7 ms·
>>What I don't understand is how people can be against the death penalty but yet be totally OK with locking people up for the rest of their lives. So I'm one o
by gambiting 7y ago
>>What I don't understand is how people can be against the death penalty but yet be totally OK with locking people up for the rest of their lives.
So I'm one of those people. It's simple really - death penalty is permanent, while life imprisonment isn't. Yes it sucks that sometimes we might have to release someone who spent 30 years falsely imprisoned - but it's sure a hell lot better than finding out that there is no one to release because the person was executed a decade ago. And secondly, I just don't see any need to execute people, the risk vs reward is not worth it.
- gzu 7y agoSomeone consciously chose to permanently end another’s life. There has to be decisions made.
- arethuza 7y agoWell, if the legal system was completely infallible in deciding who is guilty then that might be an argument. But I'm not aware of any legal system in any country that can make that particular claim.
- mattkrause 7y agoThe actual murderers chose. The people accidentally mistaken for murderers didn’t choose anything at all.
- cobbzilla 7y agoIn theory, if applied flawlessly, maybe nothing is wrong with the permanence of the death penalty. In practice, mistakes are made, regularly, and these mistakes are distributed unevenly, such that the poor and minorities suffer the most. The many wrongful deaths at the hands of the government is a good reason to be skeptical of arguments which assume the death penalty can be applied perfectly. It can’t.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago> In cases where it’s black and white with extreme evidence why even allow them to continue living on everyone’s dime. Because the cost of putting them to death using a system that has sufficient checks to (mostly) prevent innocent people from being executed (i.e. the current system, if you believe it works) is greater than the cost of imprisoning people for life.
- umvi 7y agoWell that just means the current system needs some changes. Just because that's the way it currently is doesn't mean that's the way it always has to be or always was. Some laws and policies may need to change, but treating this like an immutable fact is like being content with a super inefficient piece of code that's bottlenecking your application.
- Majestic121 7y agoThere's no such thing as a black and white case. For a simple counter example, you can look up the Outreau case : 12 people were accused of raping and videotaping children, with multiple testimonies. And 5 years later, the majority of them were found to be actually innocent. If death penalty was a thing in France, they would have got it for sure, as it was a very emotionnal case at the time. You can also check the movie 12 Angry Men, which is a work of fiction obviously, but still very relevant on why counting on 'black and white cases with extreme evidence' is simply wishful thinking, and will lead to innocent people being killed
- tomatocracy 7y agoThe case of Timothy Evans, who was wrongfully convicted and hanged in the 1950s in the UK (classic case of him being in the wrong place at the wrong time) is even more appropriate. After his execution the actual killer (a serial killer) went on to kill several other women. It was highly influential in the eventual abolition of the death penalty in the UK in the 1960s.
- ionised 7y agoAnd you want to hold that up as something immoral by...repeating it?
- luckylion 7y ago> Yes it sucks that sometimes we might have to release someone who spent 30 years falsely imprisoned - but it's sure a hell lot better than finding out that there is no one to release because the person was executed a decade ago. For society's conscience, certainly. For the prisoner, I'd say it depends. I suppose most will agree that a swift death would be preferable to 65 years of extreme torture with a "sorry, you're free to go" in the end. It comes down to whether long term imprisonment, especially solitary confinement, is close enough to torture. Some prisoners apparently prefer death, the suicide rate is much higher than that of the general population, and iirc, quite a few prisoners dropped their appeals and asked to be executed, likely because they prefer a horrible end to never ending horror.
- Fjolsvith 7y agoAt least the prisoner still has a choice he can make.
- mcguire 7y ago"Extreme torture"?
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoMany death row prisoners spend years in solitary confinement, and are driven insane in the process.
- luckylion 7y agoIn a hypothetical scenario, imagine whatever torture you consider the absolute most cruel. Would you prefer somebody suffer that torture for 50 years or be killed tomorrow? If you choose the latter, we've established that death can be a preferable alternative to otherwise horrible circumstances. I'm not saying that imprisonment is the most extreme torture imaginable, but it's probably not the best thing ever either. It's somewhere in between, likely closer to the torture end of the scale. If and where you draw the line between "this is fine" and "no person shall suffer like that for decades, no matter what they may have done, ending their life is the humane thing to do" is up to you.
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- umvi 7y ago> It's simple really - death penalty is permanent, while life imprisonment isn't. Death being permanent is a feature, not a bug. Is it possible that evil people can continue to negatively influence society from prison? Or even continue to commit heinous crimes in prison? I'd say this scenario happens much more often than killing an innocent. For example, organized crime. If you don't kill organized crime leaders, they continue to spread their secret oaths among other prisoners and continue to manage affairs even outside of prison via comm links. I agree that it's bad to kill innocents, but I think with the right policy and rigor, we could make the death penalty an efficient and painless process that has an extremely low false positive rate. In my mind it's like "yeah, we save the extremely rare false positive at the expense of allowing all the non-false positives to continue to spread and propagate evil for decades"
- QuotedForTruth 7y agoWhat "false positive rate" is acceptable to you? And shouldn't we refer to it for what it is: a "innocent people murdered by the state rate"? For me personally, 0 is the only acceptable number. The only way to get that is to end the death penalty.
- umvi 7y ago> For me personally, 0 is the only acceptable number. But why? Surely you must acknowledge that the "innocent people murdered by the state rate" is inversely proportional to the "innocent people murdered by criminals who should have been put to death but weren't rate"? This latter rate includes prison murders, calling/paying for hits from prison, influencing copycat killers, being released and then killing again, etc. So basically you are trading one form of innocent death for another (not to mention introducing a host of other negative effects to society by allowing truly evil people to interact with people in said society). For me, death penalty is acceptable as long as the "innocent people murdered by the state rate" is less than the "innocent people murdered by criminals who should have been put to death but weren't rate".
- fzeroracer 7y ago
- __s 7y agoWhat if the prisoner states they'd prefer the death penalty? ie execution becomes assisted suicide for life sentenced prisoners
- saagarjha 7y agoThat's a choice that the prisoner has, rather than one that the legal system makes.
- lisper 7y ago> death penalty is permanent, while life imprisonment isn't I think the word you're looking for here is "irreversible", not "permanent." Life imprisonment is, by definition, permanent. And yes, you can "reverse" life in prison by setting the prisoner free. But what you can't so easily reverse is the psychological damage done by the false imprisonment.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoYou can certainly mitigate and compensate in cases of false prosecution. This doesn't usually happen, but it could. And it's still less irreversible - to them, and to family and friends - than killing them.
- m-p-3 7y agoYou can give monetary compensation (like that's gonna fix it all, but that's another debate) to a living person.
- lisper 7y agoYes, of course. You can also give monetary compensation to a dead person's family. Whether either option actually makes things right is debatable.
- ionised 7y agoIt doesn't make things right. Nothing ever will, but it's better than the alternative.
- lisper 7y agoDepends on which alternative you're talking about. One alternative is not to execute people or lock them up in inhumane conditions at all (the Norwegians do this). It's not at all clear to me that writing checks when you get it wrong is better.