allows you to do so. I recognize why this exists, but I can't help but wonder why people working in government are so prepared/eager to defend the actions of the government or avoid admitting wrongdoing at any cost. Just admit, 'hey, yeah, we should have paid. We aren't required to because, like, immunity, but it would be the right thing to do. Here's some money.' and move on. Or when cops and DAs use some sketchy means of doing something good, like stingrays. Is there no sense of, hey, maybe we shouldn't have this power. We should self-regulate or get legislation made. It's not even against self-preservation as those tools made them better at their jobs, in theory, reducing the need for more people. I just feel like the people in our government, at all, levels, could be more honest. Politics makes me sad. :(
- Mathnerd314 7y agoA similar case is pending in the Supreme Court: https://blog.ericgoldman.org/archives/2019/06/statute-of-queen-annes-revenge-supreme-court-grants-certiorari-in-allen-v-cooper.htm https://blog.ericgoldman.org/archives/2019/06/statute-of-que... They directly sued for copyright infringement rather than trying to use eminent domain.
- merryandrew 7y agoThis makes no sense. Imagine that SpaceX took a photograph on the moon, and then a university freely used the image in its marketing materials. Would that make sense? Would it make any more sense if the university had a space program? No.
- skunkworker 7y agoSpaceX isn’t the greatest example here. They commonly release their photos into the public domain with a Creative Commons waiving all copyright and related or neighboring rights to their work. Though the point still stands with photographers and photo releases in general.
- merryandrew 7y agoAgreed. As you realized, though, the point is that copyrighted work should not be used without compensating the creator.
- skunkworker 7y agoCompletely, if I’m a photographer in Texas I would be worried about the effect of this ruling on my work. It’s hard for people to understand when they hire a photographer that even though they paid for images and prints they might not even have the right to modify and/or print more. But this sidesteps that completely.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoA lot of problems around copyright is a self-inflicted mess caused by (IMO) wrong abstractions, not reflecting the nature of the works and the media. For instance, photography has an issue of copyrights on buildings, which is prima facie a ridiculous concept, but it is recognized to some extent around the world, including in the US.
- hfkajshfaks 7y agoIf it's a state university then, yes, they could claim Sovereign immunity.
- userbinator 7y agoIt's very bizarre to see this seemingly very pro-public-domain/anti-copyright/anti-IP decision given the reputation that Texas has for patent trolls.
- tedivm 7y agoIt's not pro public domain though, it's basically just saying that copyright doesn't apply to the government.
- icebraining 7y agoNot really, because thedefendent didn't claim copyright infringement (which the Texas courts couldn't rule on anyway, they would have had to go to federal court).
- dragonwriter 7y agoThe US (federal) District Court for the Eastern District of Texas has that reputation, due to local rules which attracted patent cases (IIRC, recent case law has restricted the kind of forum shopping involved in that), but that has little to do with the laws or judicial system of the State of Texas.
- sailfast 7y agoI was under the impression that sovereign immunity only applied to suing of state actors (ie employees / officials, etc) but I guess it can be applied writ-large to entire institutions as well based on the copyright infringement ruling? Sounds like a job for the state legislature to handle - writing out an exception to immunity for infringement. Otherwise why would anyone bother attempting to do licensed work in Texas at all?
- qtplatypus 7y agoThe immunity from copyright and patent claims is critical to universty researches. Without it basic research would get mired in patent and copyright claims. Many would be eventually ruled as fair use but that requires a judge to make a judgement as to the fair use factors. SI just requires the judge to see that it is the uni of Texas. The uni doesnt care about the photographers licence fee. It cares about not getting by a phama company because a researcher happened to use a chemical that was under patent.
- tssva 7y agoPlenty of research gets done by corporations, private universities, and research institutes with needing immunity from copyright and patent claims. If public universities want immunity from copyright and patent claims then the resulting research should not be able to be copyrighted or patented.
- fencepost 7y agoI'm kind of curious about whether he'd have options to pursue this under the DMCA. Are there legal grounds for the University to ignore takedown notices? I'm seeing things that say the university has immunity against being sued for infringement (not sure quite why, state vs federal jurisdiction), but that's a different thing.
- test6554 7y agoSo could universities embed an entire textbook in their course descriptions? Could they post full feature films on their websites?