6 ms·
I wonder, given the rising popularity of atheism, how many of the people described in the study fall under the unthinking atheist, in the same way someone raise
by SketchySeaBeast 7y ago
I wonder, given the rising popularity of atheism, how many of the people described in the study fall under the unthinking atheist, in the same way someone raised by Christians or in Christian peer-groups can easily become Christian without conscience thought? It stands to reason that as it gains in popularity, atheism would appear more like the general population. I feel like the ‘convinced, dogmatic atheists’ is a group that's become the minority.
- User23 7y agoThere’s an argument to be made that court enforced public atheism violates the establishment clause.
- darth_skywalker 7y agoPerhaps, but it's impossible to judge the merit of said argument since you failed to make it. I don't know what you mean by "court enforced public atheism." The right to express your religious views is protected in the United States by the 1st Amendment. And on the contrary, U.S. currency reads "In God we trust."
- BackBackBack 7y agoOnly if you redefine atheism to mean theism, as in "they believe in atheism! Can't you see?"
- User23 7y agoAtheism is a positive belief system. It actively asserts special gnosis of God’s nonexistence which effectively makes it a particularly bare-boned form of Protestantism. Agnosticism on the other hand isn’t a religion, it’s just intellectual humility or maybe just laziness.
- BackBackBack 7y agoSee, you’ve redefine it. If you assert “gnosis” then you are not talking about belief you are talking about knowledge. Gnostics claim to know there is a god, Agnostics claim they do not know if there are gods. But I’m an Atheist. Why? Because I do not BELIEVE there are gods. I have not made any claims. I have not asserted anything. I simply find all the arguments in favor of gods lacking. Atheism IS NOT a positive belief system, but simply the rejection of one.
- woodruffw 7y ago> Atheism is a positive belief system. It actively asserts special gnosis of God’s nonexistence which effectively makes it a particularly bare-boned form of Protestantism. Asserting the nonexistence of something is not asserting special knowledge of something's nonexistence. Atheism isn't a Platonic Beard[1]. On a more practical level: if Protestants and atheists don't find their views mutually intelligible, there probably isn't any really meaningful sense in which one is a "bare-boned form" of the other. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plato%27s_beard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plato%27s_beard
- satellitec4t 7y agoAtheism is just a-theism, not-theism. If you are not a theist ("i believe in a god or gods"), you are an atheist. You can be atheist and agnostic - most atheists are.
- sklivvz1971 7y agoI'm sorry, but that's just incorrect. Atheists are people who assert "I do not believe in God" and not, "I believe there is no God." It can not be otherwise, because the opposite makes no logical sense. Which God would the correct one to "believe against"? There are infinite Gods that one must equally disbelieve. Not believing in Zeus, Jupiter, Odin, Ra, Yahveh, and the flying spaghetti monster does not require any evidence at all, it's merely the default position which any rational person must take. Atheists merely believe in one God less than believers.
- User23 7y agoI appreciate the sophistry, but it just doesn't accurately describe the empirical reality. Western atheists are observably interested in the nonexistence of the biblical God. As you correctly note, none of them define themselves by, say, disbelief in Trimurti. I doubt they even think about it. Furthermore, every atheist I encounter actually asserts something like "I do not believe in God, because there is no God." After all "I do not believe in God, because there is a God" is irrational and, given the consequences of disbelief if God is as described in western tradition, exceedingly foolish. Atheism is only a rational belief if God is known to not exist. Otherwise it's no different than not believing in climate change or dinosaurs. And in any event a transcendent creator God (first cause, etc) isn't anything at all like the easter bunny, comic book superheroes, or bad fictional characters.
- sklivvz1971 7y agoAtheists are well aware of the distinction, I can assure you. A statement like "I do not believe in God because there is no God" proves absolutely nothing. I could tell you "I do not believe in pink unicorns because there are no pink unicorns" and you would not take it as a statement of faith, just as the obvious truth. Such a truth is also obvious about the Judeo-Muslim-Christian God to atheists: there is no evidence of God, and in particular, there is no evidence whatsoever of Yahweh. As a side note, the strange idea that Yahweh is the only "possible" God is taken as granted by religious people, but it makes really little sense to those who came to disbelief through a philosophical journey. A lot of atheists will tell you that the specificity problem is one of the most convincing reasons not to believe in God.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoI believe you're mistaking opting to not show favoritism to a particular theology for repression.
- DougN7 7y agoI bet you’re right. I find a lot of people that take a position with just a cursory overview, and that never go deep to see what that position really implies. It’s hard work and takes time.
- rootusrootus 7y ago"Dogmatic atheist"? I would laugh, but a Google search suggests that people do believe such a thing exists. Are they just talking about outspoken atheists who are openly critical of religion?
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoI would assume that to be the case - when I think of the term I think of "The Four Horsemen" - Hitchens, Dawkins, Dennet, & Harris.
- danaliv 7y agoIndeed. Christopher Hitchens called himself not just an atheist, but an "anti-theist."
- Erik816 7y agoThere is certainly a brand of atheist who is really only the flipside of a fundamentalist. One reads scripture literally in order to find it infallible, the other reads scripture literally in order to find it impossible.
- rootusrootus 7y agoI don't really like that definition too much, it feels a little off. It feels almost like the tolerance/intolerance debate, in a way. But I get it. I choose not to call myself an atheist, since it seems to have connotations beyond the simple definition. If asked for a label, I call myself ignostic. It has the upside of being easily mistaken for agnostic, therefore it sails under the radar when the topic of religion comes up. So I can be accurate without getting into what amounts to a political debate.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- __david__ 7y agoI just seems like a misunderstanding of the term "atheist" to apply the word "dogma" to it, or liken it to fundamentalism. There's no authority structure or writings to be dogmatic about…
- deogeo 7y agoOn the other hand, maybe they don't believe in any god, but do believe in the supernatural - they would still technically qualify as atheists.
- BackBackBack 7y agoYou are being downvoted because people have problems separating the two since they've been so tightly coupled for millennia at least in western civilization. But you are right, nothing in "atheism" prohibits someone believe there is an afterlife, or ghosts, or reincarnation, etc. Atheism just means you don't believe in gods; with a little imagination an afterlife can still exist without any overlords.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoTotally true - If someone felt the evidence wasn't strong enough for a creator, but there was for ghosts, that'd be totally logical. It seems unlikely, but totally possible.
- satellitec4t 7y ago> the rising popularity of atheism How can not-a-thing have rising popularity...
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoSame way "What's your favourite beer?" can have an answer of "I don't drink beer."
- satellitec4t 7y agoBut that's beer being less popular...