5 ms·
> But there's something to be said for a degree as employability insurance. There's something to be said for going out and learning how to get things done and
by dasil003 16y ago
> But there's something to be said for a degree as employability insurance.
There's something to be said for going out and learning how to get things done and build a business as well. A college degree is hardly insurance for anything.
It's clear this guy doesn't have any actual experience with startups. He rattles off the usual talking points:
> startups can be as profitable as a few are, only because the great majority of other entrepreneurs with similar ideas fail.
Uh, no, they didn't succeed because others failed; they succeed because they were able to sell a product. Also, the ones that failed did not all go hungry in the streets, many if not most of them gained priceless experience of far more financial value than what academia is offering.
I don't necessarily advocate dropping out or going to college. You can learn a lot in college, and I certainly value my degree, however it is not the source of my financial security. As the cost of college goes up, grades inflate, and the percentage of people with college degrees increase, the cost-benefit of college is rapidly shifting. Going to college simply isn't much of a differentiator any more, and because it's gotten so easy, it's not as good an indicator of competence the way it used to be.
Especially these days when companies are no longer loyal, the type of job that a degree is required for is not some bastion of stability. 30 years from now when those college graduates get layed off to cut costs, what is the value of their college degree then? At that point they will be much better off if they've learned some business hustle.
- enjo 16y agoCounterpoint: First off, I don't have a college degree. I have something like 102 hours, so I'm a year'ish short. That said, I'm always a bit wary of hiring folks who don't have (at least) a liberal arts education of some kind. I don't really care about the computer science, engineering, physics part of the degree. I care about the part of college that prepares you to learn. I care about the breadth of experience that literature, writing, philosophy, and the like give you. I've now interviewed far too many folks who have deep computer science knowledge without a degree, but lack the ability to internalize and learn at a deep level. I think that's what college does a tremendous job of preparing people for. I jump at the chance to hire people who took strong programming skills to college and got a degree in something perpendicular to their programming skill set. One of the best hires I ever made had a degree in hospitality management. Short of that, at least stay in college long enough to complete those required core classes. You'll be a much stronger developer, business person, whatever for it.
- araneae 16y agoI'd be wary of hiring a college drop-out simply because college can be a filter for stick-to-it-ness. Only a very few college drop-outs do so because they can do better elsewhere; the majority do it because they've failed. And they don't believe that can get back on their feet. I came close to dropping out, but I'm really glad I didn't- because managing to come back showed me that effort really matters and that I have the ability to succeed at things I thought were hard as long as I work at it.
- krschultz 16y agoI think the questino of why you dropped out is a huge one. If you dropped out becuase you wanted to start the next big thing and fail, why didn't you go back? You can go back for the next 7 years and pick up where you left off. So if you are a college drop out, I am far more inclined to think it was because you couldn't hack it than becuase you tried to go big.
- mmt 16y agoI dropped out after a year, but it wasn't to go "big," merely to go (work) at all. The reason I never went back is simply that the cost grossly outweighed the benefit. Strictly from a quantifiable/money perspective, the loss would have been huge. After 7 years, for example, I'd have been giving up around $85k annually in salary and spending $15k or so on tuition and books. I'm ignoring living expenses, since I expect those would have been close enough to comparable. I'd also be trading 3 additional years of industry experience in addition to the $300k for a diploma. Each of those years turned out to be worth $5k-$10k of additional salary in the short term, though it's tough to say what they've been worth in the long term. As for the intangible benefits, that was an even easier decision, since neither the process nor the "rounding" subjects outside computer science appealed to me. These were all more difficult than high school, but in the wrong ways. That is, the was just as tedious[2], more voluminous, and no more intrinsically rewarding. Writing an essay about literature that parrots the instructor's opinion is something I already knew how to do, but making it appear as if I'm not was a college-level skill I couldn't be bothered to practice, let alone master. Had I dropped out to do a startup, even having failed, I can't imagine undergraduate academia as being anything but stifling and insulting.
- krschultz 16y agoIf you take away the cost of college, would it ever be a bad idea to go? It is only 4 years (3.5 if you are ambition, but again, ignoring the cost I'd do it in 4 to gain breadth). Not only was it a really good learning experience, but it was a hell of a lot of fun and I made a lot of life long friends. 4 years seems like a long time to 18 year olds, but it is a very short time looking at it from the perspective of someone who has graduated and is working. So the issue is cost. I absolutely 100% agree that running up $100k+ of debt on an undergrade degree is insane. The difference in value of the degree is so much less than the difference in cost, you have to go to the cheapest place you can get a quality education. You can do the entire thing for very little money if you work your butt off in high school and pick a school you can get a scholarship to. Or just go in state.
- enjo 16y agoJust to elaborate: Almost every single state has at least one reputable state school were things are absolutely affordable. In Colorado (where I live) you can attend Metropolitan State for something like $15,000 for four years of school. That's a car payment. University of Colorado Denver is something like $20,000 for the same degree. The flagship school is closer to $40,000 for the same degree. The Colorado School of Mines (an outstanding engineering school) is in the same range. That's not a huge amount of money either. Just a nicer car payment. note: Those figures include books, but not room and board. I went to college in Arkansas for a lot less than that (they hand out scholarships like candy). College costs have gotten out of control on the high end. You don't have to go to MIT, Harvard, or NYU. In state tuition is still really affordable for what you get out of it.
- pjscott 16y ago> A college degree is hardly insurance for anything. Usually, but it depends on the degree. A Women's Studies degree, for example, doesn't make you that much more employable. On the far other end of the spectrum, someone with a Nuclear Engineering degree will be all but guaranteed steady, well-paying work for a long time to come.
- Mz 16y ago> But there's something to be said for a degree as employability insurance. There's something to be said for going out and learning how to get things done and build a business as well. A college degree is hardly insurance for anything. ------ I grew up with the idea that you went to college to make sure you could be "successful", careerwise. I was inspired to drop out of college by two individuals I knew who had bachelor's degrees, had gone on to pursue yet more college, in one case had a mountain of student loans, and both were delivering newspapers. One was still living with mom in his thirties. The other was kind of pimping out his wife (not as a prostitute, I just mean he was "supportive" of her career so she would pay his student loans and support him while he remained a total effin loser). I felt like I could deliver newspapers without a degree and would be money ahead for not having the student loans. I went back to college when I had some idea of what I wanted to do with my life.