4 ms·
By not having a config item for their search to return the real url. And, as in the main story, the AMP page bricking the link to the real url.
by tyingq 7y ago
By not having a config item for their search to return the real url.
And, as in the main story, the AMP page bricking the link to the real url.
- dcbadacd 7y agoThey're working on signed exchanges, you'll soon see the "real URL" of the content.
- tyingq 7y agoOn Chrome only. While still retaining mandatory Google controlled JavaScript in the page (which is what's broken in this story). Not sure why real url is in airquotes. It's an actual issue.
- qtplatypus 7y agoSo on chrome you will have the option of getting to the real url, on firefox and other browsers you can use plugins.
- tyingq 7y agoAnd hope Google hasn't borked up their js again, sure. Not sure there's an extension API that could make signed exchanges work either.
- JoshMnem 7y agoSigned exchanges are a terrible idea. They take control away from publishers and let large sites (AMP caches) control small sites. Google punishes web publishers with a traffic drop unless they allow Google to serve their websites from Google's servers and include Google's JavaScript. AMP, signed exchanges, and portals can't seriously be considered real standards.
- dcbadacd 7y agoWhich publishers is the control taken away? You're claiming news outlets have to be super afraid of punishment if they don't do AMP. That's empirically false, many news outlets dominate (or share the dominance) markets without doing any AMP. I don't necessarily like AMP, but claiming it's the (paraphrased) "worst thing after the black plague" is also dishonest, working on alternative solutions would be the right thing to do here.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoYou've hit upon the most absurd part of these complaints. There are so many people here complaining about AMP, and not one of them in the years of AMP threads on HN have ever offered an alternative design for instant loading web pages.
- JoshMnem 7y agoIt's really easy to get a 100 score on page speed with tools like Gatsby (and similar). People would implement faster pages if they could get in the carousel from it. For custom display in the SERPs, a neutral schema could be used. Publishers don't want to be forced into using "instant loading web pages" if it fundamentally breaks the nature of the WWW and takes control away from them and gives it to a few large companies (AMP caches).
- lern_too_spel 7y agoA 100 score is far from instant, which is what users want and what they get with non-open-web proprietary solutions like Facebook Instant Articles and Apple News. Publishers have to meet users where the users want, and AMP is easily the best of the options because by implementing it once, publishers provide instant loading through multiple link aggregators. If I want to write my own link aggregator, I don't need the clout of a FAANG to get publishers to do a data integration for instant loading pages — I can just implement an AMP cache and use the AMP pages they have already published. AMP levels the playing field.