5 ms·
Sensorimotor Mechanics of People with a Sixth Finger
- m463 7y agoThe interesting technology of ctrl labs: https://www.ctrl-labs.com/ will give "common five fingered" individuals the ability to catch up. They use machine learning to decode the nerve impulses in the arm, so you can play video games without moving and can let you synthesize "extra" arms. search "ctrl labs" and watch the youtube videos, some of scifi possibilities are very interesting.
- curioussavage 7y agoA bunch of my Wife's cousins all had 6 fingers. They had them removed after birth.
- eps 7y agoFrom what I read, fully-functional and fully-formed sixth fingers are exceedingly rare. More often than not they are neither. They just interfere with daily life and attract unwanted attention.
- aetherspawn 7y agoSounds like 5 fingers is the mutation!
- arethuza 7y agoIsn't every feature of every living thing the result of a mutation?
- ObscureScience 7y agoOfcourse. But I wonder wonder if the sixth finger arose in humans or if it's an expression of an previously common structure that has been suppressed for the last couple of million years. I would wager on the latter.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- duskwuff 7y agoIt's an anomaly. Look at the analogous structures in other vertebrates -- in species where digits are discernable (i.e, discounting mammals with hooves or without front limbs at all), there are practically always five. Even a structure as unusual as a bat's wing is made up of five "fingers".
- mkl 7y agoLosing digits seems relatively easy - that's where hooves come from (horses have one toe left, goats two). It's gaining digits that seems very hard. It's possible that some configuration of six fingers could be better, but we probably can't get from our local optimum to that without going through major disadvantages. Apparently five has been the maximum number for most creatures for 420 million years: https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/1org2e/why_do_most_mammals_have_5_fingers/ https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/1org2e/why_do_m...
- Causality1 7y ago>suggest that it may be of value to augment normal five-fingered hands with an artificial supernumerary finger That's missing the big picture in my opinion. This research indicates the human brain is capable, all on its own, of adapting to entirely new sensorymotor functions. Think of the implications. If some type of new functionality were grafted onto you, you'd be able to control it without having to "reassign" any of your current functions. You could move a "third hand" cursor around in three dimensional virtual space as if it were a virtual body part, not just an interface you have to consciously manipulate like a mouse or keyboard.
- Swizec 7y ago> not just an interface you have to consciously manipulate like a mouse or keyboard How conscious is that really tho? I don’t think about how to type, I just think thoughts and they come out on the screen. It’s about as conscious as speaking. Same for the mouse. I don’t think about the mouse consciously, I just look at an item on the screen and choose to interact. Like grabbing a glass of water with my hand.
- causality0 7y agoNow matter how perfect it is, it is by definition less perfect than the movement of your hand itself. The real world is also limited by inertia, which virtual interfaces are not if they bypass the hands entirely. We're a long way from developing really good brain-computer interfaces, but this finding means we have just a little less groundwork to lay.
- kuu 7y agoI'm not sure if we can think our brain will learn to control a new functionality, or as in the case of these people, it's only able to learn to use it if it's been there since the brain formation. We don't know, at least by this study, if the brain can learn once it has developed.
- Symmetry 7y agoWe've actually known this for quite a while. And there are paraplegics controlling a normal 2D mouse with their brains right now. I'm not sure they ever attain the dexterity you or I manage by controlling a mouse with our hands, but it can be done. It can even be done without surgery now. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18367779 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18367779
- m-i-l 7y agoI remember reading (a long time ago so can't provide a reference) that in 1000s of years most humans would have an extra finger. I'd assumed that this was because of the evolutionary advantage it would have given their forebears, although I would question how much natural selection applies to rational beings like humans these days. But on a quick bit of reading now, it seems like it could be because it is a dominant trait. Although after a bit more reading, it seems it might not become more common over time due to the Hardy-Weinberg principle[0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hardy%E2%80%93Weinberg_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hardy%E2%80%93Weinberg_princip...
- dTal 7y agoI know it was just an aside, but I can't let this go: >I would question how much natural selection applies to rational beings like humans these days. It's a universal principle, why wouldn't it apply? Each generation is composed of the offspring of those members of the previous generation who reproduced, introducing a statistical bias. Why would it be different "these days", and what has rationality got to do with it? Besides - as for the notion of 'rational' humans, especially in the context of sex and reproduction - I'll get my coat.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> It's a universal principle, why wouldn't it apply? Because ever since we've invented writing (and arguably even before that - ever since we've invented spoken language), we've left the domain of biological evolution. We now accumulate, evaluate and discard knowledge and technology couple orders of magnitude faster than natural processes. From nature's POV, the entire ~10k years of human civilization happened in a blink of an eye (and note that all the interesting things happened arguably in the last couple hundred years).
- marcoperaza 7y agoThere is still differential production of offspring who produce offspring. The selection is against kind of people who have few children or have few children who go on to have children themselves. That’s how it always has been and always will be unless we abolish natural reproduction.
- dx7tnt 7y agoIs there anyone on HN with 6 fingers? How's your typing? Seems like it could only be a benefit on a keyboard.
- baxtr 7y agoNot quite typing, still insightful. A video from the original paper the article refers to: https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-019-10306-w/MediaObjects/41467_2019_10306_MOESM5_ESM.mp4 https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs414...
- inflatableDodo 7y agoThat's a really cool video, is interesting to experience how much my vision tries to reject the extra finger. Is hard to explain exactly, but every time the hand is held in a way that hides fingers, then my brain goes back to predicting it as a standard hand, then pops back to six digits again when all fingers are visible.
- anon1253 7y agoEver since I was a child I had this strange idea that I was missing fingers (I have 10 like most). From grade school till middle school I even kept counting them as if something was amiss. I mean, it's not like it's actively bothering me or something, but just a bit of a curious quirk: I think I should have 12 fingers. Although in my case it feels like they should be to the side of my pinky, not between the index and thumb. As far as I know my parents didn't have them removed at birth either. Funny enough I believe the gene for it is even dominant (meaning it needs only one copy to express the phenotype), it's just not very common in the general populous.
- timbit42 7y agoIt would be more useful to have another arm or two.