4 ms·
Before Telegram and similar apps would you have been okay with shutting down the mobile phone network if a minority of protestors might have committed some viol
by threeseed 7y ago
Before Telegram and similar apps would you have been okay with shutting down the mobile phone network if a minority of protestors might have committed some violent actions ?
Or maybe instead of a disproportionate crackdown maybe just do what they've done since forever and just have police at the protests arresting whomever is violent.
- NotPaidToPost 7y agoNote that my main question is how can the authorities "fight back" in real time against people using sophisticated communication tools to organise violent actions (I could even use the term 'terrorism' for the more serious cases). The role of the police is also to prevent violence against individuals and property, not just to arrest people after the fact. I think this is a perfectly legitimate question. Edit: Once again I seem to be the only adult in the room, so good night and good luck.
- maxheadroom 7y agoYou're treading a very dangerous line, here. To an oppressive regime, any "fighters" against that regime could be labelled "terrorism", for pragmatic approaches to dealing with the people who no longer want to be extorted, brutalised, tortured, murdered, what-have-you. If all you have to do is label a tool as 'x' to block it and shut it down, then - in premise - you're denying all of the users of that service one of the inalienable rights that you're supposed to enjoy: Which is the right to peacefully assemble and/or protest. That seems like a very large, oppressive, back-handed means to quash the few that you're actually having problems with.
- darkwater 7y agoThis poses another question thou: what about if the protests/movement is big enough to mean that the government is at fault, because the people, the real people in the streets wants something else? If you give that power to the government then you're cutting away a mean (coordinating protests at scale) to get rid of the Government if it's really needed.
- thinkingemote 7y agoDemocracy attempts to answer that question by allowing real people to change the government.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cotelletta 7y agoIf they did their jobs and understood the targets, they wouldn't need to fight back "in real time", they could actually address the source of the problem instead of hysterically fighting symptoms while causing immense collateral damage to free society, far worse than the actual terrorism.
- saagarjha 7y ago> The role of the police is also to prevent violence against individuals and property, not just to arrest people after the fact. This can very quickly cross into “let’s curtain people’s rights because we think they might commit crimes”–I would be careful with this.
- kzzzznot 7y agoI don’t think hundreds of thousands of people, a significant portion of the country’s population, protesting would ever be called ‘terrorism’ by a reasonable person. It turned violent on both sides, that does not mean it was organised violence.
- wp381640 7y agoThe answer to your question is human intelligence If a group is sufficiently behaving badly the chances of you cultivating an informant or receiving intelligence tips are high Some of this modern mass policing that relies on signals intelligence feels like the investigators just want to sit at a computer and have it mass-print out arrest warrants
- dang 7y ago> Once again I seem to be the only adult in the room You've been continuing to post quite a lot of flamebait and unsubstantive comments, ignoring our requests to stop. Continuing to do that will get you banned here. Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stop doing that.
- jstanley 7y agoThe issue in Hong Kong is that it was mostly the police who were violent.