8 ms·
This has the same solution as any other story around copyright infringement. If you provide people with easy, convenient, legal methods to consume the content
by kelnos 7y ago
This has the same solution as any other story around copyright infringement.
If you provide people with easy, convenient, legal methods to consume the content in a way that works for them, for a price they find reasonable, then they overwhelmingly won't resort to illegal means.
I'm not saying these bars are correct to resort to illegal streaming, but a wise businessperson would see this as a signal that their product offering doesn't actually match demand, and work to fill that demand. You're not going to make 100% of people happy in 100% of cases, but you can get to a point where the level of illegal streaming just isn't worth cracking down on.
It's such a sad waste that all this money has been spent to identify and track down illegal activity when it could have been spent making the overall legal experience good enough that most people wouldn't need to resort to illegality. It adds insult to injury to note that companies like La Liga are already making money hand-over-fist; it's not like they have some sort of crisis where the lost revenue due to illegal streaming is posing an existential threat to their business. Instead of cracking down and making enemies, they could instead work to make the experience better and turn potential enemies into satisfied customers.
- danem 7y ago> a signal that their product offering doesn't actually match demand Is it? Why would a smart businessman (the bar owner) pay more for a product when a cheaper alternative (pirating) exists?
- sjwright 7y agoFor the same reason they don’t stock their bar with beer stolen from the brewery?
- ashtonian 7y agoYou can't steal information
- vageli 7y ago> You can't steal information We already have legal terms for information that is property, namely intellectual property, the theft of which is routinely prosecuted (regardless of ideological beliefs on the nature of information).
- benatkin 7y agoIt isn't exactly stealing. It deprives of potential money, but it doesn't deprive them of the good. It's copyright infringement, which is a form of cheating, and megacorps routinely cheat in other ways, like doing their taxes so they record a loss and paying little or no income taxes. http://theconversation.com/is-downloading-really-stealing-the-ethics-of-digital-piracy-39930 http://theconversation.com/is-downloading-really-stealing-th... Calling it stealing is at least imprecise. I think it's also inaccurate.
- danem 7y agoExactly my point. I don't get the whole "if the service isn't cheap or convenient enough, piracy is fair game" argument that gets thrown around on HN all the time.
- pdimitar 7y agoWhat is so hard to get about it?
- briandear 7y agoIf a Mercedes costs too much, it’s ok to steal it? That’s what this attitude means. That it isn’t a physical good doesn’t mean there isn’t a cost to produce and distribute it and the price of producing that product is set specifically to make the economics work for the producers. That the bar is making revenue specifically because of the content someone else is producing makes this theft even more unjustifiable. If someone misused GPL, there’d be outrage, if a bar steals soccer, there is sympathy? If open source people expect (and enforce) licensing for software, how is it consistent that a bar owner is reselling soccer content (i.e. using it to attract customers,) is justified? The idea that people wouldn’t watch it otherwise is ridiculous — they’d seek out a bar that has it. So in this case, this is a direct loss of revenue to the producer of the content.
- benatkin 7y agoWith piracy, they don't have to pay for distribution, because the peer to peer networks take care of it. What's unjustifiable is overcharging for essential music, books, and video, some of which is old, because of the ridiculous extensions on the copyright terms. Sometimes the artists have said they understand why people who can't afford it download their stuff, and can't blame them. Also unjustifiable is how the media conglomerates exploit the artists.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 7y ago
- ordu 7y agoBecause "smart" isn't a synonym for a "criminal".
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- batiudrami 7y agoI don't know about La Liga specifically but in general bars pay a much higher fee than end users to stream sports because it's such a big value-add for them. It's likely that these bars are streaming publicly on a user license, rather than using an illegal stream. The value proposition isn't necessarily that far out - just people want to pay less for things and will do if they can.
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y agoThis is exactly it. If the bar owner living upstairs already pays for satellite TV for home use, why pay the extra for the bar license? Just rig up an HDMI splitter.
- paulie_a 7y agoBecause one is residential and one is commercial usage.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoThat is why in the UK in a pub you can see a small pint glass in the corner of the screen its the feed for commercial use.
- ddffre 7y agoTrue to that, as an example the NBA league pass provides a good experience for a decent price.
- ryan_j_naughton 7y ago>If you provide people with easy, convenient, legal methods to consume the content in a way that works for them, for a price they find reasonable, then they overwhelmingly won't resort to illegal means. I think the problem with your statement is "for a price they find reasonable." Because the price some find reasonable is much lower than others (the very reason why demand curves are downward sloping is they there are different willingness to pay for different customers). Since La Liga can't price discriminate easily and charge those with higher willingness to pay more AND since they have a monopoly over these games, the rational economic decision of the league is to keep the prices at a higher price, which while unfortunately resulting in fewer people having access, it also means more profit for them. Thus, I don't think it is as simple as you are making it appear.
- ddingus 7y agoIf they are making more money, what exactly is the worry? One of their real worries just might be having greater success resulting in an actual decline in access. Something else can enter that vacuum pretty damn easy.
- CaptainZapp 7y agoSince La Liga can't price discriminate easily Sports broadcasts are massively price discriminated, however, which is probably the whole point of this bruhaha. Pubs in the UK, for example, pay a much higher fee (something like 15'000£ a year[1]) than households (which I believe is in the 50Quid range a month) for the right to publicly broadcast the games. It's probably such shenanigans (using a home subscription to show in the pub) that they're trying to fight. Not that I agree with the methods, mind you. This, btw, explains why you see a beer glass in the corner of sports broadcasts in English pubs[2]. At least the ones that are properly licensed. [1] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/mediatechnologyandtelecoms/11038992/More-pubs-get-sport-from-BT-than-Sky.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/mediatechno... [2] https://mindyourdecisions.com/blog/2016/12/13/game-theory-applied-why-is-there-a-pint-glass-in-the-corner-of-tvs-at-pubs/ https://mindyourdecisions.com/blog/2016/12/13/game-theory-ap... e: spello
- lostmymind66 7y ago"If you provide people with easy, convenient, legal methods to consume the content in a way that works for them, for a price they find reasonable, then they overwhelmingly won't resort to illegal means." I disagree. Music is cheaper and easier to buy than ever with things like iTunes and the various streaming services and music piracy is still rampant. Bars have very slim margins and owners will most likely never pay for these these streams, regardless of price, if they can easily get away with it.
- briandear 7y agoSuccessful bars don’t have slim margins. Restaurants often have slim margins because of food waste, but bars have pretty good margins. There is very good profit on drinks: a 750 bottle of Tito’s vodka costs about $18 wholesale, provides 16 shots, at $5 per shot, that’s $80. Then discount 20% for spillage, that’s $64. Bartenders in the US make tips, so the hourly cost to the bar is pretty minimal, but in Europe, everything is more expensive, but the ratios remain similar because a $5 shot in Europe would be €8, with no tipping, but roughly 20% of that price would go to the additional labor costs. A well managed bar that keeps comps and spillage under control can make a very good profit, especially on soccer nights. Restaurants have very different economics because there are costs for the kitchen and other food waste. Anyone who has ever been in the restaurant business knows that the real profit comes from selling the drinks, not the food.
- wolco 7y agoA bar with high margins will have other bars opening up near by and attempt to steal customers by offering lower price drinks driving down margins.
- huac 7y agoliquor licenses can be exorbitantly expensive (I hear $300k+ upfront in SF), plus increased recurring costs to comply with regulations; I'm sure authorities understand that establishments which serve liquor are more profitable in a vacuum, so they are likely to try and take a larger cut.
- 7y ago
- stornetn 7y ago> a wise businessperson would see this as a signal that their product offering doesn't actually match demand, and work to fill that demand This is not necessarily true. It depends entirely on the shape of demand. By way of simplified example, imagine that there are two types of consumers equally distributed: those willing to pay $1000 and those willing to pay $100. Unless you can distinguish at time of payment between these users and charge them different prices (without possibility of resale), you will always be better off forgoing half of the market and charging only the higher price. It's possible that the business has estimated things incorrectly and is acting suboptimally, but I think it's as least as likely that they are maximizing profits the way we'd expect a rational business operator to do.
- csa 7y ago> but I think it's as least as likely that they are maximizing profits the way we'd expect a rational business operator to do I think you grossly overestimate the ability of most large businesses to behave rationally form an organizational profit maximization perspective. It would just as likely or even more likely be something like personal wealth maximization by an employee or group of employees, personal relationship improvement, ego gratification, maintaining/improving social standing, effort minimization, etc. This is even more so for a monopoly rights holder like La Liga.
- dlkf 7y ago> It would just as likely or even more likely be something like personal wealth maximization by an employee or group of employees, personal relationship improvement, ego gratification, maintaining/improving social standing, effort minimization, etc. Do you have any evidence for this? > I think you grossly overestimate the ability of most large businesses to behave rationally form an organizational profit maximization perspective. You're free to think this but it doesn't really square with common sense. Profit maximization is a stated goal of large orgs, and by definition they're doing ok at it. In any case, your comment does nothing to diminish OP's point: that the shape of the demand matters. What the shape of the demand is in this case is an empirical question and you haven't provided any evidence.
- YeahSureWhyNot 7y agonot sure about soccer but UFC fights cost 5 to 10 thousand dollars per fight to show PPV at bars. If there are 100 people at the bar then it comes out to 50-100 dollars per person. Thats almost like buying a ticket to see the fight at the actual arena
- mpetkevicius 7y agoThat figure would likely be significantly lower is bars didn't pirate
- cf141q5325 7y agoWhy do you assume that? I dont see any incentive to lower prices with higher demand.
- dorian-graph 7y ago> If you provide people with easy, convenient, legal methods to consume the content in a way that works for them, for a price they find reasonable, then they overwhelmingly won't resort to illegal means. I've never liked this sort of argument because it makes it sound like people simply have to view this content, by whatever means necessary, like their life depends on (excuse my slight exaggeration). You don't have to watch Game of Thrones. Your life really will be fine.
- gnomewascool 7y agoYou obviously won't die from not watching Game of Thrones. However, depending on your circle of friends and acquaintances, you might be excluded from social interactions. This can range from not getting occasional references, to not being able to participate in many conversations (during "peak" Game of Thrones a couple of years ago, they were a major and frequent topic in many circles) and hence being side-lined, to even being semi-ostracised ("Why should they hang out with this loser who doesn't even watch Game of Thrones?"). Obviously you could claim that you should get other/better friends, but that's not really realistic, especially if you're already on the border of social isolation. This will have negative effects on your well-being and even your health (loneliness is a major health risk, on par with obesity and smoking).[0] [0] https://www.webmd.com/balance/news/20180504/loneliness-rivals-obesity-smoking-as-health-risk https://www.webmd.com/balance/news/20180504/loneliness-rival...
- dorian-graph 7y agoI assume the number of people who would be extremely affected in this way is quite small. I've never watched GoT and I've being there when people were having those conversations, or when people were having watching parties, etc.
- carlmr 7y agoI'm not watching game of thrones, but I can't quite see the connection here. The argument doesn't really depend on people finding they have to view something. They want to view it, so they look at the offering, which is illegal with bad customer experience or legal with better customer experience. They weigh their options according to their preferences, illegal VS legal, ad riddled pages vs smooth experience, having to find out how it works vs having it work in the TV out of the box. And then they will check the price to see what is the better trade off for them. A good customer experience like Netflix will increase the odds that someone won't go through the hassle. Then if the price is reasonable people won't on average decide for the illegal option. The problem for Netflix now is that a lot of third parties like Disney retract their content. This raises the price and worsens the UX, because you have to go through multiple subscriptions. This again raises the probability of pirating. This is all just basic economics, not a moral argument.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoUp to a point a minority of Landlords / Bar owners will take short cuts to boost their revenue - this is not the same as an individual pirating. There are a lot of shady practices in this industry buying your own beer on the side for example.
- whenchamenia 7y agoNo, thats pirating, and unlicenced broadcast for profit. Much worse in the eyes of the law.
- mikorym 7y agoI find it puzzling why there isn't a Netflix for sports that just shows sports channels. (Or is there?) Cable providers like to lure people in with sports channels and then force sports to only appear in the top payment tier.
- stirlo 7y agoIn Australia the dominate cable provider who owns 80+% of sports rights has just launched this (Kayo Sports). Costs 2.5x ($25AUD) a basic Netflix connection ($10AUD) though.
- nwellnhof 7y ago> Or is there? DAZN (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DAZN https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DAZN) is increasingly popular, at least in Europe.
- ThirdFoundation 7y agoIn the US this is unlikely to happen because the big 4 sports all want to control their own distribution, TV rights, and streaming. I think they believe there's more money in that method.
- chrisweekly 7y ago> "It's such a sad waste that all this money has been spent to identify and track down illegal activity when it could have been spent making the overall legal experience good enough that most people wouldn't need to resort to illegality." ^ This. (Same principle applies to myriad other misguided efforts to exercise some form of control.)
- dwild 7y ago> the overall legal experience good enough that most people wouldn't need to resort to illegality This fail when the content is the product. Sure you can improve the delivery method, but at the end of the day, you got to pay for both content and the delivery method, while the illegal market only has to pay for the delivery method. The VPN market is flourishing, many people pay to get into private torrent trackers and rent seedbox to makes sure they can seed as much as they need to stay there. Sure pay to get your experience better, but sadly they still need to pay to keep the content as good. I believed that argument for far too long, that illegal content would happen less if a good enough service would exist. Netflix happened, it did happen, but then they increased the price just a tiny bit, others subscriptions based content appeared, still freakinly cheap, and more and more people got back to illegal content. Their thresold are way too low (and that make sense, the illegal market can deliver a good enough experience for cheaper because they only have to pay for that part of that experience, which is minimal in the actual entertainment). I'm pretty sure most people pay more in fast food than in entertainment content each month.
- latexr 7y ago> The VPN market is flourishing, many people pay to get into private torrent trackers and rent seedbox to makes sure they can seed as much as they need to stay there. If there was a legal method which worked as well as the illegal one (including quantity and offline capabilities) and cost the same as the VPN / seedbox, I doubt most would stay with the illegal content. Many would never switch because they stick with the illegal content for ideological reasons (“information wants to be free”, “I don’t want to give money to The Man”), but those you’ll never get money from either way. > I believed that argument for far too long, that illegal content would happen less if a good enough service would exist. Netflix happened, it did happen, but then they increased the price just a tiny bit, others subscriptions based content appeared, still freakinly cheap, and more and more people got back to illegal content. Netflix worked to reduce piracy because you felt they had everything. Now they don’t, and everything is split across several streaming services which you have to pay for individually. For many ex-pirates, it’s gotten to the point where consuming content legally has devolved (again) to be more cumbersome than doing so illegally.
- squarefoot 7y ago"If you provide people with easy, convenient, legal methods to consume the content in a way that works for them, for a price they find reasonable, then they overwhelmingly won't resort to illegal means." This is absolutely true, but also absolutely incompatible with our current universally accepted way of doing business which is the pursuit of maximum profits with zero consideration on moral issues. They will rather shovel money on clunky inferior but restrictive technologies, plus lawyers, if doing so would allow them to sell the product at a higher price most won't find reasonable, de facto encouraging piracy.