5 ms·
The police don't know what they are doing. Trying to break the trust of darkweb users is a fool's errand. The system is built on mistrust. The big selling po
by sandworm101 7y ago
The police don't know what they are doing. Trying to break the trust of darkweb users is a fool's errand. The system is built on mistrust. The big selling point of these markets is that you don't have to know anything about your dealer, and they need to know almost nothing about you. So there is no trust system to break.
The other big selling point is that these websites defeat all the violence. There are no turf wars online, at least not physical wars. No dealer can force users to buy from them exclusively. No low-level dealer in a neighborhood must pay homage to a local mob boss. All of that disappears. Any cop that thinks oldschool tactics like spreading distrust within the supply chain to instigate internal mole hunts has watched too many movies. Within Tor it is assumed that everyone is a mole. Each individual protects themselves with the tools available. Every dealer assumes at least some buyers are cops. Every buyer assumes the cops are running sting operations. The market functions nevertheless.
- sonnyblarney 7y agoSo long as 'trust' is part of the factor for purchase, then by 'Supply and Demand' - the tactic will work. Consider that there's an incredible number of 'regular people' who might visit these sites, not super knowledgable. They might have regular jobs, regular lives. The thought that they could be caught up in something legal, lose their jobs etc. etc. is a very material risk. Without getting into other aspects of this issue ... the tactic they're using is actually reasonable. Also, I'll bet their not spending a huge amount of energy on it, it probably boils down to 'keeping an eye on it'. As far as your comments bout 'no violence' etc. - really, it'll just move elsewhere. Anything that starts making money will be exploited very quickly by nefarious entities for nefarious means.
- velox_io 7y agoIt's also safer than buying it off the streets (aside from dealing with gang members), there is no telling what you are buying (they probably don't know either). While it's true that everyone mistrusts each other. Sellers are also competing with each other to offer the best products with the best prices, putting a huge amount of effort to build the best feedback ratings. A world away from gangs using extreme violence to increase turnover (you would think that factors into the priorities). I'd feel safer buying from DreamMarket than I would Ebay.
- mirimir 7y ago> The big selling point of these markets is that you don't have to know anything about your dealer, and they need to know almost nothing about you. Huh? Sellers need a physical address. Sure, one can use the address of some senile neighbor, or that of someone on vacation, or an empty house, etc. But I bet that over 90% of buyers use their actual address. I mean, DPR did, when he bought fake ID from SR.
- freedomben 7y agoMy thoughts exactly. People still have to provide some address to receive it, and if they are buying from a cop then when the package shows up the cops will be watching and when you grab it, you're busted. Seems like you still need some level of trust, but please correct me if I've got it wrong.
- corndoge 7y agoConsider that if I know your address, I can order drugs delivered to you. Then you take the sting. I would think that this factor and the desire to catch the sellers more than the buyers motivates law enforcement to focus on disrupting the chain and tracking down sellers more than pursuing all but the highest volume buyers.
- millzlane 7y agoAlso there is plausible deniability. "I don't know why drugs showed up to my house. Look! That's not even my name...clearly a mistake."
- mirimir 7y agoSure. But they would use your name.
- freedomben 7y agoWhat if they just record you taking the package, follow you home, get a warrant based on probable cause, and search your house and find the package?
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 7y agoThis is foolish. Vendor ratings and exchange reputations absolutely matter. It is in no way a trust-less system. Vendors forego significant profit to establish these ratings. It is a system where you must constantly guard against malicious actors - cops, exit scams, etc. - but the nash equilibrium achieved depends deeply on trust metrics. Increasing the number of malicious agents is much like increasing parasitism in ecosystems, and has dramatic effects on how the ecosystem performs.
- azinman2 7y agoBut how could you trust the ratings at all? Amazon, with all their resources and ML prowess, is having a very difficult time with fake reviews. These sites don’t stand a chance.
- __MatrixMan__ 7y agoAn Amazon verified purchase is a cheap thing, if I'm buying that widget anyway I could imagine accepting some kickback to let the bots review it in my stead. Why not? But a darknet market purchase? That's different. One goes through all kinds of ridiculous gyrations to prevent third parties from being included, and with good reason. Unless you think you can compromise legit user accounts, your bots would have to spend a whole lot of money on real drugs before anybody would give credence to their fake reviews.
- azinman2 7y agoHow do these systems do “verified reviews,” and if they can, wouldn’t it be bitcoin just going back the same person?
- __MatrixMan__ 7y agoThe system is largely the same--I'm prompted to leave a review after a transaction is completed. In the Amazon case, it's not a big deal if both me and the shady seller communicate out of band. We can use email or whatever to orchestrate the payback for a positive review, and the penalities for our scheme being compromised are low: maybe we get banned from Amazon and frowned at by our friends, who cares. In a darknet market scenario, we rely on the market to handle our identities, and try to stay completely anonymous otherwise. So we have to use some other identity mechanism to orchestrate the kickback, which fails in two ways: - Either it's too disconnected from the original transaction, and there's no way for me to hold the seller accountable for the Bitcoin I was promised in exchange for a positive review (aside from buying from the shady seller a second time just for the opportunity to leave a negative review). - Or it's too connected to the original transaction. In this case, if our side scheme is uncovered it could be used as evidence against us in court. Which is a significantly scarier outcome than being banned. Although being banned also carries more weight because some sellers won't sell to accounts without positive history, so if you need to reboot your identity you might have to risk getting ripped off a few times before the larger community of sellers trusts you again. Also, I'd stay the hell away from any seller that approached me with such an offer, they want me to participant in a scam, which tells me something about them. Why should I trust their drugs?