3 ms·
There's no rigorous scientific definition of "race", so there can't really be scientific facts about genetic differences between races. Some "racial" groups ha
by foldr 7y ago
There's no rigorous scientific definition of "race", so there can't really be scientific facts about genetic differences between races.
Some "racial" groups happen to have a higher incidence of particular genes. But when you look at specific examples, it's absurd to connect this to any kind of racial theory. For example, Latinos apparently have a higher incidence of Alzheimers than the general US population, and this could possibly have some generic component (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5874398/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5874398/). But no-one would suggest that "Latino" is a bona fide racial category.
- vcavallo 7y agohow about “a phenotypically and statistically relevant portion of one’s DNA can be traced back to X region over the range of Y years ago”? nobody is saying anything about “racial theory” in society at large. more so that certain particular phenotypes are strongly correlated together - like your example about Alzheimer’s.
- foldr 7y agoI don't really see what you're getting out. Yes, there are correlations between genes and other things. So what?
- vcavallo 7y agothere's not much of a "so what" aside from the fact that that's true and people have typically labelled some of those clumpy groupings, "races". it may be haphazard, socially problematic and not extremely useful, but those correlations and average differences between groups are present. The place where it becomes useless, in my view, and one of many ways in which it does not ground racism is that differences _within_ these fuzzily-defined groups is vast. a poster further up said "There really shouldn't be a debate that there are genetic differences amongst 'races'" and your comment seemed to, in tone, disagree while at the same time granting that its true. All I'm getting at is that this can both be 'true' and 'limited in usefulness' and if you agree then we're not arguing. ..but I sense that you don't agree and I'd be happy to hear more about the disagreement.
- foldr 7y ago>people have typically labelled some of those clumpy groupings, "races". Well no, not really. Racial labels aren't determined by DNA.
- vcavallo 7y agoWhat else could it possibly be determined by? Perhaps we're talking about different definitions of the word "race". Are you saying that the phenotypic differences between an Inuit and an African Pygmy (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/African_Pygmies#Genetics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/African_Pygmies#Genetics) are not determined by those individuals' DNA?
- foldr 7y ago>What else could it possibly be determined by? Appearance and cultural characteristics (e.g. language, community, location). The connection to genetics is very loose. In the USA for example, someone who's considered "black" might have just as much "white" ancestry as "black" ancestry.
- vcavallo 7y agowe are not talking about the same meaning of “race” then. you’re talking almost entirely about socio-cultural elements (here. not earlier about Latinos, you should notice). see my above comment about Inuits and Pygmies and notice how your tangent here doesn’t relate to it. of course DNA explains that difference - nothing else can. your divergence into culture is a bit disingenuous - especially since you were talking about Alzheimer’s and Latinos earlier, a disease which has nothing to do with culture...
- foldr 7y agoErm, the point about Latinos is that they're a group almost entirely defined by socio-cultural elements. Latinos are not a random sample of the entire population, so there is no reason to expect them to have the same distribution of genes as the entire population. But obviously, there is no genetic criterion for being Latino. There are, e.g. Latinos with white European ancestry and Latinos with Mayan ancestry. Brazil is a massively diverse country, and yet pretty much all Brazilians are (by US standards) "Latino". There is no respectable scientific or genetic definition of "race". Race is a socio-cultural construct. Naturally, there are rough correlations between genes and "race" in some instances. Lots of characteristics are roughly correlated. But by that loose standard, ”sofware engineer" would be a genetically defined category too.