9 ms·
> "No we can't teach them," she said. "We try as much as we can to not interfere with the gorillas. We don't want to affect their natural behavior." Tsk. Like
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
> "No we can't teach them," she said. "We try as much as we can to not interfere with the gorillas. We don't want to affect their natural behavior."
Tsk. Like the Prime Directive but in the real world.
Well, isn't it the natural behaviour of gorillas to learn? If they can learn by observing humans, without the humans specifically intending it, then what's so different, or unethical, if it's done with intent? I think this is just splitting of moral hairs that is missing an opportunity to help the gorillas protect themselves against poachers.
Anyway, if we left the gorillas on their own, without interfering, they'd eventually be wiped out by poachers and others.
P.S. It strikes me that the center's workers could have actually shown the gorillas how to dismantle the snares and are only pretending to be surprised at their "unprecedented" behaviour. But I'm proably just paranoid and jaded.
- warent 7y agoExactly. It's more natural to allow humans to poach them out of existence than it is to potentially equip them to protect themselves from the same?
- NikolaeVarius 7y agoYes, hunting is a thing
- wavefunction 7y agoHunting poachers is a thing.
- toss1 7y agoIMO, hunting poachers should be legal, pricey, and encouraged. Sell licenses to hunt poachers, deputize them, and use the proceeds to improve protection of the wildlife. Obviously only part of the solution, but considering that the poachers, especially of elephants & rhinos are now largely part of organized crime syndicates, totally fair.
- khc 7y agoWhat happened to due process?
- xkcd-sucks 7y agoHunting licenses constitute due process, no?
- toss1 7y agoThey are getting more due process than they give their victims, which are also fully sentient, intelligent beings. As far as I'm concerned, you hunt down a gorilla, elephant or similar with a high powered rifle, trap, or poison their water source, then use a chain saw to hack out their tusk or hand to sell, you've turned in your human-card for good. At the very least, they've signed up for "Live by the sword, die by the sword". (and they at least have the ability to shoot back at their hunter, more than the elephants/gorillas have)
- xwdv 7y agoI feel that if any human was found to be teaching gorillas how to do human things, they would ultimately suffer punishment like Prometheus who taught humans how to use the fire of the gods.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoDo you think the center has a trained eagle?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gridlockd 7y ago1) Prometheus isn't real 2) The punishment of Prometheus is based on him being immortal. Humans would die after the first round. You're going to die anyway, being a martyr for the gorilla revolution doesn't seem like the worst way to go.
- Someone 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koko_(gorilla) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koko_(gorilla): ”Hanabiko "Koko" (July 4, 1971 – June 19, 2018) was a female western lowland gorilla known for having learned a large number of hand signs from a modified version of American Sign Language (ASL)” Wikipedia thinks Koko’s teacher still is alive (aged 72), so punishment certainly wasn’t swift.
- whenchamenia 7y agoReports of actual language use by Koko were famously exaggerated, and only seemed to happen with her teacher working with her. Hardly stealing fire.
- tsumnia 7y ago> If they can learn by observing humans, without the humans specifically intending it, then what's so different, or unethical, if it's done with intent? I think this might interfere with some research involving the gorillas. You cannot study their natural behaviors if you are assisting them. Not to say there isn't research teams looking to train gorillas, my point is that may not be THEIR focus. While they cannot control for poachers, they can control for them own interactions. Furthermore, not to slippery slope, but to what end do you believe they should be allowed to interfere? If, say, a diseased food source begins to decimate the group that could be prevented through cooking, should the researchers attempt to teach them how to cook the food source to kill the bacteria?
- anigbrowl 7y agoIt's a lot harder to study them if they're dead. I'm heartily in favor of assisting them to the extent they want to learn, it's possible that the more effort we make to communicate the more we'll learn ourselves. Also, if they're capable of learning then they're sapient by definition which means we have some moral obligations to them rather than being disinterested observers, because it's our species that is trying to kill them. Perhaps we should start considering them as different species of people rather than mere livestock.
- autoexec 7y agoTraining them to disarm traps could cause more harm than good. Training them to avoid traps would maybe be better. If poachers learn that their prey are hanging around the traps all day disarming them they become lures. We also don't want an arms race between poachers and trained disarmers because the poachers are at a massive advantage. Once they know a significant number of their traps will be disarmed they will just develop traps that are more difficult to disarm or even traps that hurt the animal attempting to disarm them at which point we've trained Gorillas to walk right into their traps.
- etatoby 7y agoFrom the article, the poachers are not directly hunting for gorillas or other monkeys. When they find them in the traps, they leave them there to die.
- gricardo99 7y agoI'm no wild animal training expert, but surely there's a risk training gorillas could backfire? humans training gorillas leads to gorillas being more trusting and less suspecting of humans, including poachers, or some other unintended consequences.
- Eyes 7y agoOr it triggers a cascading increase in intelligence, and they end up taking up arms and conquering us.
- RandomInteger4 7y agoThat's not how intelligence and evolution works.
- staticautomatic 7y agohttps://www.theonion.com/dolphins-evolve-opposable-thumbs-1819565718 https://www.theonion.com/dolphins-evolve-opposable-thumbs-18...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago
- jjdjr0odo7 7y agoThe Prime Directive didn’t apply to societies with Warp. Similarly, we can see gorillas are at a rudimentary evolutionary ability to organize around tasks beyond “avoid known dangerous animal” instincts. They’ve identified synthetic structures they believe to pose a threat to them. They’re organizing around changing their world to increase safety and uncertainty on their own, like we do. They’re exploring building a comfortable environment for themselves like we do. They’re on a similar trajectory of development, like a new warp drive capable species. Let’s have a beer with them and see what happens! :-D
- nkrisc 7y agoIt's always strange to me when people seem to think humans and the things we do and make aren't "natural." We evolved naturally on the this planet like all other life here did, what we do is natural.
- homonculus1 7y ago"Natural" by definition characterizes things that aren't a result of human activity. All you've realized is that it's a synthetic distinction and not a fundamental one, but if you turn around and include humans then its literally meaningless and you just lose a useful concept.