6 ms·
Assuming that you're completely legit and utterly competent, there's still a big security problem here: it's encouraging people to put their PII and CC info int
by neilv 7y ago
Assuming that you're completely legit and utterly competent, there's still a big security problem here: it's encouraging people to put their PII and CC info into arbitrary Web sites.
On top of that, it's further identifying them as both Chase CC holders and receptive to scams, qualifying them as leads for further phishing/scamming.
- zbruhnke 7y agoUnfortunately this is the problem that Chase created ... we give users a way to download a form letter instead, but were just trying to make it as easy as possible for customers to opt out if they would like to do so
- lozenge 7y agoYou're teaching users it's OK to give out their account information "sometimes". Which is much less secure than "never".
- ralph84 7y agoI give out my credit card number hundreds of times per year. Credit cards wouldn't be very useful if you never gave them out.
- WoahNoun 7y agoAn ecommerce site has a merchant agreement with a payment processor to comply with PCI DSS. This does not. It is in no way similar.
- zbruhnke 7y agoFYI we are complying with PCI DSS when you use this site - you can read details in the FAQ
- snazz 7y agoDo we have proof of that? I think the fact that we're taking your word for everything so far is the source of the discomfort here.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoSort of humorous comment, as PCI DSS is self assessment and attestation of compliance. If OP states they’ve met their burden, that’s all that’s required at their scale.
- snazz 7y agoReally? I evidently know nothing of the matter, but you're saying that the auditors only get involved when they become a larger operation?
- toomuchtodo 7y agoYep. Card networks can also unilaterally decide your level. https://www.pcicomplianceguide.org/faq/#4 https://www.pcicomplianceguide.org/faq/#4 Disclaimer: I work in governance/risk/compliance, but have not performed PCI compliance work in the last several years.
- gowld 7y agoPCI DSS assessments are signed by natural persons, not arbitrary HTML content.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 7y agoNatural persons who are rarely, if ever, pursued when breaches occur.
- craftyguy 7y ago
- laughinghan 7y agoI give out my credit card number hundreds of times per year to websites that I have not verified have a merchant agreement with a payment processor to comply with PCI DSS. In terms of what users are taught (which is plainly the context of the comment you are replying to), this website is identical to ecommerce sites.
- travisjungroth 7y agoWhat about buying things? This is the same info that would go in an order form.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gricardo99 7y ago>we give users a way to download a form letter instead But you don't just let them download it. You make them give you their email address first. Edit: Haha! No wait, you have to click through two levels of "Don't want to give us your info? Click here to get the letter". The first one asks for you email, only after the second do you actually get the letter. Why? They already said "dont want to...". Just give it to them! Edit2: Also the form letter, prepopulated with the Chase customer service P.O. box address, is another scam pitfall. Anyone using this kind of form letter should always check the address with the financial institution before sending any forms, especially that include PII/financial information.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> The first one asks for you email, only after the second do you actually get the letter. They're pretty clearly trying to collect email addresses through this campaign. I'm okay with that. My email address isn't exactly private, and this site is going to pay to mail physical letters for me. > Also the form letter, prepopulated with the Chase customer service P.O. box address, is another scam pitfall. Anyone using this kind of form letter should always check the address with the financial institution before sending any forms, especially that include PII/financial information. Is the address fradulent? If so, please tell us. If not, I don’t see the concern.
- gricardo99 7y ago>I don’t see the concern. really? No concern downloading a form letter from some web site and mailing PII/account information to the address they provided? Call me paranoid, but that kind of behavior is just waiting to run into a scam. My point was not about the address, it was about general wariness of scams. No different than always calling your financial institution using a valid/known number, rather than a number provided to you by a voicemail/email/letter.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoYou need to consider the two possible evils. If I don't use this website, there is a 100% chance I will "agree" to binding arbitration. I know myself. There is absolutely no way I am going to print, fill out, and mail in a paper form. Is this website a perfect solution? No, but I don't see a better option under the circumstances, and from what I can tell, the people running it are doing the right things within the confines of what is necessary for their solution to work. If that's not the case, criticize away, and certainly let us know if you have a clear reason to believe this specific project is a scam. But keep the goal in mind. It certainly set off some alarm bells for me, but when I read through the site it all made sense.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Sephr 7y agoIs the form letter generated on the client-side?
- craftyguy 7y agoCollecting/storing credit card numbers, names, and addresses is creating a whole new problem for users.
- briandear 7y agoChase didn’t set up a website asking for account numbers. So how did Chase create this problem? What exactly have they done wrong? If someone disagrees with the policy, they can opt-out, so what’s the problem that causes someone to need to give a bank account number to a random website? Why not just disclose in big letters what the site is all about: lead generation for a law firm? This isn’t some kind of “we like to help people,” project any more than ambulance chasers seek “justice.” There is a place for lawsuits certainly, but let’s not pretend this is about “helping,” it’s about lead generation.
- saagarjha 7y agoNote that there is a PDF for those who don't want to enter their information: https://www.chaseoptout.com/ChaseOptOut.pdf https://www.chaseoptout.com/ChaseOptOut.pdf
- neilv 7y agoI don't see how that's relevant to what I said. The problem I was citing was the encouragement to put this info into a Web form on an arbitrary site. You should always be discouraging that.
- augbog 7y agoWell you just print the form and mail it yourself. What's the issue? Seems relevant to me.
- travisjungroth 7y agoThese people are doing A. A is bad and they should stop. But they also do B! Doesn’t matter. A is bad.
- glennpratt 7y agoThis is not constructive feedback; explain your solution and why you feel the trade-offs you prefer are better.
- monksy 7y agoIt's even worse than that. If they try to authenticate you on the phone. They'll suggest calling you back, and they don't know what phone number they'll be calling you from. They literally ask for their customers to pick up the phone from unknown numbers and give your bank details.
- stallmanite 7y agoHow does this shit get thought up? Their security team was cool with this? Mind boggling
- bmer 7y agoIANAL, so can someone help me understand how bullet proof their privacy policy is (https://www.chaseoptout.com/PrivacyPolicy.pdf https://www.chaseoptout.com/PrivacyPolicy.pdf)? It seems to me that it's pretty flimsy? In particular: > To conduct research and to improve and promote our services . We use the information wecollect to conduct research and to improve or enhance and promote our Services. Both promotion and research are pretty damn broad terms, right?
- _bxg1 7y agoOh dang. So this whole thing is just a big data grab. Even if they aren't going to make fraudulent charges, that's a clear ulterior motive.
- zbruhnke 7y agonot at all! We explicity ask if you want to opt in to future communications on our form - we are NOT using them to communicate with users if they do not opt in.
- mondoshawan 7y agoThen give the user the letter up front instead of hiding it in small text. This site has NO written all over it!
- zbruhnke 7y agosorry you feel that way? We did put a fair amount of effort (and are spending our own dollars to mail the letters) so I don't think we are doing anything too unreasonable
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lancesells 7y agoSo if I was to opt-out of communications does that mean you'll never upload my email address to Facebook or Google for advertising in the future?
- choppaface 7y agoYes but it’s your Chase account number. If it gets leaked through this service, Chase precipitated that leak through their unethical use of arbitration. Idk but I only have Chase through Amazon. Chase might get effed, but my Amazon account will probably always be fine.
- 3xblah 7y ago"And who even has stamps lying around anymore?" People who order stamps online? If the problem is writing the letter or stamps, then why not just send the user a postage-paid envelope, pre-addressed to Chase, with a generic letter that she can fill in with her personal information and deposit into the mail? You should now be wondering how this "service" can be "free". As someone else has figured out, this is a company that wants lists of Chase customers to which they can market their consumer arbitration-related services. This is interesting since the whole point of opting out here is that consumers want to avoid arbitration and reserve their rights to sue. Other websites are offering a more sensible solution for those who cannot be bothered to write a letter: templates for a simple letter a customer can just print out, fill in her information, sign and mail.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoIf you expect customers to print out a template, obtain postage, and mail it, your expectations are too high.
- 3xblah 7y agos/you/Chase/;s/your/Chase's/
- toomuchtodo 7y agoFor sure. If you don’t care, you don’t care. If you do care, you might use an online form but not print it out and mail it. Everyone here fearmongering this site is the enemy of good enough. Your credit card information is no more at risk than at a gas pump that possibly has a skimmer (and you’re not liable). Your PII has already been leaked by Equifax. Why give up even more rights by not opting out through a service that has taken reasonable precautionary measures for data protection?
- happytoexplain 7y agoDo you have a link? This is exactly what I want.