4 ms·
>> In both cases, it is believed that the drivers may have mistaken the throttle for the break pedal. No. That is either a translation error or an overly-poli
by sandworm101 7y ago
>> In both cases, it is believed that the drivers may have mistaken the throttle for the break pedal.
No. That is either a translation error or an overly-polite way of putting it. They did not "mistake" one for the other. Loss of coordination in the legs is a normal symptom of old age. It is why old people shuffle, why they use walkers. They did not make the mental mistake of forgetting which pedal is which. They suffer from a physical condition, one unrelated to cognition, that limits their ability to quickly and accurately move their feet.
Automatic brakes might help, but won't necessarily protect every kid walking through a parking lot from being trampled by someone accidental slamming on the accelerator. What might be needed is a combination of automatic brakes and throttle limiters, devices that interpret someone slamming on an accelerator as a mistaken attempt to stop.
Similarly, rapid acceleration in reverse should be disabled. That has killed in many parking lots. So too rapid acceleration with the parking brake applied.
- avar 7y ago> [...]throttle limiters, devices that interpret someone slamming on an accelerator as a mistaken attempt to stop[...] If there's a perceived need to install that sort of device the driver in question simply shouldn't be driving. Installing this sort of thing is just a recipe for disaster, now they'll cause some horrible accident on a highway instead as they legitimately slam the accelerator on an on-ramp, which the car will then auto-translate to slamming on the brakes.
- thebooktocome 7y agoPerfectly healthy people without dementia have confused the brake and acceleration pedals. It's a design problem, not a competency problem. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009%E2%80%9311_Toyota_vehicle_recalls https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009%E2%80%9311_Toyota_vehic... Maybe your point is that people shouldn't be driving in general?
- avar 7y agoNo, the premise of this discussion is not that humans are infallible up to a certain age, but rather that at some point the elderly become more prone to causing accidents. I'm pointing out that what might sound like a sensible mitigation for that can backfire. The control mechanisms of cars should not be messed with lightly.
- diminoten 7y agoAre they trying to protect "every" kid? Or just bring the rate back down to an acceptable level? Driving is inherently dangerous, complete safety isn't possible.