10 ms·
I think you underestimate how often fear comes into play. I recently was at the park with some kids and I noticed a couple of dogs playing... I then realized t
by kenjackson 16y ago
I think you underestimate how often fear comes into play. I recently was at the park with some kids and I noticed a couple of dogs playing... I then realized they were pitbulls. Maybe perfectly nice dogs, but my fear factor jumped through the roof and I quickly, but quietly gathered up all the kids.
Now fear isn't something that kicks in often, but when it does it usually means you're in pretty grave danger. Not properly reacting to potentially life threatening situations, just once a year, likely greatly shortens your expected lifespan.
- JanezStupar 16y agoPitbulls are not vicious child eaters by their nature. They are called nanny dogs for a reason. May be just the people I am around - but I have yet to see a Pit that is anything beyond sweet, loving and awesome. Now puddles - those are a kind of beast I would never trust to act decently around my kids.
- jules 16y agoSo are you saying that the idea that pitbulls type dogs are the most dangerous kind of dog is bullshit? The statistics don't agree with your personal experience.
- JanezStupar 16y agoCorrelation now counts as causation on HNews? Pitbulls greatest asset and its ultimate downfall is its wonderful toned muscular body and its iron will. Thats why they get picked up by assholes who tend to abuse them and train them to attack humans. Its the owners that are problem not the dogs. These guys could make any kind of animal into a "vicious killer". The pit is anecdotally the worst breed for guard dog. They tend to be that friendly towards humans. You have to remember that these dogs were indeed bred for fighting. Dogs not humans. So they were heavily bred to be friendly towards humans - how else can one control a powerful beast if it won't obey you and let you tend its wounds? They are so protective of children that you can easily let one babysit your kid while you're away. Condemning the breed because of their retarded owners is like condemning whole minorities because of gang members.
- jules 16y agoI'm sorry but given the choice between your personal hunches/anecdotes/biases and published statistics I'm going with the latter: Year Total # Most fatal attacks by # Second-most fatal attacks by 2005 29 Pit bull-type (18) (62%) Rottweiler (6) (21%) 2006 29 Pit bull-type (15) (52%) Rottweiler (8) (27%) 2007 34 Pit bull-type (18) (53%) Rottweiler (4) (12%) 2008 23 Pit bull-type (15) (65%) Husky (3) (13%) 2009 30 Pit bull-type (14) (47%) Rottweiler (4) (13%) 2010 32 Pit bull-type (22) (69%) Rottweiler (3) (9%) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fatal_dog_attacks_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fatal_dog_attacks_in_th... The vast majority of these deaths were <10 year olds. > The pit is anecdotally the worst breed for guard dog. They tend to be that friendly towards humans. You have to remember that these dogs were indeed bred for fighting. Dogs not humans. So they were heavily bred to be friendly towards humans - how else can one control a powerful beast if it won't obey you and let you tend its wounds? Yeah right that's why they are the #1 human killer dogs with a spectacular margin. > They are so protective of children that you can easily let one babysit your kid while you're away. shudder until your 3 year old accidentally hits the pitbull on the nose. Do you happen to own a pitbull?
- JanezStupar 16y agoHad I owned one - I'd have already disclosed it. I'd love to raise a pit - it's just that currently I'm in no position to own such a demanding animal. However I love to hang around people who do own them. As far as statistics go - there pretty skewed: http://animals.change.org/blog/view/are_dog_bite_statistics_reliable http://animals.change.org/blog/view/are_dog_bite_statistics_... - yes thats a blog post - but I couldn't be bothered to perform a more thorough research, I'm sorry. I agree that pitbull attacks will result in more damage and are more prone to kill somebody. But thats not because there evil or go crazy, its because when you mistreat a poodle - you get a minor annoyance, but when you mistreat a pit - you get a 100 pound of muscle and bones bomb ticking to go off. > shudder until your 3 year old accidentally hits the pitbull on the nose. Pits not reacting to a 3 year old punching them is exactly the reason they are so good with kids. Pits pain threshold is so high they don't mind kids being abusive towards them (lets face it thats what kids do to animals). I guess that asshats will keep mistreating their dogs and enjoying in making them vicious and that something has to be done. But banning the dog is the wrong thing to do. Dangerous dog handlers license or/and personality screen of owners is the correct way to go IMHO.
- srean 16y agoI am extrapolating from experiences with a tibetan mastiff and a bull terrier. I think dogs in this family are less temperamental and less snappy.They do have a lot of aggression for other dogs or animals of similar size. But a lot depends on how they were trained. A poorly trained pitbulls can be very dangerous. But they are extremely obedient even if it comes to following orders when they are in pain. I think this is the reason they are the preferred breed for dog-fighting. There a participant is disqualified if it continues to attack after a round has ended. I am sure that trait was bred in.
- kenjackson 16y agoIf you read what I wrote, I said, "Maybe pefectly nice dogs". With mine and other peoples kids I really didn't want to find out, especially since their owner was nowhere in sight. And we've had several incidents of pitbull attacks in this area. Here's a useful site: http://www.dogsbite.org/dangerous-dogs.htm http://www.dogsbite.org/dangerous-dogs.htm Last thing I'd want to tell a parent is, "You child was attacked... sure I saw the pitbulls, but I just assumed they were friendly, I mean, JanezStupar has never seen a vicious one before".
- JanezStupar 16y agoI apologize, but to me you came over like you haven't seen a nice one before :). I might do the same in your shoes. But the fact remains that pitbull is no more dangerous inherently than your average mutt. Probably less so. Yes when they go wrong they tend to cause a bigger mess - but so does Porsche or Ferrari. But we don't go around banning the dangerous car.
- kenjackson 16y agoWell causing a bigger mess is kind of a big deal. If a toy poodle attacks me I can likely win. Against a pitbull, I don't like my odds. And there are a LOT more pitbull fatalaties than your average mutt. See http://www.dogsbite.org/bite-fatalities-2010.htm http://www.dogsbite.org/bite-fatalities-2010.htm
- JanezStupar 16y agoI can see now what I did there, I'm not a native speaker so formulating complex ideas is still pretty hard for me in english. It was wrong of me to say that Pits are less dangerous than your average mutt - because that is clearly not the case, since your average mutt is NOT 100 LBS of muscle and determination. I should of said that pits are (inherently) less likely to attack humans than your average mutt - meaning they take "encouragement" (read training) towards human agression.
- jules 16y agoHave any evidence beyond hunches to back up this theory?
- sliverstorm 16y agopuddles? Is that a typo (poodles), or an attempt at humor? I should mention that according to record, in 20 years poodles have been responsible for one (uno) reported attack resulting in injury, and according to the report there was reason to suspect the dog had been given a controlled substance.
- tjr 16y agoCould you not observe the potentially dangerous dogs and then logically conclude that it may be prudent to leave the area? Why would you have to be afraid?
- sliverstorm 16y agoLogic can fail to put 2 and 2 together. Logic isn't always fast. Fear is very, very fast and almost never fails. It allows the danger to command your attention in a way logic alone can never achieve. It also stimulates the whole fight-or-flight response, souping you up with chemicals in case you need 'em. It has it's limitations, but on the whole it does a much better job than logic would alone IMHO. Being geekish myself, I totally understand the desire to replace everything with cool, calculating logic, but our basic instincts usually do a pretty damn good job. An easy example is if you put your hand on a hot stove, you will instinctively pull away, often even before you feel pain or heat. If you relied on logic (gee, this stove is hot and my hand hurts! I should pull my hand away) your burn would be much, much worse.
- geoffw8 16y agoYeah, fear is the loud siren, and red flashing lights, nuclear meltdown type warning.
- rbanffy 16y ago> fear isn't something that kicks in often, but when it does it usually means you're in pretty grave danger Fear is a very bad advisor. That's why some people have to rehearse disaster scenarios over and over until reacting to them becomes a routine activity - so they can properly react to the threatening situation.