6 ms·
This is a fun design exercise, but a couple things really do stand out to me as useful. First, panels instead of windows -- a thousand times yes, please. Overl
by crazygringo 7y ago
This is a fun design exercise, but a couple things really do stand out to me as useful.
First, panels instead of windows -- a thousand times yes, please. Overlapping windows doesn't provide any benefit. Making everything either full-screen or splitting the screen is so much better. There's a reason so much software has moved to tabs and side panels instead of separate windows within the app.
Second:
> The desktop metaphor as the basis of computer interfaces is inefficient and outdated. Today, most of our data exists outsides of files and folders. The desktop worked great to get us started 40 years ago, but it was never built for the complexity and amount of work today.
I don't like the author's particular solution... but yes the idea of an actual "desktop" folder seems silly and antiquated now.
And it's about time that cloud content (whether file-based like Google Drive or content-based like Google Photos) got treated as a first-class citizen in the OS.
If the iOS Files app lets me treat my Google Drive as just another folder... why doesn't Finder? Why do I have to install third-party software for that?
- cesarb 7y ago> Overlapping windows doesn't provide any benefit. Just yesterday, I overlapped a tiny terminal window (resized to be very small and set to "always on top") showing the current disk space ("watch df") over the corner of a larger window which was doing a file transfer. While I agree that non-overlapping panels are better most of the time, sometimes overlapping can be useful. > treat my Google Drive as just another folder That illusion would fail quickly as soon as your network connection dropped. Non-local folders have fundamental differences to local folders and should be treated differently. (Local folders can be assumed to always be present unless manually removed, be fast, and unmetered; non-local folders can disappear and/or change at any time, can be slow and/or vary in speed, and might have a per-megabyte cost.)
- falcolas 7y ago> Overlapping windows doesn't provide any benefit. Another example: Overlapping my work windows over the Slack window. The red "you have new mention" indicator is a poor indicator for determining the importance of the mention; being able to see the channel it occurs in at a glance is very nice for prioritization. There's no real need to see the whole slack window.
- swordsmith 7y agoAnother example: When I work on laptops, I like to have my terminal/editor to be semi-transparent with design doc/browser underneath for quick reference.
- mhink 7y agoI think this is one application of the “minimized pane” example the article showed: applications still have a way to show more data than just an indicator. Alternatively, you could let panes be resized smaller than their “native width”, and get the same effect as overlapping.
- alpaca128 7y agoOh yes, the ability to pin a window to the top is one of the features I miss most on Windows. You don't need it every day but when you do it saves a ton of time and clicks.
- qu4z-2 7y agoAltDrag[0] provides this feature, among a few other useful tweaks (resize with win + right mouse button anywhere in the window). [0]: https://stefansundin.github.io/altdrag/ https://stefansundin.github.io/altdrag/
- mruts 7y agoFocus follows mouse obviates this feature. I'm not sure why it hasn't gained any popularity outside of certain Linux WMs.
- lottin 7y agoSpace on the screen is a limited resource and overlapping windows allow making a more efficient use of it.
- the_pwner224 7y agoOther users have mentioned situations where this is true (and I have run into them myself too). But tiling window managers + workspaces are just so much more efficient for almost all use cases. And they don't have to have a steep learning curve. I use KDE with the grid tiling plugin. When I open a window, it takes up the whole screen. Opening another window splits the screen in half vertically. They can be dragged as normal to swap positions. Opening a third window splits one window into two, horizontally. This goes up to a (configurable) 2x2 grid. There are only four basic keyboard shortcuts to remember: meta+F floats a window to make it not affect tiling; meta+T makes it tiled again. Floating is useful for small utilities like calculators or temporary status indicators; they always float above the tiled windows. meta+Q/E shrink/grow the current window, and the rest adjust size to fit (of course window borders can still be dragged and it works the same). Since every window is always visible, there is no need for a window list in the taskbar - mine only has the date/time, status icons for notifications, and the workspace pager (map). Virtual desktops are the last part. You obviously will want more than three windows. I use a 4x4 grid of 16 desktops; 4 total desktops is more practical for normal people. They are mapped to a 4x4 square of keys on my keyboard. A few windows for applications like email or IM have a permanent space on the bottom row of 4 desktops. Normally I stay in the top left desktop and move to adjacent ones once space starts running out on the primary one. The pager in the taskbar shows an overview of the grid. meta+WASD or arrow keys switches between them; holding ctrl moves the current window along to the other desktop. Oh, and meta+tab is like alt-tab but for workspaces. This maximizes screen space that can be used. In a floating WM like Windows/macOS, only maximized windows take up the full screen; every other window is smaller. Windows has a 2-pane L/R split builtin, which is a weak replication of my system. If you have three floating windows open, using all the screen real estate is a frustrating task of dragging windows by their titlebars and then using the thin borders to resize them. With my system they just magically appear into place; the only user input is to swap their positions or resize them. With floating WMs if you have more than 4 windows open you have to either: A) leave bits of windows visible behind the other, which takes up time to arrange the windows, or B) frequently focus on the taskbar and select windows, which is very inefficient Workspaces solve this well, especially when put in a grid instead of a row. Related things are just a single press of meta+WASD away, clustered in their own area in the grid.
- lisnake 7y agoCheckout PaperWM extension for Gnome Shell, it looks a lot like your description
- nkkollaw 7y ago> First, panels instead of windows -- a thousand times yes, please I don't know what OS you use, but putting windows side by side quickly can be easily done in all OSes I use, including macOS, Linux, Windows, and Android. What stops you from using this functionality?
- crazygringo 7y agoWell, with third-party tools for sure. But macOS certainly doesn't come with that. I've got to manually drag the windows and edges and everything.
- nkkollaw 7y ago> But macOS certainly doesn't come with that. I've got to manually drag the windows and edges and everything Keep the green maximize button pressed in the app you want on the left in split screen. On the right you'll see a list of apps. Click on the one you want on the right. This feature has been available for a while.
- crazygringo 7y agoThanks, but that's just split full-screen, which is limited to only 2 apps and also hides the menu bars (which I usually need when I'm working). macOS definitely does not come with a general way to tile applications.
- nkkollaw 7y agoI see.
- danielscrubs 7y agoYou’re not wrong but...it’s exactly what they show in the video.
- baud147258 7y agoNo need for third-party tools on Windows (at least in Windows 10)
- Tyr42 7y agoI have recently been working where I have around 5 windows open. Editor, Terminal, Documentation, Email, Browser with test profile. I've found that alt-tab hasn't been working the best for me, but what has worked is having mostly overlapping windows, with a bit sticking out that I can click on to pull it to the foreground. Maybe I should be assigning some keyboard shortcuts to pull up particular windows, but this works reasonably well, and is easy enough to adjust if I added a 6th window, or whatever.
- Too 7y agoWin+1,2,3,4,5... does what you ask for, in both Windows and Ubuntu. It follows the order of the apps on your task bar.
- megaremote 7y ago> Overlapping windows doesn't provide any benefit. Making everything either full-screen or splitting the screen is so much better. I disagree 100% and I hate people like you. Please, do not force this on users. I have about 10 programs running at once, all accessible because of the way they are partially stacked over each other.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- AmrMostafa 7y agoThe idea of panels can be realized today on Linux using a tiling window manager, and is superior in my opinion because it allows you to slice your screen as you see fit, has workspaces and you can have multipe windows in a single slice snd switch between them using a variety of wsys (tabs, etc)
- rocky1138 7y agoI agree with pretty much everything you've said except the part about overlapping windows. I find Sticky Previews immensely helpful in Windows and sorely miss it when using other operating systems. https://johnrockefeller.net/super-useful-windows-app-sticky-previews/ https://johnrockefeller.net/super-useful-windows-app-sticky-...
- baud147258 7y ago> First, panels instead of windows You can achieve some of it on Windows (10 and maybe 8) by snapping the windows to the sides of the desktop (with the mouse of Win key + arrows). And when you have two windows, both will resized at the same time