27 ms·
The virtue of logic isn't that your model is always correct or that it should be adhered to without modification despite contrary evidence, it's that it allows
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
The virtue of logic isn't that your model is always correct or that it should be adhered to without modification despite contrary evidence, it's that it allows you to have one to begin with. It's a method of choosing which experiments to conduct. If you think prohibition will reduce substance abuse but then you try it and it doesn't, well, you were wrong, so end prohibition.
This is also a strong argument for "laboratories of democracy" and local control -- if everybody agrees what to do then there is no dispute, but if they don't then let each local region have their own choice, and then we get to see what happens. It allows more experiments to be run at once. Then in the worst case the damage of doing the wrong thing is limited to a smaller area than having the same wrong policy be set nationally or internationally, and in the best case different choices are good in different ways and we get more local diversity.
- westurner 7y ago> If you think prohibition will reduce substance abuse but then you try it and it doesn't, well, you were wrong, so end prohibition. Maybe we're at a local optima, though. Maybe this is a sign that we should just double down, surge on in there and get the job done by continuing to do the same thing and expecting different results. Maybe it's not the spec but the implementation. Recommend a play according to all available data, and logic. > This is also a strong argument for "laboratories of democracy" and local control -- if everybody agrees what to do then there is no dispute, but if they don't then let each local region have their own choice, and then we get to see what happens. It allows more experiments to be run at once. Then in the worst case the damage of doing the wrong thing is limited to a smaller area than having the same wrong policy be set nationally or internationally, and in the best case different choices are good in different ways and we get more local diversity. "Adjusting for other factors," the analysis began. - [ ] Exercise / procedure to be coded: Brainstorm and identify [non-independent] features that may create a more predictive model (a model with a lower error term). Search for confounding variables outside of the given data.