3 ms·
Sort of going off on a tangent to Backblaze's post. I know big enterprises still use a lot of LTO tape. But the total market worldwide for LTO drives and LTO ta
by walrus01 7y ago
Sort of going off on a tangent to Backblaze's post. I know big enterprises still use a lot of LTO tape. But the total market worldwide for LTO drives and LTO tapes (two manufacturers, total!) can't be very large compared to the number of spinning rust type hard drives that are manufactured yearly, and sold into distribution channels. Economy of scale matters a lot. If you can buy a product that's manufactured in the dozens of millions and piggyback on everyone else's purchases, it may be a better solution.
Backblaze's system architecture is fairly failure tolerant, so they use a huge number of "consumer" grade drives that would cause enterprise people to run away screaming. They're successful with it.
I know a number of people who have self built ZFS servers in the $2000 to $18,000 price range, who also use consumer grade drives with a failure rate no higher than the expensive $450 enterprise drives.
- jonatron 7y agoA small video production company I worked for used LTO tape for archiving footage, so it's not just big enterprise.
- walrus01 7y agoSmall sample size, but I consult on backend systems for post-production houses / special effects contractors in the Vancouver BC film industry, and tape is exceedingly rare.
- metabagel 7y agoAlso, there is only one manufacturer of LTO tape drives. IBM. The other companies ship OEM versions of the IBM drive.
- syshum 7y agoI have several ZFS Servers in my Homelab, using both consumers and gasp referb drives.... I do not have a higher drive failure rate in my homelab than the enterprise gear I manage daily at the end of the day the mechanical parts between the drives are very similar, the biggest difference if the firmware loads on the different types of drives.
- the-rc 7y agoYears ago, a vendor revealed that the largest buyer of tapes on the planet was Google, not some enterprise.
- slaymaker1907 7y agoI think where tape starts to have an edge is in long term storage, particularly for archival. You have to take into account that a tape sitting somewhere in a controlled environment will be readable for quite a long time compared to a hard disk.
- dfrage 7y ago> Backblaze's system architecture is fairly failure tolerant, so they use a huge number of "consumer" grade drives that would cause enterprise people to run away screaming. I think what would "cause enterprise people to run away screaming" is that your data is stored by them in only one data center, and they don't offer a S3 compatible API (although someone may have addressed the latter). Backblaze however correctly notes that if you really want redundancy, you get that from using two or more vendors. Tape is physically a lot more robust than hard drives, the single endurance advantage the latter have is better tolerance of environmental extremes, heat and humidity.