3 ms·
This appears to be a glorified services ad posing as an open source project. The crux of desktop automation isn't that you can do the easy things, but that you
by ethbro 7y ago
This appears to be a glorified services ad posing as an open source project.
The crux of desktop automation isn't that you can do the easy things, but that you have a way of doing everything. A 99% automated process with one manual step in the middle is still pretty useless.
Which is the reason the major vendors tend to have been in business for 10+ years. Because it's not about wrapping the Windows Active Accessibility API (or whatever they're calling it now) and patting yourself on the back.
It's about supporting, out of the box, that VB6 app with a hacked-in async UI interaction using a custom grid with a combo box in it.
And it's about exposing it in a way that, ideally, a business use familiar with Visio-only can kludge together 85% of the logic.
In short, this looks like all those times HN opines on {biology / rocketry / etc} and offers that "If they just ____, it would all be easy."
- cgio 7y agoHave you worked with major vendor solutions? They don’t do much more than wrapping the accessibility api and in some cases clumsily so. They have surface automation on top, but if you end up using it you are already in a bad place automation wise.
- ethbro 7y agoI've worked with all of the top 5 products in the space at various times. And no, they don't. Automation Anywhere is the least compatible of the bunch, and even it includes custom translators.