5 ms·
Some articles make you stupider for having read them. This is one of them. It is full of nice sounding misinformation that you'd be better off forgetting. Th
by btilly 16y ago
Some articles make you stupider for having read them. This is one of them. It is full of nice sounding misinformation that you'd be better off forgetting.
The original purpose of the XBox was to kill the profit margins on Sony's cash cow, the playstation. It succeeded in that, and Sony is no longer threatening Microsoft across a range of areas. This was a wise strategic move, and profit was not the main motive.
According to Google's Q3 release, Google's annualized run rate on mobile is over a billion dollars. Android is a disproportionate share of that. Android is not a waste of resources for Google. It is a profit center.
As for Wave, it was a great experiment. It didn't work out. But lots of ideas from Wave are showing up in docs. I think it was a worthwhile risk to take, and Google learned something from it.
The one thing that I agree with the article on is that Microsoft's mobile strategy is severely broken. But the reasons for it are more complex than simply saying that Microsoft has a bunch of cash.
And now I'm going to try to forget having read that article.
- joakin 16y agoI thought that this was one insightful article, but after reading your comment I see that not everything is as this person is trying to make us see. There is no black and white, and not every decision/project can be put in the same sack (even though lots of em are the result of what the article says)
- foobarbazoo 16y agoThe original purpose of the XBox was to kill the profit margins on Sony's cash cow, the playstation. It succeeded in that, and Sony is no longer threatening Microsoft across a range of areas. This was a wise strategic move, and profit was not the main motive. If you think that btilly is not describing and then praising wealth destruction in that quote about Microsoft's Xbox business, please downvote this comment. Thanks. HOW TO DESTROY WEALTH: When I spend $100 on materials and labor, and I can -- at best -- sell the result to you for $80, $20 of wealth is destroyed. Why? Because the original $100 came from the creation of wealth equal to that, and I transformed that $100 into something that is now only worth $80. Literally, wealth was destroyed. If you'd like a more concrete analogy, what Microsoft did is a lot like taking a a 1 carat diamond and smashing it into diamond dust. Only the arrangement of matter has changed, but in terms of wealth, the diamond dust is worth far less than the sparkling 1 carat diamond. It's the same with the $100. As a $100 bill, it is worth exactly $100. Microsoft took that $100 and spend it on labor and materials. The matter in the world stayed the same. But the new arrangement of matter (an Xbox) was only worth $80 to the world. Microsoft destroyed $20 in wealth to the world. This, in a nutshell, is what Microsoft did with the Xbox. Sony was doing something the world wanted with the Playstation. They were literally spending $100 and getting $120 in value out of it. That's what wealth creation looks like. Microsoft did the opposite. Even worse, they did so in order to make it impossible for Sony to create wealth, too. In my book, reducing the wealth of the world for something so stupid, so small, as to "eliminate competition" is about the worst sin a business can do. The literally billions of dollars of wealth destroyed at both Sony and Microsoft by the behavior of Microsoft has hurt the world in enumerable ways. For all we know, had the money been returned to shareholders, we may have made more progress on green energy. Or food production. Or water purification. Or cancer research. Or any of the other things we could have done instead of destroying wealth. That is why the OP is so off base. And why the rest of you should upvote my comment like crazy. Wealth destruction is bad, full stop.
- zoomzoom 16y agoIt is not praising wealth destruction, it is praising competition. The market is not a zero-sum game where Sony's loss is everyone's loss.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Hoff 16y agoYour position appears to be one of tactical and not of strategic thinking. Per the article, Xbox itself wasn't itself intended to be a large revenue stream. It was (again, per the article) intended to protect other existing revenue streams of Microsoft from a competitor (Sony) that had been enjoying increasing success with gaming products, and a competitor that was then likely to use that success and that revenue to start competing against Microsoft in other arenas and other products. And yes, Xbox does look to have been a wise move. There have been more than a few comments over the years of companies having used press releases and roadmaps and deliberate leaks to freeze a market; to effectively remove the wind from a potential competitor's sails. Steps taken to change the business environment that the competitor is operating in. BTW: the difference between tactics and strategy is analogous to the differences between sales and marketing. Confuse the two at your corporate peril.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- endtime 16y agobtilly's not praising anything, and (s)he's not describing wealth destruction. You may want to take your own advice.
- raganwald 16y agoThe original purpose of the XBox was to kill the profit margins on Sony's cash cow, the playstation. It succeeded in that, and Sony is no longer threatening Microsoft across a range of areas. What areas are those and why do we we think that spending billions with a "b" on Xbox to kill Sony's profits was a more effective defence of those areas than spending those same or fewer billions with a "b" making those areas more competitive? And more importantly, are any of these areas Sony threatened actual cash cow businesses like Windows or Office?
- kenjackson 16y agoIt was really one area. The TV in the living room. MS feared that Sony would end up winning that with the PlayStation and then use their consumer electronics arm to have an integration stranglehold on the living room. You have to remember that this started back in 2000 (or so). Nobody had a clear vision of Netflix or Roku or Hulu. I don't think they ever worried that Sony would take Office, but I think the fear was that they would move computing to appliances and take Windows revenue... now that fear is the iPad will do it.
- btilly 16y agoIt started a bit earlier than that. Sony's WebTV came out in 1996. Which fed perfectly into Microsoft's paranoia that the web was about to make Windows irrelevant.
- kenjackson 16y agoAbsolutely. I meant XBox planning proper, but you're right, this paranoia goes back as MS also had WebTV in the 90s as well (I don't recall Sony's, but I'm not surprised that they had one).
- AaronI 16y agoSony's WebTV was a set-top box (Phillips produced them as well) for WebTV Networks, Inc. Microsoft later bought WebTV Networks in '98.
- c2 16y agoIf anything MS mis-calculated with XBOX, thinking Sony was the threat in 2000, but the real threat was Apple. Now it's 2010 and the money is not in the living room (and it never was really), it's in mobile.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoA false dichotomy, it's in both. Home entertainment in the form of music, tv, and video games is a massive industry. Just because mobile is new and hot doesn't mean it defines the extent of the known business universe. Ignoring a multi-billion dollar market for the sake of intellectual simplicity is the epitome of zealotry.
- c2 16y agoWell there's money everywhere - groceries is a 100 billion dollar industry too, I don't think it's the "epitome of zealotry" for MS to ignore groceries. Mobile wasn't exactly a hot industry 10 years ago. It's the job of a hundred billion dollar company like MS to make big investments in billion dollar markets, sure, but I don't think there's any denying Xbox was a miscalculation on MS's part. See the market caps of Apple and MS now for lessons learned.
- jsnell 16y ago10 years ago mobile was an incredibly hot industry. In December 2000 the market cap of Nokia was around 200 billion, roughly comparable to the likes of Intel or Microsoft. Just a few months before telecoms had bled themselves dry in the German 3G frequency auction, seriously believing that the rights were worth tens of billions.
- c2 16y agoShould have quantified my statement, mobile software wasn't hot 10 years ago.
- twp 16y ago> Some articles make you stupider for having read them. This is one of them. It is full of nice sounding misinformation that you'd be better off forgetting. You make this sweeping statement but do not explain it beyond suggesting that a couple of details may be incorrect. Please provide justification that the central argument of the article is incorrect.
- btilly 16y agoA couple of details?? Go read the article carefully. The "details" I criticized include every significant supporting example offered. The fact that the article got them all wrong should make you suspicious of the grandiose reasoning that they were meant to support. In short there is no evidence that having cash makes companies stupid. Companies with cash should be doing a certain amount of experimentations with it. They should experiment with projects outside of their core area. And the fact that it isn't obvious to you why they are doing something doesn't mean that they don't have a good reason to do it.
- barrkel 16y agoI believe the over-investment in consoles (by MS and others, but amped up in large part because of MS) has largely killed the PC gaming market, and the death of the PC gaming market is what's killing Windows in the consumer computing space; it's the last major "sticky" item keeping people back from switching platforms. And where the consumers go, businesses will soon follow.