5 ms·
Traditionally AMD does NUMA differently from Intel. Would like to see a comparison focusing on NUMA.
by klodolph 7y ago
Traditionally AMD does NUMA differently from Intel. Would like to see a comparison focusing on NUMA.
- p_l 7y agoRyżem branded cpus have single NUMA zone, threadripper have 2, EPYC have 2 per socket
- paol 7y agoThis was true up until now, but the upcoming 3900X and 3950X have 2 separate dies ("chiplets"). I assume this means it will have the same architecture as the current TR 2920X and 2950X. Edit: opencl post above says apparently not, it's a different memory architecture.
- horyzen 7y agoThe 2 smaller chiplets are for core complex, the memory controller is on the IO die(the other bigger one) that these 2 CCX share. So there is still one single memory controller, and hence, not NUMA.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoAll memory access is through the single I/O die, so neither the new Ryzen nor the new Epyc are technically NUMA. However, because all cores in a single chiplet share a single L3 cache, doing NUMA-like optimizations will still yield significant benefits. AFAICT.
- lorenzhs 7y agoThe bigger EPYCs have four NUMA zones per socket (at least the 7551P does).
- opencl 7y ago3950X and the single socket versions of new EPYC chips aren't NUMA. Instead of each CPU die having its own memory controller there is a central I/O die with an IF link to each CPU die.