5 ms·
The moment the idea is admitted into society, that property is not as sacred as the laws of God, and that there is not a force of law and public justice to prot
by ams6110 16y ago
The moment the idea is admitted into society, that property is not as sacred as the laws of God, and that there is not a force of law and public justice to protect it, anarchy and tyranny commence.
John Adams (http://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/v1ch16s15.html http://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/v1ch16s15....)
- eftpotrm 16y agoThe country was founded on the principle that the primary role of government is to protect property from the majority, and so it remains. Avram Noam Chomsky
- javert 16y agoWow, Chomsky got something right! I couldn't agree more. See, that's a good thing. Stalin and Hitler tried seizing property "for the majority."
- eftpotrm 16y agoActually I just put up the quote as a counterpoint.... I'm sure we can find better refutations that don't invoke Mr. Godwin. Regardless though, my core point in this is that the sanctity of private property within real estate isn't an unqualified good; as a very firmly limited resource with impacts on us all, there are surely times when it is right that the common good override the individual claim, with truly fair compensation for this violation.
- javert 16y agothere are surely times when it is right that the common good override the individual claim, with truly fair compensation for this violation Can you give examples? The only one I can think of that is potentially convincing is for building highways.
- eftpotrm 16y agoWell, I'm coming from the UK where space pressures are rather higher than average in the USA. But: * Airports - Heathrow Airport had a proposed runway addition recently, as a very busy and overcrowded airport and piece of critical national infrastructure. There's only so many places one can build a runway in relation to the existing site and a new development elsewhere would need to be far, far larger to provide anything like the same level of service. * Roads and railways. There are frequently only so many paths one can choose to avoid building a line that meanders so much as to both hugely increase its construction costs and vastly reduce its usable speed, rendering their construction largely pointless. * Infrastructure such as power stations, waste disposal etc. Many if not most communities want to have them as far away as possible and can help facilitate this by blocking the sale of the land as well as introducing blocks on development permissions. We surely all agree that they need to be somewhere though, and clearly we can't all have them as far away from us as possible - there is sometimes a need to impose development on a location becase all need its services but none want to host it. One of the core issues here is the difference between very crowded limited resources (such as Manhattan real estate) and the rather more open, available real estate situation across more of the USA. What might well be an unreasonable claim in an area where there was a significant amount of available land can surely be judged differently when there are such harsh constraints on availability, particularly when one owner is in a position to use their property to hold the larger entity to ransom because both parties know there's nowhere else it can go. That is surely the very definition of an unfair market.
- javert 16y agoThanks for such a detailed (and intelligent) response to a question that I think most people wouldn't take seriously (although I meant it seriously). * Airports: How much is it really going to help to build one more runway? What about when another runway is needed, and another after that? The best thing to do is to plan for the airport to take up an enormous amount of space beforehand, and probably, in this case, to build another airport. (NYC already has three, but I only know of two in London off the top of my head.) * Roads and railways: I think this is the "most difficult" one to deal with. I think it helps to have a more accurate definition of property rights than what most people operate with, which is to say, it's only your property if you actually use it--otherwise nobody is impacting you if they use it, which is the whole point of property. For example, I don't think people should be allowed to "own" large, empty tracts of land. (This would be the common problem with building roads and railways in America.) And if you want to build new roads in a heavily urbanized area, I think that's just a bad idea... I mean, that's never really necessary, unless you want to increase the human density of that particular area (which it self is never really necessary). Also, there are options like building underground and building multi-story highways. * Infrastructure: The examples you're giving (power plants, waste disposal) are just discrete "points" in the map that don't have to be physically in any one particular place, as long as they're in the general area. Surely someone in a large area will be willing to sell you a plot of land. (If not, just build the infrastructure further out.) Your point about density of USA vs. UK is a good observation, though I don't think it really changes the principles. A lot of times American libertarians (I'm not one, FYI) talk about limited government, and their opponents immediately say things like "What about roads? Roads only work if the government builds them, and has eminent domain." I personally don't agree with the latter point of view on roads - but, in general, I don't think it's really an argument worth having. There are more important things to argue about, such as defending property rights in principle. But for a principle to be valid, it has to always be valid. So when I argue about eminent domain, I do so to save property rights, not because I acutally think eminent domain is particularly important compared to so many bigger issues in our culture today.