3 ms·
Giving an explanation is fine but even as a SO user, I don't "get" it. It's just splitting a strong StackOverflow down into weaker parts. Why not a separate Rub
by petercooper 16y ago
Giving an explanation is fine but even as a SO user, I don't "get" it. It's just splitting a strong StackOverflow down into weaker parts. Why not a separate Ruby SE? One for dynamic languages? One for questions that involve networking? That's what tags are for.
Stated another way, the best Stack Overflow questions tend to have actual source code in the questions or answers.
That may be generally true, but isn't my experience. Those SO posts that get voted up the most on sites like HN and Reddit have tended to not be source based. These sorts of posts, say:
http://stackoverflow.com/questions/487258/plain-english-explanation-of-big-o/ http://stackoverflow.com/questions/487258/plain-english-expl...
http://stackoverflow.com/questions/448673/how-do-emulators-work-and-how-are-they-written http://stackoverflow.com/questions/448673/how-do-emulators-w...
- wladimir 16y agoI agree. Appears almost as if they are using divide and conquer tactics against their own user base. It used to be one large, easily searchable, interesting developer site now it is split into at least: - Programmers - AI - Gamedev ... As you can easily skip questions that don't interest you using keywords, I don't see the advantage of this...
- dagw 16y agoStack exchange recently got a huge cash investment and now they have to justify getting all the money with a growing user base. However most new stack exchange sites that I've looked at are pretty dead and empty, so to me it looks like they are cannibalizing Stack Overflow to try to seed Stack Exchange sites with content so they can show positive numbers to their investors.
- j_baker 16y agoIt's the age-old inclusionist vs deletionist battle. I think what they're trying to do is keep both sides happy by creating a vast network of sites with various purposes and then encouraging the deletionists to push questions to other sites rather than deleting them. Personally, I find it highly annoying but if it keeps interesting questions from getting closed then fine.
- petercooper 16y agoIn this case, there seems to be a subjective vs objective divide between the sites whereas the topics are the same (things like algorithms are mentioned explicitly in the good questions suggestions). Clearing that up in a way that satisifies even a minority will be tough and many will just end up scanning both sites (which is perhaps their goal, traffic wise).
- clojurerocks 16y agoTheres also the issue that the main site is like a one stop shop for all questions. Whereas the micro sites seem kind of pointless unless theres more to them. Like more ability to be social or something. Plus they all apparently have different designs which causes inconsistency and frankly headaches having to deal with all of it.