4 ms·
What, again? With so many going to, already at, or already been to Mars, it seems like they should be able spare a probe for Venus. Mars will never be a place
by ncmncm 7y ago
What, again?
With so many going to, already at, or already been to Mars, it seems like they should be able spare a probe for Venus.
Mars will never be a place anyone sane would want to be. But Cloud City floating 50 miles above Venus! Who could resist?
- azernik 7y agoCloud City would have no access to raw materials for ISRU, and still have to deal with (low-pressure-gradient) sealing and wind forces. In terms of engineering, easier to build a self-contained environment in a place where the only environmental interactions are heat loss and some dust, and where you can use local materials to make oxygen, concrete, and metals.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> Cloud City would have no access to raw materials for ISRU Arguably, it would, it would just require the collector to take a dip in the denser parts of the atmosphere. It might be tricky though, and generally the less moving parts a misson has, the better.
- jacobush 7y agoWhat worries me about Cloud City is the sulfuric acid gas in the atmosphere. Is it so hard to handle as I imagine?
- ncmncm 7y agoConcentrated sulfuric acid is shipped freely in polyethylene bottles. Polyethylene is just carbon, hydrogen and oxygen, all available at altitude.
- ncmncm 7y agoCloud City has easy access to unlimited amounts of carbon, oxygen, hydrogen, and sulfur, and plenty of solar energy. Balloons dipping lower could pick up other needed trace materials. Balloons don't need to deal with wind forces. They go where the air goes. More important, though, is that on Mars you're in Nowheresville. Cold, dusty, airless, dim, with possibly unhealthily-low gravity.
- ryanmercer 7y ago> it seems like they should be able spare a probe for Venus. Venus is hard unless you want to just stay in orbit. Surface temperature that's steady right around 872F (tin melts at 449.4F, lead at 621F, zinc at 787F) and a surface pressure that is equivalent to being under 3000 feet of water. Sure, something in orbit over Venus could do some mapping and stuff but meh, Mars could have harbored life like we find on Earth now at some point in its past, we can hang out for months or years taking photos from orbit and the ground, on the ground missions can last months or years instead of hours (Venera 12 sent data back for 110 minutes, it could have for longer but was out of range of its orbiter after 110 mimutes) or days that evne modern equipment would be able to survive before you started having multiple failures. Best case you'd have to land something akin to a submarine with expendable coolant and buy some time as you consumed coolant but realistically you aren't going to get more than a couple of days if that on the surface. Something like a balloon is just as likely to fail as it is to succeed given we have no way to realistically test one before sending it and even then, it's still going to collect very limited amount of data, not much more than the Russians already collected via the various Venera missions.