3 ms·
These things never fail to get the same reaction from me: I get immediately excited, thinking that we've cured cancer, and then a bit depressed because this thi
by tombert 7y ago
These things never fail to get the same reaction from me: I get immediately excited, thinking that we've cured cancer, and then a bit depressed because this thing is probably a really long way away.
I don't work in the medical industry, but to those that do, do these headlines irritate you?
- roywiggins 7y agoThe good news is it's been in development for a decade already and the next step seems to be human trials for effectiveness, so it's still years away, but if it works out, maybe not that many.
- SubiculumCode 7y agoCancer has turned out to be much harder than anyone realized 50 years ago...but the exciting thing over the last decade has been the major advances that have occurred, capitalizing on the basic biological research investments we've made. If anything, this is a story of how much we need to fund (and increase!) basic science research, even if it seems pointless in the near term.
- throwaway5752 7y agoUsually the big advances are built on a number of small incremental advances. Think about modern immunotherapy like CAR-T. Rather than recap myself I'm just going to post this timeline of the milestones that led to CAR-T over many decades: https://www.mskcc.org/timeline/car-t-timeline-progress https://www.mskcc.org/timeline/car-t-timeline-progress. You'll generally be disappointed, though. "Cancer" isn't really a thing. It is a family of disorders characterized by several properties that arises from different causes. At this point in my life, I am very confident that we will never have a single general cure for cancer (killing mutated cells, repairing carcinogenic dna damage).
- gus_massa 7y agoOne very clear explanation of the problem is in a "PhD Comic" post: http://phdcomics.com/comics/archive.php?comicid=1162 http://phdcomics.com/comics/archive.php?comicid=1162 --- Also, remember that the fight against cancer is a marathon, not a sprint. It is like curing "virus infections" or curing "bacterial infections". It's imposible to cure them all with a magic weapon. Someone makes a new antibiotic/antiviral drug, someone makes a new vaccine, someone makes a new mixture to prevent dehydration, someone makes a new procedure to detect the infections. Each is only a step. Get happy for every step, but remember that it is only a step and there are a lot ahead. (Just ignore the press titles, assume they are always linkbait.)
- asdff 7y ago>do these headlines irritate you? Sometimes, but I'm usually not exposed to these news articles unless they are posted to hn or something. I prefer to go to the journal article over these written by journalists who don't have time to dig in and do a proper summary of the findings. Usually it goes something like this: 1. Interesting thing published in decent journal, but years away from clinical trials or even animal models and things fail during those tests all the time. 2. Journalist pumps out a half assed article about how its the new silver bullet. 3. Public reads the article, picks up that its remarkably similar to the half assed article they read on tuesday about a completely different thing in a completely different disease. 4. Public complains that there's "a new cure for cancer every day." 5. Public looses confidence in scientific authority. 6. Rinse and repeat when journals push the next batch of manuscripts next week. What's remarkable is that some of the biggest advances don't get very much coverage at all, or are covered for like a week or two and forgotten, despite the field mulling over and improving that finding for years. Clickbait-style news and scientific findings aren't compatible.