5 ms·
I find it really interesting that everyone was so pro wikileaks and supported him until they released the wrong documents: something against hillary. If you li
by baby 7y ago
I find it really interesting that everyone was so pro wikileaks and supported him until they released the wrong documents: something against hillary.
If you like leaks, you have to accept that it is going both ways.
- res0nat0r 7y agoI supported him until he started releasing information in drips and drabs to interfere with a US election, and willingly accepted stolen documents from an obvious foreign agent.
- influx 7y agoHow about Edward Snowden being housed, clothed and fed by the same Russian government that was interfering with US elections and providing information to Wikileaks?
- staunch 7y agoAFAIK he's earned his own money by doing talks and receiving donations from supporters, etc not from the Russian government. And Snowden has never mislead anyone about why he's in Russia. He's said that he would love to come home. And if U.S. whistleblower protections was stronger he could. Snowden was openly revealing violations of the U.S. constitution. Assange was covertly acting as an agent of a hostile foreign government with the intention of interfering in U.S. domestic politics. There is no comparison between these two, at all.
- soulofmischief 7y ago> Assange was covertly acting as an agent of a hostile foreign government with the intention of interfering in U.S. domestic politics. You're gonna need proof for that, staunch.
- staunch 7y agoLawyers prosecuting cases need proof. The rest of us can, with some basic level of objectivity, just look at the preponderance of the evidence and come to a conclusion. I believe that any reasonable person that looks into the publicly available evidence would come to the same conclusion. On the other hand, if you're one of the rubes that bought the Seth Rich story from Assange you can be 100% sure that you're terrible at objective analysis.
- soulofmischief 7y agoThat isn't how "innocent until proven guilty" works, staunch. You cannot claim Assange is guilty without irrefutable evidence, which you still have not provided.
- staunch 7y agoThis isn't a courtroom, soulofmischief. My conclusion is based on the preponderance of the evidence, not proof beyond a reasonable doubt. And I do assert that anyone with an objective point of view would come to the same conclusion.
- soulofmischief 7y agoInnocent until proven guilty is a thing for a reason. We should presume innocence until more qualified people beholded to a strict investigative and judicial process make their ruling, which will hopefully not be tainted by outside interests. Innocent until proven guilty does not mean that we get to make premature assumptions and pass them off as fact because "this isn't a courtroom". It is not something just lawyers and judges are beholden to, it's something we as a society are beholden to. Everyone has to play along. You can have your own thoughts, but you cannot just pass them off as objective fact without hard proof. So I ask one more time, what evidence have you prepondered to ascertain Assange's guilty status? You're speaking in vague nothings instead of providing real data.
- cycrutchfield 7y agoSnowden’s existence is currently at the pleasure of the Russian government. If he did anything to displease them, we would quickly hear that he has committed suicide by shooting himself twice in the back of the head.
- decoyworker 7y agoWhat violations of the Constitution did Snowden reveal?
- mrguyorama 7y agodepending on your interpretation, the routine use of unwarranted searching of United States Citizens, among other things
- decoyworker 7y agoPRISM requires a FISA warrant on domestic targets.
- jascii 7y ago"Assange was covertly acting as an agent of a hostile foreign government with the intention of interfering in U.S. domestic politics." That is quite an accusation, is there any proof of that?
- SAI_Peregrinus 7y agoThe US illegally revoked his passport while he was in transit. He thus got stuck during a layover on the way to his original destination (some South American country, I forget which).
- tracker1 7y agoAgreed... I think, for the most part, it should have just been a single dump of information. I generally vote Libertarian, so realistically this didn't effect me, but I am glad that a lot of people got to see a lot of the dirty deeds that politicians abuse. I've known since Bill Clinton was President that Hillary is not a good person and now the world knows it.
- bduerst 7y agoSame - it became pretty obvious that he was using Wikileaks to manipulate headlines leading up to the 2016 election, rather than just trying to deliver valuable information: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/wikileaks-hillary-clinton/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/wikileaks-hillary-clint...
- buboard 7y agoso, until the truths were convenient? And btw, the question is not if we support his decision to leak things, but whether he deserves to die in jail (or worse) or not.
- res0nat0r 7y agoOne is legal, the other isn't.
- pwinnski 7y agoI don't think your second sentence tracks generally. I can heartily support protests against a policy I consider bad while being less-supportive of protests against a policy I support. I can support responsible disclosure while not supporting 0-day drops. In this case, I haven't seen a credible case that Wikileaks endangered anybody, but I can still see a distinction to be made between leaking documents related to national security and leaking documents solely to discredit a political candidate one dislikes.
- staunch 7y agoEdward Snowden released incredible evidence of fourth amendment violations, making him an absolute hero in my book. Assange, in all his years, never actually released anything on the U.S. government that I found to be damning or evidence of illegality. I don't think he did any good by leaking that Iraq war video, the embassy cables, or CIA tools. I went from being ambivalent about Assange to thinking he was a terrible person based on his incredible dishonesty regarding the Clinton emails. I had no problem with the leaking of her emails itself. He, like some kind of weasel lawyer, claimed that he did not receive the emails "from a state actor" and directly implied that they came from Seth Rich. He intentionally mislead a lot of very naive people. The fact is that they almost certainly came through an intermediary of a Russian state actor and almost certainly did not come from Seth Rich. So me disliking him has nothing to do with politics. I would have found him just as much of a dishonest weasel had Trump been the target instead of Clinton. And yet I still think the First Amendment should protect him because I believe American freedoms should remain extremely broad.
- we_love_slon 7y agoWhat does make you believe that documents “almost certainly” came through an intermediary of a Russian state actor?
- jimbob45 7y agoI like leaks and I still like the concept of Wikileaks. I just wish they were less discriminatory about how and what they posted. Honestly, I'd prefer that there wouldn't be a curation staff at all (or at least not one that blocks posts before they're published) and that anything could be published that they could take down if they found it to be spam/meaningless. Honestly, I don't even have a problem with the stuff against Hillary either. They were doing bad things and got caught.
- kmlx 7y agowhat bad things was Hillary doing? or are you referring to the deaths of US agents by the no-filter leaks of wikileaks?
- tracker1 7y agoI don't know that I agree. By contrast the Snowden leaks were extremely considered and vetted to minimize potential harm. The Wikileaks could have very well cost lives and put people into harms way. While you may disagree with political espionage, that doesn't mean you should potentially dox active agents in the field.
- happytoexplain 7y agoIn my experience, this doesn't follow. For the most part, people who were broadly for or against wikileaks remained so after the leaks. The rest of the people judge things on a case by case basis, and taking a look at the facts, those people didn't seem to show very inconsistent application of critique across cases. I know it's easy and satisfying to accuse people you don't like of hypocrisy, especially because there always will be those who make decisions purely based on whatever represents their "side" at any given moment, but painting the broader population with the same strokes is something we should all strive to avoid.
- kmlx 7y agoyou mean working with the FSB in order to interfere (successfully i might add) in the US election? fyi i’ve got no problem with leaking emails or whatnot. but i do have a problem when the FSB uses your org in order to further their interests.
- gjmacd 7y agoWe have BINGO. WikiLeaks is a GRU agent that's been in business to gain the trust and confidence of the United States citizen.. they did this for years. Then once they got the trust and confidence, they turned into an Anti-US democracy propaganda machine. If you don't believe that. Please show me where the Putin information is to disparage HIS opponent in the elections in Russia? Or better, just find me any WikiLeaks dumps or information that's negative towards the GRU or Putin (in a way in which is as damaging as what happened to our elections). Assange was a useful idiot that got played OR he was willing and just good at acting. Either way, WikiLeaks is not our friend.
- we_love_slon 7y agoSimilarly you can pinpoint Wikileaks as Chinese or Iranian agent. Or Malaysian. The fact that they hadn’t had a chance to publish anything on Russian establishment does not make them their agents. It’s a very strong accusation.
- deepakhj 7y agoThose leaks were in coordination with the Russian government.
- micmil 7y agoYour willful ignorance is astounding. Then again I don't expect any better from Trumpettes.
- buboard 7y agoi find the lack of support for assange out of principle from the tech community disheartening. it's alright though, people reap what they sow eventually