4 ms·
Nuclear is denser than gasoline but we don't run cars on it. There's a lot more to the discussion than the best technology.
by wmf 7y ago
Nuclear is denser than gasoline but we don't run cars on it. There's a lot more to the discussion than the best technology.
- lgleason 7y agoThere are other issues with nuclear that made it not the best technology. https://www.autoblog.com/2014/07/17/nuclear-powered-atomic-age-classic-cars/ https://www.autoblog.com/2014/07/17/nuclear-powered-atomic-a... Like I said before. I am a big fan of electrics. Currently drive a Volt and plan on getting a Tesla eventually, but am not blind to it's faults. If we were talking about what lead to using leaded gasoline there is a different argument because that could have been avoided. Given the lower population density and the fact that in the early 1900's a large percentage of the population did not have electricity to charge the batteries.. when you factor that in with the other issues of electric cars vs ICE I can see why electric cars did not take hold at that time.
- jerrysievert 7y agonot for lack of trying: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Nucleon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Nucleon but there are a lot of reasons why it never made it into production.
- syockit 7y agoInteresting that the concept is based on steam engine. Would there be a way to recondense the steam for reuse, or did they plan to just release all of them? Then they would need to run on water, much like the steam locomotives of the past.
- jerrysievert 7y agogiven that the "fuel" was set to be replaced every 5,000 miles, i'm going to guess that it was going to be reused, but likely the need for weapons grade plutonium and the amount of shielding required made it not feasible to even think that far, so no idea what the end product would have entailed.
- willyg123 7y agoWe could be running all electric cars on nuclear, indirectly, if we would start building more power plants. cue the anti-nuclear power comments
- potta_coffee 7y agoWe still don't know the full extent of the environmental impact of the Fukushima disaster. Can we afford more incidents of that nature? I'm not certain.
- Buttons840 7y agoIs this satire?
- anchpop 7y agoThat's nice, but we do know that burning fossil fuels kills a huge number of people [0]. Moving away from fossil fuels will require some form of nuclear power. Much of Europe has successfully transitioned most of their power to nuclear [1], so it's not like the concept is some experimental sci-fi dream. From an environmental standpoint, nuclear is by far our cleanest option based on all the information we have. [0]: https://qz.com/568450/fossil-fuels-kill-more-people-every-year-than-wars-murders-and-traffic-accidents-combined/ https://qz.com/568450/fossil-fuels-kill-more-people-every-ye... [1]: http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-profiles/countries-a-f/france.aspx http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-pro...
- stale2002 7y agoIs the "full effect" more than a million deaths a year? Because that's how many people coal kills. And Im not talking about global warming. I am instead only talking about the pollution deaths. If Chernobyl happened like 3 times every single year, that would still be safer than coal, TBH.
- DuskStar 7y ago> If Chernobyl happened like 3 times every single year, that would still be safer than coal, TBH. More like 300, assuming 4000 (as per the IAEA) deaths from Chernobyl.
- ummwhat 7y agoNot for lack of trying. https://youtu.be/kR5gefU87TY https://youtu.be/kR5gefU87TY
- jacquesm 7y agoYou meant 'there is a lot more to the discussion than the density of the energy carrier'. A nuclear vehicle would be impractical due to waste and risk.
- standardUser 7y agoIt turns out the same was true for internal combustion engines all along.
- jacquesm 7y agoActually, no. Given the state of the tech at the time and our knowledge about pollution and the effects of various types of exhaust gases on the atmosphere it wasn't true 'all along'. There were levels of vehicle use that were perfectly acceptable. But now that transportation is a world wide commodity instead of a luxury those effects are inescapable. So there was some point in time where the balance shifted, and then it took a long time for the reality to set in (and some part of the world are still in denial). And it will take some time still to shift to electrical vehicles, but those too have their own waste and risks, some of which will only become apparent when their adoption rate crosses certain thresholds. Crystal balls are in short supply.
- lovemenot 7y agoYour parent comment was transparently using hindsight (it turns out). No crystal ball needed.
- pier25 7y agoPeople usually think cars are the biggest sources of emissions but it's not even close. All transportation (car, planes, trains, etc) represent 14% of global emissions. Globally the biggest source of emissions is energy production which represents about 35% (25% of direct emissions and 10% of processes like refining fuel). https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/global-greenhouse-gas-emissions-data#Sector https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/global-greenhouse-gas-emiss... So, I doubt emissions from ICE cars would be as bad as widespread nuclear residues from nuclear cars.
- pushpop 7y agoYou’re right, otherwise we’d all be powering our cars with with zero point energy reactors. Clearly feasibility has a big part to play as well and everyone driving around little fission reactors would be ridiculously impractical from both an engineering standpoint, as well as a safety one too. Not to mention it becoming a terrorists wet dream because of all the waste material. (Not that I’m normally one to play the “terrorist” card)
- munk-a 7y agoTerrorists currently utilize cars for destructive acts all the time - it hasn't caused us to abandon them. I wouldn't be surprised if, had we gone down that path, automobiles had less fissile material in them than platinum. Currently fissile materials and high explosives are purchasable, we just keep an eye on purchases and follow up on suspicious buying patterns.
- inflatableDodo 7y agoThankfully, Stack Exchange has provided some guidance on these matters. 'Practicality of a thorium-powered, superheated-steam car?' https://worldbuilding.stackexchange.com/questions/69576/practicality-of-a-thorium-powered-superheated-steam-car https://worldbuilding.stackexchange.com/questions/69576/prac...