5 ms·
Usually you just use multiple keys - one USB-C in the MacBook, one tiny USB-A in the laptop and the built-in Titan key in the Pixel phone. You don't remove them
by izacus 7y ago
Usually you just use multiple keys - one USB-C in the MacBook, one tiny USB-A in the laptop and the built-in Titan key in the Pixel phone. You don't remove them.
- jiveturkey 7y agofew providers support enrolling multiple yubikeys into your account.
- cbhl 7y agoThis is true, and it is dangerous (once the key fails, folks get locked out). I don't use security keys with such providers. It would be nice if someone made a library that made incorporating Webauthn login into an app as simple as using django or Ruby on Rails or React to create a login form, so folks don't end up rolling their own and assuming that a user will have at most one yubikey. Failing that, you could do what Zeit does and rely on email providers' support for Security Keys (login by email link only).
- Operyl 7y agoWhich don't? For all the big major ones I've used U2F with, they've supported multiple keys for a while (or since introduction). It's practically a requirement in case you lose a key.. To name a few off the top of my head: Google, GitHub, Gitlab, Facebook, 1Password, etc.
- zippergz 7y agoVanguard (where my company has their 401k plan) is one I have encountered that only supports a single Yubikey.
- bitskits 7y agoNot sure when you last checked, Vanguard supports up to 4 security keys.
- zippergz 7y agoOh, great news, thanks for letting me know!
- PStamatiou 7y agoI just think Vanguard doesn't let you fully disable SMS though right? (but I only checked like a year ago..)
- lstamour 7y agoBefore this, both LastPass and 1Password said they supported U2F via Duo, but Duo only supported one key, so I could never use it.
- saltminer 7y agoMy college uses Duo and it has no such restriction, if you tried this recently and couldn't add more than 1, it is probably set by LastPass/1Password.
- lstamour 7y agoDuo Free used to have a restriction of one device, but it seems for U2F they now require one of their paid plans: https://duo.com/product/trusted-users/two-factor-authentication/authentication-methods/u2f https://duo.com/product/trusted-users/two-factor-authenticat...
- saltminer 7y agoI didn't even realize they had a free tier, makes sense.
- mclehman 7y agoIf that's the case, it must have changed at some point. Lastpass and Duo both support multiple U2F keys, and have for at least a couple of years. I have two keys registered with Duo for login at my school and also through Lastpass's non-Duo U2F support.
- cal5k 7y agoAWS only supports a single U2F key at the moment.
- abstractbarista 7y agoUsually you can use a TOTP backup method (Google Authenticator or similar). But don't actually use it. Just save the key to initialize it to a secure backup which can be accessed of your Yubikey is lost.
- jwr 7y agoAren't you effectively removing the second factor by keeping it permanently attached to each of your devices?
- jen729w 7y agoNot unless your attacker has physical access to the machine. You still have to touch the device to activate it each time. This still mitigates the most common MITM-type attacks: 1. Attacker instigates login via fake portal. 2. Attacker fools you in to entering your 6-digit OTP. 3. Attacker intercepts your valid OTP, combines with your stolen password, logs in to real site. This doesn’t work with a YubiKey or the equivalent because of the back-and-forward cryptographic signing. The request has to come from the website you’re logging in to, which it doesn’t in this scenario. It’s the weakness of part 2 above which we avoid here.
- jwr 7y agoWell, yes, that is exactly what I'm talking about. The biggest advantage of a physical second factor is that I can see if it has been stolen: I either have it with me, or I don't. By using multiple keys, you are effectively removing that advantage: someone could have one of your devices (e.g. your laptop while you're out for lunch) and would be able to make use of your second factor without you knowing.
- ithkuil 7y agoThat's true. But if the alternative is that people have to setup weaker fallback mechanisms (such as SMS verification) then I'm happy to pay that price.
- jen729w 7y agoWell if your primary concern is a local threat - which it absolutely is not for the vast majority of people - then you just have to be more careful with your keys. If you suspect someone might be actively trying to break in to your home, you wouldn’t leave your keys on your desk while you went to lunch.