2 ms·
1. Which part of the discussion were not mature? 2. The situation is not loophole left by the British. But it was specifically left in place so the one country
by ksec 7y ago
1. Which part of the discussion were not mature?
2. The situation is not loophole left by the British. But it was specifically left in place so the one country two system would work for the next ( then ) 50 years. To guarantee the certain freedom of the Hong Kong people which was clearly listed out in the Sino-British Joint Declaration.
3. It is not a Riot. ( I am sorry but that has to be one of the most insulting thing ever said ) No one started a Riot, What was once, one of the most peaceful protest. by 1M people, was fired with Rubber Bullet and Later Metal Bullet to eyes and head shot ( Both in ER ), Along with Tear Gas with NO Prior warning, Against a group of people with bare hands and no weapon.
- luckylion 7y ago> 1. Which part of the discussion were not mature? For my personal taste: the "I don't agree with this opinion so I will downvote this comment instead of replying with an argument" part that many users engage in. I see two explanations: infantile "NO NO NO" and malicious "if I downvote this, it will be buried and fewer others will see it". Given the design of the voting and flagging system and the fact that it's not discouraged, it appears that this is a desired behavior.
- darkpuma 7y ago> "I don't agree with this opinion so I will downvote this comment" If that bothers you, then HN is not the site for you. Downvotes for disagreeing has received the thumb of approval from PG[0]. Upvotes are for agree and downvotes are for disagree. On reddit people like to pretend otherwise (even though it's true in practice there as well), but here on HN there are no bones about it. [0] one example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=658683 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=658683
- NotPaidToPost 7y agoHence the groupthink we see all the time... Not least on such a topic which is 'owned' by extremists who will not tolerate even a shred of non-conformity. It's hypocrisy when mods say otherwise.
- darkpuma 7y agoI'm not saying it's a great system that never goes wrong, but with the seal of approval from PG you're swimming against the tide if you're trying to change how people vote on HN.
- luckylion 7y agoThanks, that explains it, I suppose. I try not to let myself be bothered by hyper-tribalism too much, but it does put the good parts in perspective for me.
- marcinzm 7y agoThe third option is always "I consider this post's argument so stupid it's not worth my time replying to as it shows the poster is incapable of intelligent discussion on this issue." My response to the poster explains why in my opinion these comments fall into this category.
- NotPaidToPost 7y agoDo you really, seriously think that posting such a comment full of gratuitous insults when you have your professional website in your bio is a good idea? Because if we're on the topic of stupidity... Projecting such an unprofessional, rude, and aggressive behaviour so casually is quite something. This is shocking.
- marcinzm 7y agoI should care why exactly? Do you plan to stalk me? Email my boss that I insulted someone online? If you care so much about a silly internet argument then I honestly feel sad for you. edit: Since you decided to edit your comment, I'll add that this isn't a professional venue. If people don't understand the distinction between professional and casual environments (or that people have different ways of acting based on situation) then I'm glad they don't want to associate with me as a result.
- Spare_account 7y agoYou're feeding a troll. It would have been better to walk away a few comments ago.
- luckylion 7y agoPossible, but I do personally rule that out, as the downvotes are very selective.
- ksec 7y agoIt is not about disagreeing per se, it is just plain wrong. 2 + 2 will never be 22, doesn't matter how you spin it. ( Edit, Ok may be in Javascript ) He made a statement, about not being able to put trial in the same country, I also made a statement about it is a future not a bug. And the reply I got was discussion were not mature. Had the first sentence been a question as to why, you cant have the trial inside the own country, I would have replied about one country two system. But since he made a statement, I presume he does understand the topic on a certain level. May be that was my wrong assumption. ( Not to mention the article linked explains the fear of doing so )
- luckylion 7y ago> And the reply I got was discussion were not mature. I believe, and his further comments strengthen my belief, that this wasn't aimed at your comment, but at the fact that he got mass downvoted. That has since changed considerably, as it tends to do when it's highlighted. The counts are not public, but at the time I wrote my comment, his was practically background-colored.