4 ms·
This makes no sense to me. There is no reasonable reality where Sprint becomes a healthy competitive force in the US as a standalone business.
by scarface74 7y ago
This makes no sense to me. There is no reasonable reality where Sprint becomes a healthy competitive force in the US as a standalone business.
- colinbartlett 7y agoInstead of approving this merger, is there another way the government could encourage competition? Perhaps break up the larger carriers or some how promote new upstart competition? Your statement sounds correct but I don’t exactly like the reality.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoManage the cell tower infrastructure and spectrum themselves through a non profit GSE (government sponsored entity) (think ISO grid operators for electric grids) and make every commercial provider an MVNO stakeholder. Similar to a municipality owning the last mile fiber to the house, and any provider can provide you service with a quick patch cable or VLAN change at the central office/colo facility. Running a nationwide cellular network is expensive and complicated AF. You have to provide a level playing field if you want to enable competition without needing hundreds of millions of dollars to start up.
- clairity 7y agowith 4G finally getting fast enough (along with the low latency promises of 5G), i think we're almost at the point where what you propose might make sense. before this, wireless tech/infrastructure just wasn't good enough, and needed continuing investment to improve. now that we're over the hump, a GSE can begin buying up the 4G infrastructure and leaving operations/service to the carriers. since there are 4 national and some regional carriers, you could even divvy the duplicative infrastructure up between state and federal GSEs, much like state and federal highways. then you'd have some semblance of competition that would keep the infrastructure from just crumbling away from political/bureaucratic neglect.
- JoshTriplett 7y agoCompetition between carriers has partly driven the widespread availability of coverage. Several carriers compete on the basis of their coverage. A government-funded entity seems highly unlikely to provide optimal coverage, or to do so in a cost-efficient manner.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 7y agoI'm not categorically against government-run solutions. But the cellular market isn't so obviously broken that a government-run system has any hope of being better. U.S. market concentration in cellular is less than for shipping, ecommerce, and soft drinks, and a lot less than for mobile operating systems, search, or social media. Verizon and AT&T's combined market share of about 68% is about the same as Apple and Samsung's combined share of the U.S. smart phone market.
- theturtletalks 7y agoI don’t see how. Most of the small carriers piggyback off the big 4 networks anyways.
- scarface74 7y agoBreaking up the carriers would be worse for consumers. Every carrier now has some semblance of “nationwide” coverage.
- iscrewyou 7y agoBreak them up by region? With ability to use each other’s equipment? Idk, I’m shooting in the dark.
- scarface74 7y agoYeah I know.... I guess you could enforce roaming agreements like they do in the EU(?) but then you still would have carriers having to negotiate with each other when one carrier has more external roaming traffic with the other - like Internet peering arrangements. I don’t have a strong emotional opinion either way. Just trying to come up with pros and cons.
- notSupplied 7y agoBreakup by region would not increase competition from the perspective of most consumers. They would have the same number of options.
- baroffoos 7y agoGovernment owned infrastructure that anyone can rent space on. That way there is minimal startup costs.
- rhino369 7y agoIf we did that 30 years ago, we’d have really affordable GPRS systems. We can’t even upgrade bridges and dams.
- mateo- 7y agodo...do we want GPRS?
- jaredklewis 7y agoThat's the parent's point. If the government owned the wireless infrastructure, that infrastructure would be in the same state as our dams and bridges (i.e. not good).
- baroffoos 7y agoObviously your government has to not be a disaster before this will work.
- rayiner 7y agoFun fact: Maryland's transit agency recently moved to diesel technology for its next generation of commuter train locomotives. The railroads in this area were first electrified more than a century ago, and most of the last several generations of locomotives were electric. But the overhead catenary is in bad shape, and some lines have stops that haven't been electrified. Maryland apparently believes that, over the 20-30 year service life of these locomotives, the infrastructure is likely to deteriorate further (to 19th century levels), instead of improve, such that diesel is the smarter option.
- kurczynski 7y agoThat's what people said when AT&T tried to buy T-Mobile.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoCingular buying ATT Wireless? Sure no problem.
- trimbo 7y agoBoth were still somewhat regional, and that acquisition made a national carrier out of it. Edit: found a spectrum map reportedly from the acquisition https://www.howardforums.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=88817&d=1358188573 https://www.howardforums.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=888...
- scarface74 7y agoAnd AT&T paid T-mobile $6 billion in cash and spectrum afterwards because of the failed merger.
- megablast 7y agoT-Mobile was going to crap before its failed merger to ATT. It would be stupid to think Sprint can't turn itself around either.
- scarface74 7y agoT-mobile “turned itself around” partially because of the $6 billion that AT&T had to pay https://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/12/20/att-and-t-mobile-whats-2-billion-among-friends/ https://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/12/20/att-and-t-mobile-wha... Also, T-mobile was hurting because it was the last major carrier that didn’t have the iPhone.
- mdasen 7y agoT-Mobile also merged with MetroPCS after the failed AT&T merger which was key for their resurgence. T-Mobile's turnaround had a bunch of facets. 1) Increased spectrum. In 2011, T-Mobile didn't have the spectrum to launch a competitive LTE network. AT&T had to divest spectrum to T-Mobile as part of the breakup and they gained spectrum through their merger with MetroPCS giving them 20MHz of new spectrum. 20MHz of new spectrum is an LTE network right there. In some ways, AT&T's decision to offer spectrum as part of the breakup fee might have pushed the FCC to deny the merger. "T-Mobile can't compete due to its spectrum position...which would improve if you denied this merger and might put them in a position to compete." 2) Increased customers. MetroPCS added 28% more customers, 26% more revenue, and 29% more EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization). In an industry that relies a lot on scale, that's pretty important. It moved T-Mobile from a very distant 4th place where Sprint was 61% larger to a much closer 4th where Sprint was only 21% larger. 3) Finances. T-Mobile's finances were a lot better than Sprint's and Deutsche Telekom reduced T-Mobile USA's debt as part of the MetroPCS merger by $3.8B. That meant that the new T-Mobile had a solid footing to go forth. Sprint, on the other hand, is getting crushed by debt. T-Mobile's net debt in 2013 (when they started making their comeback) was $15.3B over 44M customers or about $348 per customer. Sprint's debt is $32.9B over 54.5M customers or about $604 per customer. A lot of that debt is coming due over the next couple years. If Sprint is paying that debt and doesn't have the money to invest in 5G, it's hard to make a turnaround. Sprint has $27.6B in debt maturing from 2019 through 2023 (5 years). That's going to make it hard for Sprint to invest in its network during critical years for 5G deployment. They'll be competing against a T-Mobile that can get loans at better rates and has about half the debt Sprint has on a per-customer basis. T-Mobile is profitable and has revenues about 32% higher than Sprint. 4) Timing. T-Mobile launched the Un-carrier while customers were still making up their minds about LTE and hit the ground running fast. They announced targets for LTE coverage and blew past them inspiring consumer confidence. They broke new ground on pricing and features offering a more consumer-friendly approach to wireless - no contracts, trading in phones for upgrades, free international roaming, paying off ETFs to get switchers, music streaming that didn't use data, video that didn't use data, and finally unlimited. Likewise, T-Mobile was going up against an AT&T and Verizon that were only two companies and had become very anti-consumer and very unfriendly. Today, the timing isn't there for Sprint to do the same. AT&T and Verizon were broken by T-Mobile. They now offer unlimited and while they might not be the best deal, they make sure to remain competitive. Likewise, Sprint would have to compete against three strong companies instead of just two. That's a much harder proposition. These are three companies with way more customers. T-Mobile is now 50% larger than Sprint. These are three companies with more revenue and profits to invest in their networks. These are three companies with more low-band spectrum to provide broad coverage. These are three companies that aren't under crushing debt. 5) Spectrum Mix. Ultimately, Sprint's assets are different from the other three companies. Low-band spectrum covers a larger area and provides broad, reliable coverage. The other three carriers have 3-5x more than Sprint. Mid-band spectrum was used to supplement that for greater capacity and the other carriers have about double what Sprint has. Then Sprint has a lot of high-band 2.5GHz spectrum that doesn't cover as much area. Clearwire and Sprint have been trying to use that spectrum for over a decade and it's not fruitless or anything, but it's unclear whether that spectrum will provide compelling mobile service that will truly compete. Now, that spectrum could be quite useful for 5G. However, Sprint doesn't have the finances to go on a huge spending spree to add more cell sites (and they have far fewer than the other three) and mobile use still might need more low and mid-band spectrum than Sprint has to create a robust network that doesn't feel patchy. -- I think it's easy to say that Sprint could do what T-Mobile did. However, I think there are key differences. T-Mobile changed its possible future by adding 20MHz of new spectrum (increasing its total spectrum by 38%). The addition of MetroPCS customers meant that Sprint was only 21% larger while T-Mobile stands at 50% larger than Sprint today (and that gap is growing as T-Mobile adds millions of customers each year). T-Mobile's finances were simply so much better. They were barely profitable, but profitable with so much less debt. The timing was right to disrupt the market as AT&T and Verizon kept making increasingly consumer-hostile moves and jacked up prices a lot, but that isn't the market Sprint faces today. Finally, it might just be that Sprint's spectrum mix makes it hard to create a network that customers love. It's certainly possible that Sprint could turn itself around, but T-Mobile was in a very different situation when it launched its comeback.
- Despegar 7y agoIt makes plenty of sense. The goal is to not let the number of wireless carriers go from 4 to 3. If Sprint is not viable then they'll file for bankruptcy and then Charter or Comcast (or both of them together in a JV) will probably pick up the assets.
- scarface74 7y agoWhat would the motto be for Comcast+Sprint? “The cellular company with the worse customer service has combined with the cable company you hate....” More importantly do we really want a media company owning a cellular company? Shouldn’t we be trying to get away from media companies merging with communication providers. Comcast owns NBC/Universal.